I do think the cartoonish nature of the trailer was... a surprise. But honestly? I don't like the hate bandwagon going on.
I don't mean this in the sense of "don't have a negative opinion", because we should all have our own tastes. I've been a dragon age fan since DA2, I am well versed in the art of shit talking dragon age while simultaneously defending it to hell and back. It's the DA relationship, if you will.
What I mean is that I think a lot of people (especially on the trailer youtube comments) were just... jumping in, doing the hate train because everyone else was on board with the destination set to shit talking. Without forming their own opinions. It is honestly a good representation of how media criticism has evolved.
Best comparison I could give would be the live action ATLA series. I disliked it from the trailers alone. But then, I waited for it to come out, watched it with friends, and now I openly talk about the countless bads while also mentioning the few goods it had. Because I form my own opinions, be they negative or positive.
I do think Veilguard won't fulfill me. I unfortunately became extremely passionate about DA2, and no other dragon age game has done it for me. Origins was nice, but maker Kirkwall has charm. I thought Inquisition was disappointing, but I also have no trouble singing its praises.
But from what we're seeing I am hopeful. Even if the game is trash, if the companions are well done and bring me back to my DA2 times when I replayed the game countless times and lost my mind laughing at Fenris and Anders' banter (I always brought them together everywhere, poor sods)... I'll be satisfied.
If you hate what we have seen so far... I just ask you think for yourself, and form your negative opinion based on your own thoughts rather than jumping on the hate train. That's the problem I'm seeing: not negative reviews, but mindless negative reviews.