(Hi I feel the exact same way about the mindy project as you do in your tags ly bye)
Ah I love this message and Iām so happy you agree with me! It has so much potential as a show but it keeps wasting it. I feel like it lives solely for its jokes and its jokes are funny and endlessly quotable but the story lines and characters feel like they exist to serve the jokes instead of the other way around.
Remember Peter? I loved Peter! But I really wish they would have taken the time to develop his character and give him a love interest that the audience really cared about. And itās likeā¦they almost did? But then they didnāt. I know he ends up with Lauren but Iām not sure thatās actually her name and thatās a bad sign! I should have cared about Lauren; I was ready to care about Lauren but they just didnāt convincingly develop that relationship. It felt like everything about it, all of the insights into them as a couple, all of their dynamic was crafted solely to be a series of punchlines. And I remember the punchlines and I love them! Remember when Peter went out to dinner and he got into a fight with Lauren about something and then he stood up to leave and saidĀ āIām going to pay my 1/3 of the bill and leave now.ā (Because she had a son.) And I laughed so hard but itās pretty indicative of the show that I remember this line but I donāt remember what they were fighting about and I? Donāt? Remember? Lauren? or liking her at all because Iām pretty sure she had no character. Ugh.
And now Iām on a roll and Iām writing way too much anyway so I will keep going and say that I feel like there is so much wasted potential for cute and satisfying story lines. Everyone is pretty talented and charismatic but theyāre never given anything to work with but jokes. Every big plot point, every breakdown, every thing that happens just feels like a vehicle for Mindyās one liners. Take Jeremy. Do you remember the episode where Jeremy spends the weekend at Betsyās house with her family for thanksgiving? (Maybe?) Iām probably just overly sentimental and want everyone to get together with everyone but I thought there was real potential for a surprising and sweet love story there. Maybe Iām crazy but I donāt think I was totally making it up. At the very least they could have developed a friendship or something. But none of them ever do.
I love that this show is surprising and doesnāt always go where you think itās going to even in its jokes. I love all of the weirdly specific tidbits we get about the charactersā inner thoughts. But the only person besides Mindy that I feel really has a character is Danny and so his jokes are funny because he actually has a distinct personality. When he says something in or out of character both are delightful. But characters like Tamra and Jeremy are just punchlines most of the time. And I want more people to care about than just Mindy and Danny. (Also get rid of Morgan. He is no longer funny. Heās funny in small doses. Not continuously.) Maybe Iām expecting too much from a 20 minute sitcom but I know Mindy wrote on the office. I know she can do better so itās frustrating.
Also she really really needs to stop with the Catholic punchlines. And just because Iām Catholic doesnāt mean I canāt at least see the humor in an occasional funny, even irreverent, Catholic joke. Dannyās joke about Pope FrancisĀ ābeing way too chillā made me laugh so hard. (Does that make me a bad person?) But sometimes she goes way way overboard and it stops being funny and becomes not only disrespectful but just plain predictable and boring. Pick on another religion Mindy.
I have a way of writing you an essay every time! I really donāt try to; it just happens! I should write more text posts about stuff like this but I never do until someone sends me a message about them and itās usually you. So thank you for always inspiring me to never shut up. :)