Analysis: Villain Recruitment for Simultaneous Schemes of Multiple Big Bads in My Hero Academia - Part 3

This analysis extends the recruitment dynamics from Parts 1 and 2, focusing on which villains from the provided document (Untitled document (78).pdf) would join the major big bads—All For One (AFO), Kai Chisaki (Overhaul), Flect Turn, Rikiya Yotsubashi (Re-Destro), Nine, and Valdo—in a scenario where they operate concurrently, pursuing their own agendas with one-sided alliances and inevitable betrayals. The document provides detailed information on Toxic Chainsaw, Takeshi Bushijima, Octo-Lover’s Brigade, Speed Villain, Thieving Hooligans, Dinosaur Villain, Grave Robber, Shop Thugs, Future Park Villains, Shoplifters, Madame Puppimil, Salaryman Villain, K3 Gang, Masked Robber, Gang of Thieves, Imposter Villains, and Wolfram. Due to the document being truncated at page 13 of 400, this analysis incorporates the provided pages and leverages prior knowledge from Parts 1 and 2, assuming the remaining pages describe additional minor villains or details consistent with My Hero Academia canon. The focus is on recruitment likelihood, considering each villain’s motivations, abilities, resources, and personality, as well as the big bads’ goals and leadership styles.

Recruitment Analysis by Big Bad

All For One (AFO)

Goals: AFO seeks global domination as a "Demon Lord," aiming to steal One For All (OFA) and consolidate power through Quirk theft, manipulation, and fear, as detailed in Parts 1 and 2.

Recruitment Style: AFO uses his genius intellect, vast resources (League of Villains, Nomu, Dr. Garaki), and Lie Detector Quirk to secure loyalty, offering power or protection while planning to betray recruits once their Quirks or utility are secured.

Likely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His infamy and ability to injure All Might make him a high-value target. AFO would offer enhanced Quirks or resources to lure him, planning to steal his powerful, unknown Quirk, as discussed in Part 2. Toxic Chainsaw’s ruthless nature aligns with AFO’s sadistic tendencies, but his independence risks early betrayal.

Speed Villain: His Super-Speed and Projectile Webbing are ideal for AFO’s hit-and-run tactics. AFO would exploit his pride, offering Quirk enhancements, but betray him due to his Fragile Speedster nature, as noted in Part 2.

Dinosaur Villain: His dinosaur-like Quirk (increased height and strength) makes him useful as muscle. AFO would recruit him as cannon fodder, betraying him after major battles, consistent with his use of minor villains in prior analyses.

Wolfram: AFO would ally with Wolfram to access the Quirk Amplifier, promising Nomu or funding. Wolfram’s greed aligns with AFO’s manipulative offers, but AFO would steal his Metal Manipulation and Muscle Augmentation Quirks, as outlined in Part 2.

K3 Gang: Their idolization of Stain makes them easy to manipulate with promises of infamy. AFO would use them as distractions against heroes or Overhaul, discarding them due to their reform potential, as seen in their canon Heel-Face Turn.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk could aid AFO’s operations (e.g., breaching hero defenses). AFO would recruit him for specific missions, betraying him once his Quirk is stolen or his utility ends.

Shop Thugs: As hired muscle, they align with AFO’s need for disposable fighters. AFO would use them to pressure heroes or rivals, betraying them to avoid long-term liabilities.

Future Park Villains: Their willingness to sabotage for profit makes them suitable for AFO’s schemes. AFO would fund their operations to disrupt heroes, betraying them once their role is fulfilled.

Shoplifters: Their stealth and disguise skills could serve AFO’s covert operations. AFO would recruit them for espionage, betraying them to eliminate loose ends.

Gang of Thieves: Their minor criminal activities make them ideal pawns for AFO’s distractions. AFO would use them against heroes, discarding them quickly.

Imposter Villains: Their deception skills (posing as manner school teachers) align with AFO’s manipulative tactics. AFO would recruit them for infiltration, betraying them after stealing their secrets or Quirks.

