#official scripts

✎ NOTES

the script explicitly confirms that this is the first moment the audience is meant to realize cate isn’t just a “pusher”—she’s a full-blown telepath. that distinction changes everything. earlier in the series, we only understand her as someone who can push thoughts and commands into others. here, we finally see that she can also hear them—and that her “silence” all season was artificially maintained. cate’s immediate instinct is to reach for her pills, her coping mechanism and the tool shetty used to keep her compliant. the empty bottle is symbolic of both her loss of control and shetty’s manipulation: shetty never wanted cate to access her full telepathic ability, because that would’ve exposed everything. the pills weren’t just a sedative—they were a leash, designed to keep cate’s mind quiet and therefore useful. i think it's fair to read her pill use as an addiction—both physically and psychologically. the withdrawal here is twofold: she’s losing the numbing control of the drug and being hit full-force with her suppressed empathy and guilt. the “maddening din” of voices drives home how unbearable her power becomes when unrestrained, and it mirrors how someone in withdrawal experiences sensory and emotional overload. the stage direction calling her “well past rock bottom” is chilling. she’s beyond self-destruction—she’s in survival autopilot. that’s what makes her pulling the others into her “mind palace” so compelling later on: she’s not doing it from a place of control or strength, but from sheer emotional and psychic collapse. the decision to reveal her telepathy now also reframes everything we’ve seen before. cate’s obedience to shetty isn’t stupidity or blind loyalty—it’s the result of engineered isolation. shetty ensured cate could never hear the truth, literally silencing her intuition. the breakdown of that control marks the start of cate’s awakening and descent all at once.

✎ NOTES

this beat quietly suggests how dire cate’s headspace is. even marie wonders if cate attempted suicide, which reframes the scene from “cate collapsed” to “cate may hate herself enough to harm herself.” it’s a striking omission in the final cut, including it would’ve guided viewers to recognize just how deep cate’s guilt and self-loathing run. the moment also invites ambiguity: the empty pill bottle from earlier points to dependence/withdrawal and shetty’s control, while marie’s line opens the door to a darker interpretation. the tension between those two readings doesn’t weaken the scene—it mirrors cate’s fractured state of mind, where coping, addiction, and self-destructive despair coexist. functionally, this would have humanized cate’s collapse for the audience. instead of reading her condition as karmic fallout or “power side-effects,” we’d read it as the breaking point of a girl buckling under engineered isolation, manipulation, and relentless guilt.

✎ NOTES

andre’s first instinct is “she erased our shit again,” which tracks with his hurt and confirmation bias, he reads every unexplained gap as more manipulation. marie, by contrast, immediately clocks that something else is happening and leans sympathetic. the contrast matters: it shows the group already splitting into punitive vs. context-sensitive lenses on cate, and foreshadows who’s primed to be a bridge for her later. this tiny exchange quietly positions marie as the one willing to differentiate intent from impact, while andre is stuck in defensive vigilance—understandable, but limiting. it keeps cate’s crisis human, not just criminal.

✎ NOTES

soldier boy’s “she really loves you” knocks andre sideways. by now he’s got his memories back, so the shock reads less like “news” and more like disconfirmation: he’d been nursing the belief that cate didn’t love him (or couldn’t), which made the betrayal easier to hold onto. realizing she did love him complicates the hurt—love doesn’t erase what happened, it just makes it messier. what kind of “love” is this? i don’t read cate’s feelings as simple, sweeping romance. it plays closer to attachment + refuge: andre was the safest place left—the closest link to luke, a steady presence to project comfort onto. that doesn’t make it fake, it makes it trauma-shaped. she clung to him the way drowning people cling to driftwood. the script’s “twinge of jealousy” undercuts andre’s hard line. he’s furious, but he hasn’t flipped the switch to indifference. that tension keeps their dynamic alive (and volatile). soldier boy is cate’s construct. he might be speaking truths, but he’s filtered through her psyche. his “she really loves you” lands as something cate believes/needs to be true—even as the show leaves room for the interpretation that her love is conditional, coping-driven, and tangled up with grief. it’s fascinating that he presents as a self-serving jerk, not the polished public persona cate would mostly know. that suggests her subconscious reads through branding and sketches him as the archetype she needs in here: abrasive, goading, hard to trust, making him an unreliable narrator by design. therefore, soldier boy likely operates as psychic misdirection—a noisy spectacle that keeps everyone busy while cate’s internal trauma reel threatens to consume her. he draws focus away from the rawest parts of her mind, buying her system time.

