#poly!mbav

Fandom: My babysitter’s a vampire

Request: “ Hey! I was just wondering if you could do some fluff hcs or a oneshot for Poly!Bethan x Reader (?). It's fine if not^^ have a good day/night! :) “ @thatonehornymf

Genre: fluff

Warnings: none

~~~

You and Benny definitely feed into each other's recklessness. It’s a problem. You’re usually very chill and collected but when it’s you and Benny, it feels like your inner child is rejoicing and you can let go of all common sense and responsibilities and just live! Sure, that sometimes lands you two in trouble (many hours spent in detention between the 2 of you) but ultimately, the fun you have together outweighs the consequences. Plus your other boyfriend is right there for you!

He waits for you in the cafeteria or library. You always walk home together, so this is usually the time you and Benny will have to explain yourselves and he will give you a long and boring lecture about being more “responsible” and whatnot. It’s ok tho, because he will always end said lecture by kissing both of you and reminding you how much he loves you.

Ethan just loves you two so so much, he doesn’t want you to think any differently just because he’s acting annoyed. All he wants is for you to not get in trouble!

Date nights are definitely rare. It’s not because you 3 don’t wanna go out, but because you already spend so much time together at Ethan’s house, dates don’t feel exactly necessary. It’s not like any of you are the “going out to a fancy restaurant in suits and dresses'' type.

Even when you do go out, it’ll more than likely be something casual, like a movie! The boys will make a point of getting you your own bag of popcorn, while they share theirs because “as a lady”, you shouldn’t have to share your snacks with anyone. You’ll take turns picking the movies and everytime you guys agree on a horror movie, it’s custom to let E sit in the middle because poor boy gets so scared and you and  Benny love sharing knowing looks while holding his hand or wrapping your arms around him

Benny is the KING of gifts!! He’s more observant than many think and always knows exactly what to get his two lovers to leave them speechless. He drops them on you at the most random moments too. He needs no occasion to get you the newest game you’ve been into and new paranormal hunting equipment for Ethan

When you get tangled up in paranormal business, Ethan becomes extremely overprotective of you and Benny! He will stop at nothing to keep you safe, which sometimes leads to arguments because he would much rather prefer you two stay home and out of it but you remind him that he can’t do it by himself, he needs you!

If any of you end up getting hurt at all, even if it’s as much as a scratch, you have a plan already in place!! You’ll go back to one of your houses and clean up, before starting a massive cuddle session!! The injured one reserves the right to choose the playlist that’s going off, but the others choose the snacks.

Fandom: My babysitter's a vampire

Request: "I read your poly! bethan hcs and I wanted to request poly benny x rory x reader or rory x reader x erica if possible!! whichever one you feel more comfortable with :)"

Genre: Fluff

Warnings: implications of a toxic relationship in the beginning but it's not bad, I swear!

A/n: headcanons are weird to me cause I just end up writting a short story anyways. Might make another part to talk more about the relationship itself

~~~

Your relationship definitely started on a…rough patch

You and Rory got together first. It happened very naturally, as he couldn’t really hide his affections from you (not that this mattered at all to him) and you found him more and more endearing and adorable with every passing day

You and Erica got together almost 8 months later. She realised her feelings for you during a school dance and made it her mission to steal you away.

Rory was actually excited for you, funnily enough! Of course both of you acknowledged how hot Erica was and he thought it was so cool that his girlfriend was approached by someone like her (gave him a new sense of confidence too). He was the one who encouraged you to reply to Erica’s advancements, assuring you he was totally fine with it!

It took Erica a long time to agree to “sharing” you with Rory. She tried time and time again to have you change your mind, but you stood your ground firmly, explaining that you loved him with all your heart, so she could either accept the terms or move on

A lot of disagreements in the beginning over Erica’s possessiveness, but things got even worse when she started catching feelings for Rory as well

All of a sudden, she’s picking fights over everything! Rory’s name can’t even be uttered in conversation without some sort of volcanic reaction. She often feels guilty about these moments, but she finds it really hard to navigate her new found affection for somebody she used to see as such a weirdo. Now she can barely suppress a smile when he offers to pay for her coffee as well while out or pretend to be annoyed when he’s oversharing about his special interests

You figure it out for her. The realization hits you all at once one day, during another argument in which Erica tried to convince you to ditch your plans with your boyfriend and stay with her! It almost makes you laugh at how simple this whole thing could’ve been solved

You told Rory everything (with Erica’s consent of course) and he was over the moon. He was pacing around the room, giggling like a little kid, hugging you, twirling you, posing and making all sorts of funny remarks about how much of a ladies man he is before he finally picked up the phone, called Erica, and asked her on a proper date

Things calmed down a lot after that. Arguing halted at once, even though it still took all of you a little bit to get accustomed to this new dynamic.