Unlikely Recruits:

Takeshi Bushijima: His non-malicious nature and desire to avoid harm clash with AFO’s cruelty. AFO might coerce him with a false promise to fix his Power Incontinence, but Takeshi’s moral core, as seen in his canon reform, makes defection likely.

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their niche animal rights focus is too small-scale for AFO’s global ambitions. He might arm them briefly to cause chaos but would discard them, as noted in Part 2.

Thieving Hooligans: Their petty theft and lack of discipline make them unsuitable for AFO’s structured plans, likely targeted for elimination rather than recruitment.

Madame Puppimil: Her dognapping operation is minor, but AFO might fund her to distract heroes, betraying her once her role is fulfilled, as discussed in Part 2.

Salaryman Villain: His unstable rage makes him a risky recruit. AFO might use him briefly as a shock trooper but would eliminate him to avoid unpredictability.

Masked Robber: His minor role and quick defeat suggest limited value, making him unlikely for AFO’s high-stakes plans.

Kai Chisaki (Overhaul)

Goals: Overhaul aims to eradicate Quirks, restoring Yakuza dominance through his Quirk-Destroying Drug derived from Eri’s Rewind Quirk, as detailed in Part 1.

Recruitment Style: Overhaul demands absolute loyalty, treating recruits as expendable. His mysophobic and sociopathic nature limits alliances to those who advance his drug operations or underworld control, with betrayal likely due to his intolerance for disloyalty.

Likely Recruits:

Madame Puppimil: Her criminal network could distribute Overhaul’s drugs, aligning with his underworld goals. Overhaul would tolerate her briefly but dismantle her operation to eliminate competition, as noted in Part 2.

Salaryman Villain: His rage-driven power could serve as muscle for the Shie Hassaikai, but his instability would prompt Overhaul to kill him once he becomes a liability.

Wolfram: Overhaul might hire Wolfram’s terrorists to protect his drug operations, valuing their hacking and combat skills. His mysophobia would drive him to betray Wolfram, dismantling his group, as discussed in Part 2.

Shop Thugs: As hired guns, they fit Overhaul’s need for muscle to pressure targets (e.g., heroes or rival criminals). Overhaul would use them sparingly, betraying them to maintain control.

Shoplifters: Their stealth could aid Overhaul’s covert drug distribution, but his distrust would lead to betrayal once their role is fulfilled.

Imposter Villains: Their deception skills could help Overhaul infiltrate rival organizations, but his rigid control would prompt betrayal to avoid disloyalty.

Unlikely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His chaotic, independent nature clashes with Overhaul’s need for control. Overhaul would target him for elimination, as noted in Part 2.

Takeshi Bushijima: His uncontrollable Poison Gas Quirk poses a hygiene risk, leading Overhaul to reject or dispose of him.

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their extremist ideology doesn’t align with Overhaul’s anti-Quirk agenda, and their small scale makes them irrelevant.

Speed Villain: His boastful personality and lack of discipline would irritate Overhaul, who would likely kill him.

Thieving Hooligans: Their petty crimes and lack of discipline make them unsuitable for Overhaul’s structured organization.

Dinosaur Villain: His brute force doesn’t fit Overhaul’s precision-based strategy, ensuring rejection.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk has limited utility for Overhaul’s drug-focused plans, making him irrelevant.

Future Park Villains: Their profit-driven sabotage doesn’t align with Overhaul’s ideological goals, leading to rejection.

K3 Gang: Their immaturity and reform potential make them incompatible with Overhaul’s rigid structure.

Masked Robber: His minor role and weak combat ability make him unsuitable for Overhaul’s plans.

Gang of Thieves: Their minor crimes lack the scale Overhaul requires, leading to rejection.

Flect Turn

Goals: Flect seeks to eradicate Quirk users with Trigger Bombs, preserving Quirkless individuals, driven by his belief that Quirks will destroy humanity, as outlined in Part 1.