✎ NOTES

jumanji matters beyond the title. cutting this exchange flattens the reference into a wink. in-script, it’s textual character insight: jumanji is cate’s favorite movie, and her mind unconsciously patterns the crisis on it. that tells us she’s not masterminding an elaborate trap...she’s grabbing for a familiar story-shape while her powers spiral. this is more evident with cate’s later line “what are you doing here?” she isn’t fully aware she’s pulled them in. the jumanji callout clarifies the episode’s premise as involuntary mindscape rather than deliberate manipulation, reinforcing how overwhelmed she is. without this scene, viewers can read the episode as a stylish homage. with it, the homage becomes character logic—cate’s mind reaching for the only blueprint that makes sense to her while she drowns.

✎ NOTES

this cut scene finally shows what the final edit only implies: cate pushes her friends about the party—and she does it pained. it matters that the script writes her as emotionally torn during the act. it reframes the push from cold manipulation to coerced compliance. she’s doing the harm with full awareness that it is harm, which is exactly what makes it a moral injury for her. the second (also cut) scene is devastating character text. cate voices a boundary but shetty answers with the classic abuser’s script. that one line collapses their whole dynamic—weaponized “care,” manufactured obligation, and the exploitation of cate’s savior complex. together these pages capture the loop: (1) cate harms at shetty’s direction, visibly distressed. (2) cate tries to stop (3) shetty reframes harm as help and resets cate’s guilt into obedience. rinse, repeat. without these, viewers can default to “cate enjoys control/just likes wiping.” with them, it’s unambiguous: she never enjoyed it. she was guided, gaslit, and guilted into it, and the institution profited from her power while keeping her conscience on the hook.

✎ NOTES

the script explicitly lists cate as 17 here. even without this confirmation we are aware as an audience that shetty has known and managed cate before godU, but this stretches the shetty timeline in a interesting way. it opens up the possibility that shetty either regularly visited while cate finished homeschooling or perhaps even stepped in as a legal guardian to extract her from that bedroom-prison. in maddie’s interviews, cate sees indira as her savior—the adult who “rescued” her, protects her, and “keeps her safe.” layer the drug regimen on top (which dampens telepathy and keeps the ugliest truths out of earshot), and cate’s willingness to obey shetty isn’t convenience—it’s engineered dependence. the stage direction calls out a room that’s curated but connectionless—no family/friend photos, bolts and locks. the wall art leans towards queen maeve (queer icon) and crimson countess, with a conspicuous absence of soldier boy. that omission supports him as a mind-made misdirection/self-defense construct in the earlier scenes: if you’ve accidentally dragged your friends into your trauma, you don’t also volunteer your closeted self on top of it. cate states she’s been confined nine years. taken with the earlier script cue, that back-solves to her first catastrophic push at 8, not 9 as previously stated—another timeline wobble the show never fully resolves...

