For Beloved, Rosy, Astra, Aloith and Streams: How would they feel about a cheesy, romantic, candle-lit dinner? Assuming Reader does the cooking, of course.
Beloved: Dude? Beloved just stars BALLING. He breaks down. It's one of the nicest things that someone had done for him in so long that it just is too much for him to handle at first. He loves it though! He thinks that is very sweet and he'll hug you. His tail is wagging faster than you've seen in a long time too!
Rosy: Oh she thinks that it's just the cutest thing. She'll cuddle up to you while you two eat, her wings flapping happily. It becomes one of her favorite memories of you two together!
Astra: She's going to be shocked and a little confused. She wasn't expecting that and... well now she's all embarrassed. She would most likely need a moment to calm herself down and once she does, she'll hug you and start to pepper kisses over your face, "You're so sweet!" She loves it!
Aloith: He almost cries too, tbh. Yeah, a lot of people are nice, but a lot of people do nice things for... sexual reasons but he knew that you were doing it because you loved him! He would love it if you sat on his lap and let him feed you :D it makes him feel close to you.
Streams: "Aww you did this for me? You're so cute" he would cuddle you and kiss your cheeks. He thinks that it is very sweet and kind that you would do something like that. Expect him to tease you though...