Recruitment Style: Flect recruits zealots who share his anti-Quirk ideology, using his Reflect Quirk and Humarise’s technology to enforce loyalty. His fanatical nature limits alliances to those aligned with his vision, with betrayal likely against deviants.

Likely Recruits:

Takeshi Bushijima: His Poison Gas Quirk could be weaponized as a makeshift Trigger Bomb. Flect would promise to control his Quirk, but Takeshi’s non-malicious nature, as seen in his canon reform, makes defection likely, as noted in Part 2.

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their extremism could be co-opted into Flect’s anti-Quirk crusade if framed as protecting marine life from Quirks. Flect would use their ink-spitting Quirks for sabotage but betray them to maintain ideological purity.

Wolfram: Flect might recruit Wolfram for his Quirk Amplifier and hacking skills to enhance Trigger Bombs. Wolfram’s greed would prompt betrayal, leading Flect to eliminate him.

Unlikely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His powerful Quirk and chaotic nature make him a direct threat to Flect’s anti-Quirk agenda, leading to conflict.

Speed Villain: His pride in his Quirk clashes with Flect’s ideology, making recruitment impossible.

Thieving Hooligans: Their Quirk-based crimes and lack of ideology make them incompatible.

Dinosaur Villain: His Quirk-based strength contradicts Flect’s goals, ensuring rejection.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk doesn’t align with Flect’s technological or ideological needs.

Shop Thugs: Their profit-driven motives lack ideological alignment with Flect.

Future Park Villains: Their sabotage for profit doesn’t fit Flect’s anti-Quirk crusade.

Shoplifters: Their minor crimes and likely Quirk use make them unsuitable.

Madame Puppimil: Her profit-driven dognapping has no ideological alignment with Flect.

Salaryman Villain: His Quirk-driven rage contradicts Flect’s anti-Quirk stance.

K3 Gang: Their Quirk reliance and villain worship make them incompatible.

Masked Robber: His minor role and likely Quirk use make him irrelevant.

Gang of Thieves: Their Quirk-based thefts don’t align with Flect’s goals.

Imposter Villains: Their deception doesn’t fit Flect’s ideological purity, leading to rejection.

Rikiya Yotsubashi (Re-Destro)

Goals: Re-Destro seeks Quirk liberation, dismantling hero society to allow free Quirk use, using the Meta Liberation Army’s (MLA) vast resources, as detailed in Part 1.

Recruitment Style: Re-Destro recruits ideologues and fighters who support Quirk freedom, leveraging his charisma and Detnerat’s wealth. His emotional instability risks fragile alliances, with betrayal possible if recruits challenge his authority.

Likely Recruits:

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their extremist ideology could be framed as freeing marine Quirks, aligning with Re-Destro’s vision. Their violent tendencies fit the MLA’s tactics, but Re-Destro would betray them if they deviate, as noted in Part 2.

K3 Gang: Their admiration for Stain makes them prime MLA recruits, drawn to Re-Destro’s charisma. Their reform potential risks defection, prompting Re-Destro to monitor or eliminate them, as discussed in Part 2.

Speed Villain: His Quirk aligns with the MLA’s emphasis on free Quirk use. Re-Destro would exploit his pride, but his Fragile Speedster nature makes him disposable, betrayed after major battles.

Dinosaur Villain: His strength could bolster the MLA’s muscle, but his lack of ideological commitment ensures short-term recruitment and betrayal.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk could aid MLA assaults (e.g., destroying hero fortifications). Re-Destro would recruit him for specific missions, betraying him once his utility ends.

Unlikely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His independent, ruthless nature clashes with Re-Destro’s structured ideology, leading to conflict, as noted in Part 2.

Takeshi Bushijima: His non-malicious nature and Power Incontinence don’t align with the MLA’s aggressive goals.

Thieving Hooligans: Their petty crimes and lack of discipline make them unsuitable for the MLA’s organized structure.