You and Rory tried to make Erica as comfortable as possible. She’s very insecure and concerned with maintaining her image in front of the school and her feelings felt very conflicting at first, but soon, she learned to get over her fears. On your first date together as a throuple, as she looked at the two of you sharing a menu across the table from her, she knew she loved you more than she loved being popular, whatever that meant

Rory loves boasting about his two beautiful girls. Takes every occasion to rub it in Etahn and Benny’s noses, which definitely makes for an entertaining scene

Erica finds it exciting to rediscover and explore some of the more geeky subjects that she used to be passionate about before. You encourage her a lot and she eventually learns to have a fun time exchanging theories and information with Rory about whatever topic.

Fandom: My babysitter’s a Vampire

Request: “OMG, you write for My Babysitters a Vampire!!💕 Almost no one writes for them! Can you write a Benny fic please?❤️ Or maybe a poly fic with Benny and Ethan!”

Summary: You boyfriend, Ethan’s birthday is coming up so you and Benny, your other boyfriend, are trying your very best to plan the best birthday surprise you can for him but there might just be one tiny detail you forgot about...

Genre: Fluff

Warnings: None

~~~

Ethan’s birthday was coming up and of course you and Benny had to go all out for your boyfriend! Even though you knew he wasn't one for big celebrations, you couldn't let the occasion slide! You were putting together a surprise party with the help of the entire friend group.

“Alright, so I talked with his mom and she said it’s ok and we can stay the night. She offered to cook for us but like…” Benny took a break, looking for the perfect way to describe how he felt but when he couldn’t find anything, he settled for an exasperated sigh. You couldn’t help but laugh at the drama

“You want pizza instead?”

“Of course!” you giggled at his antics, reaching over to kiss his lips

“I’ll talk to her. You’re too nice to refuse”

“You’re the best”

“Don’t I know it” you smirked at him

You and Benny were sitting on the floor of your bedroom, making lists of everything you needed to buy and possible presents you could get your boyfriend, but mostly eating popcorn and vibing to your father’s old records. With Benny, a simple task such as this one always took longer than it should have.

The day of Ethan’s birthday, both you and Benny pretended to be as busy as possible. Of course you wished him a happy birthday in the morning when you saw each other and told him you loved him but afterwards, you made as many excuses as possible. It wasn’t that you didn’t want to be with your boyfriend for his birthday, but both you and Benny were incredibly awful liars. If you were to spend every free moment you had with E,like you usually did, one of you was sure to crack.

During lunch break, you pretended you needed to study in the library, but instead you sneaked out with Benny in the parking lot

“I kinda feel bad” you confessed “It’s his birthday and we’ve obviously been avoiding him all day”

“It’s for the greater cause, babe! Just think of his face when he sees the epic birthday celebration we prepared for him tonight!” Benny was swaying his arms in the air to emphasise the grandeur of the night you had arranged

“I don’t know. We shouldn’t have to avoid him all day for a surprise later in the evening”

Benny grabbed you by both shoulders so you would look him in the eyes

“It’s ok. Ethan isn’t the type to get pissed about stuff like this. It’ll all be worth it” he looked at you with love and sympathy. It was impossible for you not to melt when he did that. You nodded in agreement and he leaned in to kiss your lips. You melted into his embrace and he held you into his arms

“It’s all good.” he whispered in your ear. You smiled to yourself and planted a sweet kiss on his neck, as a ‘thank you’.

The day went on as scheduled. You didn’t share any classes with Ethan and you made sure to leave school as quickly as possible to avoid running into him. You made your way home and took a shower, your outfit already prepared from yesterday. Texting Benny and Sarah to make sure they had the last few details under control and you were out the door, heading towards Ethan’s.

His dad opened the door for you.Him and Ethan’s mom were on their way out for the night, leaving you, Benny and Erica to order the pizza and wait for a sign of life from Sarah, who was out with Ethan, distracting him. Soon after your arrival at the Morgan household, you phone beeped with a text from Sarah, letting you know they were on their way home. Benny was spying out the window, while you were doing your last checks

“They’re here!” your boyfriend yelled from the living room

“What? Rory hasn’t arrived yet!”

“Well it’s too late now for that!”

Together with your boyfriend and best friend, you made your way to the door and as soon as Ethan cracked it open… “SURPRISE!” all of you, including Sarah screamed out loud. E looked at all of you and smiled

“Thank you guys, I really appreciate the effort but you are awful at keeping secrets” he said with a laugh, looking at you and Benny in particular

“What? You knew?” B said

“Rory told me” a couple of sighs felt the friend group as they realised their mistake

“Just wait until he gets here!” You joke, going in to hug your birthday boy and continue the celebration as planned.

~~~

It was late into the night when E dragged both you and Benny into his room, saying he had something he wanted to say.

“What’s up babe? Are you not enjoying the party?” Benny asked, afraid of what the answer might be

“No, no! It’s amazing! I just wanted to say thank you guys, it means so much that you went through all this trouble just for my birthday”

“We would do it again anytime!” You assured him with a bright smile. E giggled and pulled you into a hug, kissing the top of your head

“You are the best girlfriend in the world” he said, hugging you tight “And you” he continued, pulling Benny into a hug as well “Are the best boyfriend anyone could ever ask for” Benny leaned in to kiss his boyfriend before wrapping his arms around both of you