A Nice Indian Boy: Hollywood quietly dropped a gay love story with a 98% Rotten Tomatoes and no one noticed
A Nice Indian Boy is a heartfelt queer rom-com where cultures collide, love blooms, and identity finds its voice, starring Karan Soni and Jonathan Groff.
By:Ā Entertainment Desk
5 min read
New Delhi
Apr 18, 2025 03:12 PM IST
Roshan Sethiās directorial,Ā A Nice Indian Boy, is a queer love story inspired by Madhuri Shekarās play, adapted by Eric Randall. The film released worldwide on April 4. And while Hollywood critics have practically written love letters to this tender American rom-com blending Bollywood elements, praising its refreshing take on LGBTQ+ narratives, the story somehow flew under the radar in India.Ā A Nice Indian Boy, starring Jay (Jonathan Groff) and Naveen (Karan Soni), currently holds a 98 percent Rotten Tomatoes with an 8 IMDb rating. And hereās everything you need to know.
Whatās the storyline ofĀ A Nice Indian Boy
The movie is a boy-love romantic comedy that blends two very different worlds. The romance blossoms in five stages. After āThe Boy,ā each chapter takes you deeper into their relationship, they fall in love, meet families, deal with culture clashes, last-minute engagement drama, and a big wedding day. The show follows Naveen, a gay Indian-American boy who finally sees himself in a love story where he doesnāt have to choose between being Indian and being himself. Jay teaches Naveen to accept and love himself. And by the end, even Naveen becomes a voice of quiet power in his traditional family. The film first premiered at the South by Southwest Film Festival in March 2024.
The movie spotlights the stereotype, especially the non-acceptance that, technically on surface, is a āyes,ā but practically, in minds, that unspoken ānoā is still there. In the movie as well, Naveenās parents know heās gay, but theyāve never seen him be gay. Never seen him with a boyfriend.Ā This unspoken gap makes Naveen feel like maybe heāll never have the kind of wedding his siblings had. But his beliefs change when he meets Jay Kurundkar (played by Jonathan Groff), a white guy who was adopted and raised by Indian parents.
The story has beautifully chosen its filming locations and tries hard to be as vocal as possible while treading carefully on sensitive ground. The first time Jay and Naveen meet is at a Hindu temple, in front of a Ganesh idol. They donāt even talk. Just silent glances. But when Jay rings the bell while leaving, itās like something magical starts. (Much like SRKās violin playing moment in Mai Hoon Na). Having said that, the film also spills its Bollywood magic. Jay invites Naveen to a movie screeningāDDLJ, a 90s Bollywood classic. Each part feels like a thoughtful approach. The actors arenāt just two people datingātheyāre learning to mix into each otherās lives, cultures, and fears. Jay has no family left, but Naveenās family brings enough drama for everyone.Ā Ā At one point, everything seems to fall apart. Misunderstandings. Cultural confusion. Emotional walls. It looks like the wedding might never happen. Against all odds, theyĀ doĀ make it to the mandap.Ā
Speaking of the cast, Zarna Garg, the Indian-American stand-up comedian, plays the role of Naveenās mother. Known for her excellent comic timing and hailed as āone of the gutsiest women comedians in Americaā, her presence adds the fun factor in the show, and thereās not a single boring moment you can spot. Apart from the lead, Sunita Mani plays Arundhathi, Naveenās sister. Harish Patel appears as Archit (Naveenās father), and Sas Goldberg is seen in a supporting role.
A Nice Indian Boy- What are critics saying
āRoshan Sethiās quietly confident film unspools a tender love story between two menāand the generations learning to accept themāwith wit, nuance and no interest in clichĆ©,ā Rotten Tomatoes approved critic Rex Reed said.Ā
āItās very easy to ignore A Nice Indian Boyās faults because it tells a story that feels familiar, but forges its own path. We need more queer rom-coms and it will be easy to welcome A Nice Indian Boy into that growing cano,ā said Zach Youngs.
āIt begins and ends with a wedding, but itās whatās in between that results in you being hitched to āA Nice Indian Boy.ā Thriving on a combination of charm and hard truths, itās an astute celebration of family, no matter how big of a pain it can be,ā wrote AL Alexander.
Speaking to the Deadline, Jonathan Groff said, āIt felt like a rom-com, but also a love story about becoming a part of somebodyās family ā and the complicated ways they accept or donāt accept you.ā For Karan Soni, āIt felt like the kind of movie that I could have never imagined when I started in Hollywood, in 2010, being made⦠but this felt like it was just pure joy.ā Karanās real life partner Roshan directed the film, which made this whole movie even more speciaL. āWe wanted a movie that felt like a Hollywood rom-com, but gave you the flavour of Bollywood,ā he added.