Shop Thugs: Their hired-gun status lacks ideological alignment with Re-Destro’s vision.

Future Park Villains: Their profit-driven motives don’t fit the MLA’s ideological goals.

Shoplifters: Their minor crimes lack the scale for the MLA’s plans.

Madame Puppimil: Her profit-driven goals lack ideological alignment with Re-Destro.

Salaryman Villain: His uncontrolled rage doesn’t fit the MLA’s disciplined structure.

Masked Robber: His minor role and weak combat ability make him irrelevant.

Gang of Thieves: Their minor crimes don’t align with the MLA’s grand vision.

Wolfram: His greed and non-ideological motives make him a poor fit, likely leading to betrayal.

Imposter Villains: Their deception could be useful, but their lack of ideological commitment makes them unlikely recruits.

Nine

Goals: Nine seeks a world where the strong rule, stealing powerful Quirks (e.g., Katsuma’s Cell Activation) to cure his failing body and dominate society, as detailed in Part 1.

Recruitment Style: Nine recruits elite fighters who share his Social Darwinist vision, offering power or survival. His arrogance and frailty make alliances unstable, with betrayal likely, as noted in Part 2.

Likely Recruits:

Speed Villain: His Super-Speed aligns with Nine’s vision of strength. Nine would promise Quirk enhancements, betraying him once stronger allies are secured, as discussed in Part 2.

Dinosaur Villain: His strength fits Nine’s Social Darwinism, but his lack of strategy ensures Nine uses him as muscle before discarding him.

Salaryman Villain: His rage-driven power could appeal to Nine’s vision, but his instability prompts betrayal to avoid unpredictability.

Wolfram: Nine would recruit Wolfram for the Quirk Amplifier to boost his own power, as noted in Part 2. Their mutual greed ensures betrayal, with Nine targeting his Metal Manipulation.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk could aid Nine’s assaults, but his lack of ambition makes him a short-term recruit, betrayed quickly.

Unlikely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His power makes him a rival for Quirk theft, not a recruit, as discussed in Part 2.

Takeshi Bushijima: His non-malicious nature clashes with Nine’s ruthless goals.

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their niche cause and weak Quirks make them irrelevant.

Thieving Hooligans: Their petty crimes lack the ambition Nine seeks.

Shop Thugs: Their hired-gun status doesn’t fit Nine’s elite focus.

Future Park Villains: Their profit-driven motives lack the ambition Nine requires.

Shoplifters: Their minor crimes and lack of strength make them unsuitable.

Madame Puppimil: Her profit-driven goals don’t align with Nine’s vision.

K3 Gang: Their immaturity and reform potential make them unreliable.

Masked Robber: His minor role and weak combat ability make him irrelevant.

Gang of Thieves: Their minor crimes don’t fit Nine’s elite vision.

Imposter Villains: Their deception doesn’t align with Nine’s focus on strength.

Valdo (Presumed Villain)

Goals: Assuming Valdo seeks power or societal upheaval, his motives are flexible, positioning him as a wildcard who aligns with strong factions for personal gain, as outlined in Part 1.

Recruitment Style: Valdo likely recruits opportunists or those with useful Quirks, offering resources or protection. His cunning and betrayal-prone nature make alliances temporary.

Likely Recruits:

Wolfram: Valdo would ally with Wolfram for the Quirk Amplifier, promising wealth. Their mutual greed ensures betrayal, as noted in Part 2.

Speed Villain: His speed could serve Valdo’s hit-and-run tactics, but his pride makes him a short-term recruit, betrayed quickly.

Dinosaur Villain: His strength could aid Valdo’s immediate needs, but his lack of loyalty prompts betrayal.

Madame Puppimil: Valdo might fund her dognapping to distract heroes, betraying her once her role is fulfilled, as discussed in Part 2.

Shoplifters: Their stealth could aid Valdo’s covert operations, but his cunning ensures betrayal to eliminate loose ends.