✎ NOTES

as the audience, we learned earlier that cate is a full telepath, but this flashback is when the others discover it—on screen, in real time. andre didn’t know—at all. his blindsided reaction underlines that, for all their closeness, cate kept her deepest truths hidden from him. it supports the read that her “love” has been attachment + projection born from grief and survival, not open intimacy. cate doesn’t volunteer the telepathy, she admits it only when cornered, reinforcing her pattern: a perfect, manageable mask over a self she’s sure will be rejected. that fear is why she withholds history—even from those she supposedly "loves." marie tracks the manipulation as it happens. stage direction literally has her watching shetty’s seduction mechanics and checking if andre “gets it.” marie is again the only one reading cate with empathy rather than disgust. shetty offers the same bottle we’ve seen all season explicitly framing the drug as a coping necessity. that’s coercive caregiving: relief in exchange for compliance. she also weaponized comfort when asking for a hug, which floors cate because no one has asked since she was a child—and shetty knows it. the hug is not warmth, it’s leverage. this scene proves that cate’s obedience isn’t convenience, it’s the product of long-term grooming + chemical restraint. the show is telling us shetty cultivated dependence first, then positioned herself as the only safe harbor.

✎ NOTES

marie clocks the grooming pattern immediately. she connects shetty’s tactics to her own experience in real time, which reframes cate’s behavior as coerced, not malicious. that instant recognition makes marie the only one reading the room with empathy instead of resentment. andre’s “love” vs. love in practice. his first reflex is anger and punishment, not curiosity or care. marie’s comment lands because love isn’t just a claim, it’s whether you even try to understand the person in front of you. he doesn’t. marie also calls him out on his hypocrisy. it’s a mirror moment the episode otherwise softens: all of them are shaped by harmful adults, but he only has compassion for himself. this scene underlines the show’s core: none of them chose what was done to them. cutting this entire exchange hurts the arc, and further blurs why marie keeps defending cate.

✎ NOTES

in the script, andre is the one who keeps going. cate hesitates first, then follows once he surges forward to kiss her. final cut flips that dynamic so it looks like cate is the engine and andre is the conscience. that single change quietly reassigns blame...cate carries visible conflict from moment one in the script whereas andre overrides it. on screen, most of the guilt is parked on andre while cate reads as brazen. that’s character assassination by omission: it erases cate’s ambivalence towards the affair and makes her feel colder than the material intends.

✎ NOTES

the script puts andre right there with cate as an active participant (and often the one pressing forward). it reinforces that the affair wasn’t cate dragging him, it was mutual. cutting adjacent moments elsewhere primes viewers to pin it all on her, so this scene is a needed counterweight. marie's line reframes andre not as the pained conscience, but as someone who knowingly crossed a line. it also mirrors how episode edits repeatedly let andre’s culpability blur while cate’s is spotlighted. the past tense of love is narrative distancing and shows that andre is already shifting to a posture where remorse > responsibility. it supports why other scenes (like with tek knight) have him minimizing or recasting the affair timeline. jordan's reaction matters to show that the group’s moral judgment isn’t one-sided in the script—another beat that gets softened in the final cut, which is why luke’s “she didn’t force you—you wanted to” line gets memory-holed by an anti-cate-biased audience... leaving scenes like this in would have preserved the show’s messier, fairer moral geometry—cate’s guilt and andre’s, manipulation from shetty and andre’s choices—rather than funneling hate toward one character.

✎ NOTES

the action lines (“her heart starting to break,” “pained”) make explicit that cate hates doing this. the final cut trims that texture, so viewers only hear the repeated “forget,” which reads colder than the script intends... every push here targets one subject—luke’s memories of sam. nothing else. that specificity points straight back to shetty’s agenda rather than cate freelancing evil. the script even shows how it was cumulative damage—on both sides. repetition explains luke’s fragmentation and cate’s eventual collapse. it’s harm that compounds, not a one-off villain move. framing, timing, and content align with shetty’s interests, not cate’s: keep luke from looking for sam, keep campus quiet, keep the woods hidden, etc. cate acts from groomed trust and is coerced into thinking it's “for their own good,” not from malice. without luke’s spoken lines (and cate’s pained beats), the final edit primes audiences to read this as blanket, casual mind-wiping. the script shows it as a narrow, mandated intervention that’s eating her alive.

