Twst Magi Au: who else at NRC would be likely have been made into Magi pre-NRC
(Rankin these from most to least)
1. Idia - I think that he could have been one of he was approached before he made Orthro
2. Jamil - He would have become if Kalim hadn't first. Probably after his curry poisoning
3. Ruggie - the only reason he is not higher is because he is so diligent and hopefully and that hope would deter The Benefactor
4. Leona - I personally think that to a degree he, whether he realizes or not, clings to the things he's good at to give him hope.
5. Malleus - If Lilla was never there, he would be a candidate but because he's from the briar valley this making him less likely them most.
6. Vil - if he wasn't so disciplined and driven then he would probably make the deal but I feel like he would make his around 14 like when Niege got that award. Or some other exceedingly bad heartbreak/ underminement of his skills
7. Trey - out of everyone he definitely could have been approached. He just wasn't.. maybe if he was like a little bit closer with riddle than the emotional trauma from the incident with riddle's mother would have pushed him to the point of being a candidate. But like he was almost there. The only reason why he's not higher on the list is because he is just better off in terms of everyday and home life. But that incident would have been his catalyst .
8. Riddle - he like Trey. Definitely could have been a candidate for similar reasons but I think because the way he processed his trauma was into shame that it prevented him from becoming a possible candidate because he never really despaired. And that shame response to him breaking the rules also puts him below Trey.
9. Azul - if he didn't immediately turn his energy into drive and despaired about it for just like a little bit longer, he also would have been camped it, but his diligence and determination kind of just saved him from being a possible magical boy.
10. Deuce - he would have become a magical boy either almost right after overhearing his mother's phone call or about the same time Ace does after Vargas camp.
11. Jack - right after Leona's overblot that would really get to him. Especially if right after something bad happened to him in Savannah claw because of him being a "traitor"
12. Floyd - his would be either after playful land if it was written to be as traumatizing as it was, or right around The book 6 missing.. I feel like without some sort of major event greatly negatively impacting either azul or Jade then he wouldn't at all be a candidate.
13. Epel - would only occur if he got some form of factual proof that he could never obtain his dream of being strong.
14. Cater - maybe if he never found connection he would qualify but I don't know him well enough to say for certain.
15. Jade - He's too entertained by everything. I can imagine him being so physically distressed that he could be a candidate but not emotionally. So unless something really really bad happened. But he would definitely be a possibility of a non-zero one but not a high non-zero one.
16. Rook - because of his Outlook on life and seeing beauty in everything, he would almost always be able to see hope in most situations and I highly doubt he would reach the emotional criteria. Maybe before he saw Niege he could have been a candidate but I don't know enough about that time to make a call on that part.
17. Ortho - has a lot of Hope also I do not believe that the benefactor would recognize him as a possible candidate because of the fact he's a humanoid.
18. Sliver - Lilia kept him happy and hopeful that I don't think he would reach that point and if he did it would be during Malleus's overblot. But once again he's from the briar valley which makes it way less likely for him to be selected and the only time he would meet the emotional criteria for it is while he was within a dream and used to physically be approached in order to become one.
19.Lilla - well I think his orphaned pass could make him a possible candidate. Him being in the briar valley and also hella old makes him incredibly unlikely to be selected. He's just too old and in such an unfortunate location to be chosen as a magical boy.
Some of them are only ranked this low because I don't know them as characters well enough to give a solid statement. But the majority of NRC probably could have been selected if they just had their lke overblot emotions without the overblot before NRC.
A large portion of why most of NRC aren't magical boys is because they either have like heavy shame in place of despair in those moments or some other emotion rather than despair. Mostly shame and envy.
Sorry for typos, my screen is still damaged.