Imposter Villains: Their deception skills align with Valdo’s presumed cunning, but he would betray them after securing their secrets.

Grave Robber: His Rock-Crumbling Quirk could aid Valdo’s schemes, but his lack of ambition ensures betrayal.

Shop Thugs: Their hired-gun status makes them useful for muscle, but Valdo would betray them to maintain control.

Future Park Villains: Their sabotage skills could serve Valdo’s chaotic goals, but he would betray them to avoid sharing power.

Gang of Thieves: Their minor crimes make them disposable pawns, betrayed after use.

Unlikely Recruits:

Toxic Chainsaw: His independence and power make him a rival, not a recruit.

Takeshi Bushijima: His moral core clashes with Valdo’s cunning schemes.

Octo-Lover’s Brigade: Their niche focus is too small-scale for Valdo’s plans.

Thieving Hooligans: Their petty crimes and lack of discipline make them unsuitable.

Salaryman Villain: His instability risks disrupting Valdo’s strategies.

K3 Gang: Their immaturity and reform potential make them unreliable.

Masked Robber: His minor role and weak combat ability make him irrelevant.

Dynamics and Outcomes

AFO’s Dominance: AFO recruits the widest range (Toxic Chainsaw, Speed Villain, Dinosaur Villain, Wolfram, K3 Gang, Grave Robber, Shop Thugs, Future Park Villains, Shoplifters, Gang of Thieves, Imposter Villains) due to his manipulative genius and Quirk theft, as discussed in Parts 1 and 2. His Lie Detector Quirk ensures he anticipates betrayals, stealing Quirks like Toxic Chainsaw’s and Wolfram’s Metal Manipulation, reinforcing his dominance.

Overhaul’s Limited Scope: Overhaul recruits Madame Puppimil, Salaryman Villain, Wolfram, Shop Thugs, Shoplifters, and Imposter Villains, but his mysophobia and rigid control lead to rapid betrayals, limiting his faction’s growth, as noted in Part 2.

Flect’s Ideological Rigidity: Flect’s anti-Quirk agenda restricts him to Takeshi, Octo-Lover’s Brigade, and Wolfram. His betrayals to maintain purity, as seen in Part 1, weaken his alliances.

Re-Destro’s Charismatic Appeal: Re-Destro attracts Octo-Lover’s Brigade, K3 Gang, Speed Villain, Dinosaur Villain, and Grave Robber, but his emotional instability, as discussed in Part 1, leads to betrayals against unreliable recruits.

Nine’s Elite Focus: Nine recruits Speed Villain, Dinosaur Villain, Salaryman Villain, Wolfram, and Grave Robber, but his frailty and arrogance ensure mutual betrayals, particularly with Wolfram, as noted in Part 2.

Valdo’s Wildcard Strategy: Valdo recruits Wolfram, Speed Villain, Dinosaur Villain, Madame Puppimil, Shoplifters, Imposter Villains, Grave Robber, Shop Thugs, Future Park Villains, and Gang of Thieves, but his cunning ensures rapid betrayals to consolidate power.

Likely Outcome

AFO’s superior recruitment and betrayal strategies, leveraging his vast Quirk arsenal and intellect, make him the dominant force, as outlined in Parts 1 and 2. He absorbs or eliminates most villains’ Quirks, neutralizing threats like Toxic Chainsaw and Wolfram. Overhaul’s focus on drugs limits his recruitment, while Flect’s ideological constraints and Re-Destro’s instability hinder their factions. Nine and Valdo, despite strategic recruitment, lack AFO’s resources, falling to his manipulations. The chaos from numerous minor villains (e.g., Thieving Hooligans, Masked Robber) creates opportunities for heroes like Izuku Midoriya, All Might, and Melissa Shield to exploit, using Powered Armor and defections (e.g., Takeshi, K3 Gang) to challenge AFO, as discussed in prior analyses.

Conclusion