✎ NOTES

cate explicitly saying “i can’t” is the cleanest onscreen proof that she does not want to push them. removing it flattens her into compliance, keeping it shows refusal → coercion → surrender. ultimately this further proves that cate's own consent is revoked under duress. the beat progression is: objection → refusal → parental override → compliance. that’s not choosing, that’s compliance under threat of losing the only “care” she has. shetty and brink's comments are classic reward/punish conditioning: praise to override instinct, order to force action. it’s conditional love weaponized in real time. with the inclusion of “i can’t,” viewers see a kid begging to stop. without it, the scene might be viewed as cate crying over the fact she's been caught. that edit subtly shifts blame from the institution to the traumatized teenager. this also mirrors the shetty tea-scene pattern: cate reaches her limit → asks to stop → shetty wraps threat in “for their own good.” same playbook, different situation. cate’s impulse here is caretaking, her powers are just the tool. the ethic is already in place but she’s being coerced to act against her better judgment.

✎ NOTES

marie offers what cate’s never gotten: a real choice. that’s consent, agency, and trust—all the things shetty/brink systematically denied cate. it turns the scene from exposition into a moral fork in the road. one in which cate chooses good—on purpose. with that line in place, cate pulling them out and saying they can leave isn’t an accident or power-glitch, it’s a decision. no shetty whisper, no brink order—just cate finally able to exercise her autonomy. it's the first clean break in the coercion loop. marie models empathy that holds two truths at once. she knows cate harmed her, and she still recognizes their shared wound. that’s the difference between empathy for a victim and empathy for the harmed-who-harmed. marie can carry both, the others (especially andre) largely can’t. the script direction that andre and jordan finally grasp marie's deepest pain, yet still struggle to extend that empathy to cate because her harm was proximate to them, is telling. marie—who was also harmed by cate—chooses to see the whole person anyway. that asymmetry is the point. without this line, viewers can read cate’s exit as plot convenience or passive collapse. with it, we see intentionality! the redemption hinge isn’t a later speech—it’s this trust exchange in which marie becomes the moral center and the first person to relate to cate as a peer with boundaries, not a tool.

✎ NOTES

here cate isn’t just saying “i don’t want to wake up.” she’s articulating a sentence: she believes the only proportionate atonement for the harm she caused is death. essentially, she rejects forgiveness. that matters because it counters the “cate always plays the victim” take: here she refuses the comfort of being comforted. her stance is, “do not rehabilitate me. let me pay for my sins.” that’s accountability—misguided and tragic, but real. this confirms insight, not ignorance. by this point she fully grasps the scope of the hurt she's caused. cutting it ultimately left room for “she still doesn’t get it”, keeping it shows she does—and that insight is crushing her. we’ve already seen the script toy with overdose/ideation signals. this line threads those moments into a coherent through-line of escalating self-annihilation, not a one-off dramatic flourish. it also solidifies marie's role...she isn’t just coaxing a friend to wake up, she’s interrupting a self-imposed execution, giving cate a counterargument to her death-as-penance logic.

✎ NOTES

in the final cut, dusty is blown to bits in in cate’s mindscape and is ultimately functionally tallied as another victim of her powers. however in the script, cate intervenes to save him. that’s active, restorative use of her power—the polar opposite of the “cate breaks people” narrative. especially coming immediately after the “leave me to die” spiral, this is the first concrete demonstration of cate attempting reparation rather than self-annihilation or obedience. it’s a micro-choice toward good, and it plants the seed for her later, bigger choices. removing it robs her arc of one of its clearest “i can use this to help” datapoints. without this moment, casual viewers slot dusty into the evil cate montage in their heads. with it, you’re forced to hold the tension: she has hurt people and she’s capable of healing/undoing harm.

✎ NOTES

cate isn’t begging, deflecting, or hiding behind emma. she’s staring sam’s rage in the face and accepting the consequences of her actions. remove it and she reads as a passenger in the scene, not an agent who owns what she did. it’s not a death wish—it’s consent to judgment. she’s saying, “i know i hurt you. if you need to hurt me back, i won’t run.” that’s the opposite of the “unrepentant evil” reading some viewers carried into season 2. in the aired cut, emma does all the de-escalation, sam verbalizes harm, and cate’s silence gets conflated with refusal to take responsibility. the script’s version balances the triangle: cate accepts blame, emma redirects sam from retribution to restraint, and sam chooses not to become what hurt him. when later scenes play with cate’s defensiveness, the missing s1 breadcrumbs (the apology beats, the “i can’t,” the “i don't want to wake up,” and this “do it”) vanish from the ledger. the net effect is a subtle character assassination by subtraction: cate loses her textually stated remorse and choice-for-good moments, which makes her season 2 self initially read differently.

✎ NOTES

kinda wish they hadn’t cut those cute little moments of dialogue between marie and cate…they add such warmth to their dynamic.

✎ NOTES

interesting detail: in this episode cate is referred to as a “pusher”, but later the scripts frame her as a full telepath—almost like the writers wanted to slowly “reveal” the full extent of her powers.

✎ NOTES

this little exchange is honestly hilarious, and it works as a nice reminder that cate and andre were friends before anything else. the mix-up feels like one of those goofy inside jokes that only comes from shared history, and it makes their relationship feel more grounded in normalcy amid all the chaos.

✎ NOTES

this moment is telling for jordan’s dynamic with the group—they don’t pull their punches, even with friends. the line lands harshly, and the script itself makes clear andre is visibly shaken by it. it shows how jordan’s way of handling tension often comes across as cutting, confrontational humor that leaves real bruises.

✎ NOTES

plays out almost exactly like the final cut, but the action lines offer a little more framing that emphasizes just how casual yet devastating cate’s delivery is. she drops trauma like it’s nothing, while everyone else is left reeling—which speaks volumes about how much she’s endured. cate has lived through so much that she just rolls with the punches and “deals” with it, almost as if she’s become numb to her own pain. there’s also the haunting sense that she views these moments as a kind of punishment for her sins, something she believes she deserves.

✎ NOTES

this is especially insightful because it shows how cate actively resists being seen as a victim. despite what people love to say about her “victimizing herself,” the script makes clear that she does the opposite: the moment her guard slips and people see behind her perfect mask, she immediately recoils, it’s like the moment she lets herself show vulnerability, she immediately panics—convinced that if others glimpse her softness and pain, they’ll see her as weak. it’s a defense mechanism, not an appeal for pity.

✎ NOTES

cate explicitly telling jordan “i loved luke. so did andre” is fascinating. it almost reads like she feels the need to prove her grief and her love—to assert she isn’t the heartless villain jordan (and others) might paint her as. this moment also could have created a poignant parallel between cate’s losses and jordan’s “loss” of marie in early s2, potentially setting the stage for jordan to better understand where cate’s actions and motives stemmed from.

✎ NOTES

this scene really underlines that cate is pained by the act of wiping marie. her dialogue and the action lines make it clear she wishes things could be different. that distinction matters, because it challenges the common misconception that she was acting purely out of her own will or maliciously. instead, the script supports the idea that cate is following shetty’s orders—torn up inside, but still forced to comply. the addition of the tear of blood makes it even more visceral, showing how much the act physically and emotionally costs her.

✎ NOTES

this scene was cut entirely, but it’s telling in what it reveals: cate’s first instinct is to seek out comfort. the tragedy is that the only person she has to turn to for that comfort is also the one pulling her strings and forcing her hand. It underscores the cruel cycle she’s trapped in—yearning for safety, but only able to find it in the person manipulating her most. the black-and-white imagery i chose for this scene reinforces its absence from the final cut, almost like the erasure of a crucial insight into cate’s loneliness and dependency.

✎ NOTES

this first (cut) scene is crucial for showing how much cate has unraveled. she’s so wracked with guilt that she comes to shetty begging to stop. it underlines that she’s not willfully complicit. she’s desperate. (and yes—her asking for “three sugars” feels vindicating, tying into the headcanon of mine that she craves sweetness she was long denied as a locked-away child.)

✎ NOTES

cate can’t even look at shetty, framed like a child afraid of disappointing their mother. this shows just how deep shetty’s approval runs in cate’s psyche—the last time she disappointed a parent, she was locked away and isolated. that fear drives her compliance. her insistence that all she’s ever wanted to do was help her friends is devastating. she realizes she’s hurting them instead, but shetty’s manipulation and cate’s fear won’t allow her to walk away. (the action line noting she could send shetty to her death with a touch hits even harder knowing that’s how things eventually play out.)

✎ NOTES

nearly identical to the final cut but kept here for context as the fourth scene is especially telling.

✎ NOTES

shetty explicitly invokes luke and sam, twisting their fates into a manipulative rationale—“look what happens when you stop helping.” it’s framed almost like a guilt trip: if she stopped and tragedy struck them, then she wouldn’t want the same thing to happen to her other friends, right? that subtle but devastating tactic preys on cate’s grief and loyalty, making her believe her obedience is the only way to protect the people she loves.

the script notes that cate lacks the emotional bandwidth to resist, which is profound: shetty was the first person to “care” since cate was nine years old. that emotional deprivation stunted her maturity, leaving her stuck in an endless cycle desperately craving (parental) love and approval. therefore, cate clings to any perceived feeling of love or acceptance shown toward her, even if it comes from harmful people—especially when those people are powerful, capable of protecting and providing for her in ways she’s never known. the description of this as a “bates-esque” moment and the explicit framing of cate’s situation as impossible is vital. it undercuts the simplistic argument that cate could have easily freed herself when the reality is far more complex and tragic.

✎ NOTES

cate’s body language here is crucial—her puffy face betrays that she’s been crying, but she steels herself before knocking on andre’s door. this visual choice highlights how she refuses to appear too weak or vulnerable, even in front of one of the only people she’s closest to. it reinforces the tragic reality that cate hides her pain even from those who care for her, keeping the most vulnerable parts of herself tightly guarded.

✎ NOTES

the inclusion of cate dry-swallowing a pill would have been vital to the audience’s understanding of her state of mind. even while reaching for comfort with andre, she’s still obeying indira—clinging to shetty’s manipulative teachings as “truth.” cate’s compliance with continuing the pills shows that she genuinely believes indira knows best, underscoring how deeply the conditioning has taken root. it also illustrates the double-bind she’s trapped in: she wants to be loved and to feel safe with andre, but she can’t break from the control that keeps her harming herself in the process.

✎ NOTES

mostly for context, but there’s one telling detail: andre assumes cate just doesn’t want to talk about it. in reality, she’s silently drowning. that gap between what she feels and what she allows others to see once again underscores how deeply she hides her pain, even from those closest to her.

✎ NOTES

this moment is crucial. cate’s inner thoughts spell out the tragic paradox of her character: she feels like a monster, and always has despite her desperation to do good and her longstanding belief that she was doing good. she’s terrified that when her friends inevitably find out what she’s been doing, they’ll hate her—but she still wants to confess. she’s holding onto the fragile hope that maybe, just maybe, they’ll understand the impossible pressure she’s been under, and the way shetty manipulated her choices. this insight makes her feel far less like an intentional traitor and far more like a cornered girl suffocating under guilt and secrecy.

cate’s love confession to andre hits so differently when read through the lens of her history. she has never experienced unconditional love. even with indira, while cate believes it to be unconditional, the audience can clearly see that it’s manipulation: shetty’s “love” is conditional, transactional, and rooted in using cate as a weapon until she’s no longer useful. because that’s the only model of love cate has ever known, it makes sense that when she tries to express love herself, it comes out tangled in the same patterns—part genuine, part desperate, part manipulative. so when cate confesses in return to andre, it isn’t the simple purity of “i love you.” it’s laden with subtext: please don’t hate me when you find out what I’ve done. she’s essentially trying to brace him for the inevitable fallout, as a last defense against the heartbreak she knows she’s about to cause. she’s hoping that if he believes her love is real, he might understand her actions and see her as more than the betrayal, that he will hopefully interpret her eventual confession as something born out of desperation, not malice. it’s tragic, because even her most vulnerable expression of love is shaped by the conditional, manipulative versions she’s been shown.

✎ NOTES

then the final moment is all about timing and inevitability. cate finally steels herself to confess, to tell andre the truth she’s been holding back—and then jordan’s text cuts her off. the script explicitly notes that cate is once again faced with an impossible choice. this phrasing is so important because it reinforces the central tragedy of her story: no matter what she does, she’s trapped in situations where every option feels damning. it’s not that she won’t confess—it’s that every chance she gets is ripped away from her, leaving her caught between silence, guilt, and the looming fear of losing everything she holds dear.

✎ NOTES

it’s a real disservice that the line about cate protecting everyone (not just andre) was cut. without it, her actions are easier to misinterpret as selfish or limited to her relationship. keeping that detail would’ve underscored that she genuinely wanted to protect all of her friends, showing that her choices weren’t born of malice or indifference, but of desperation and misguided love.

✎ NOTES

the script direction that Andre “won’t ever forgive her” is fascinating. it could be read as cate realizing this through her own power (a mind-read) and resigning herself, or as a meta stage direction for us—signaling the weight of her betrayal and how final andre’s hurt feels. that ambiguity is powerful, and the final cut loses some of that nuance. instead of just “andre hates cate now,” it adds tragic depth: cate believes she’s permanently lost the love of the person she tried hardest to protect.

andre calling cate a monster lands harder in this because the action lines earlier show she’s already primed to see herself that way. the tragedy is that she isn’t the monster—she’s been twisted into believing she is. this doubles down on her self-perception, reinforcing why she breaks so completely in this scene.

✎ NOTES

the “potential key memories” section highlights just how much was streamlined (or outright rewritten) during production...

andre and marie as joint recruiters of emma: final cut makes it entirely andre, but here marie shares that agency, which alters the group dynamic. the “brainiac” element. likely a scrapped subplot that may have tied into the woods surveillance or tech but i don’t think we lost much with it’s removal. stardust motel scene with andre & cate. potentially swapped with emma/sam at the drive in theater in the final version, but this draft suggests a whole other scene was originally considered. luke’s parents visit: interesting divergence that ties andre into the story more so in the final version. the affair clarification: the appendix further solidifies that andre and cate’s affair wasn’t a one-off and presumably wasn’t hidden from andre via memory wipes. this undercuts the interpretation that cate was repeatedly manipulating andre into cheating without his knowledge, or attempting to absolve him of the guilt of it. instead, it makes it clear he was a willing, complicit participant at one point and likely for an extended period of time was purposefully going behind luke’s back—even if he later told tek knight otherwise, which hints that cate must have wiped him of all those memories at some point.

courtesy of the WGA library<3

EPISODE 1 | EPISODE 2 | EPISODE 3 | EPISODE 4

EPISODE 5 | EPISODE 6 | EPISODE 7 | EPISODE 8

DISCLAIMERS :

the majority of this content is cate-centric and organized by episode. some episodes naturally contain far more material than others.

the original scripts remain unaltered in every respect—no changes were made to dialogue, description, or structure.

much of what’s included consists of scenes and dialogue that were cut during post-production and therefore do not appear in the final aired episodes.

for accessibility and distribution purposes, the scripts have been reformatted and laid out manually—as photographing or scanning the original documents was not allowed.

the goal of this project is to provide greater context for cate’s character—her motivations, choices, and emotional depth—through material not visible in the final edit.

i am inviting discussion into this space. however, blatant hate toward cate, maddie, or myself WILL result in an immediate block. please do not engage in bad faith or with harmful intent.

✎ NOTES

not much to add on the first scene, just a small change in dialogue that i found interesting, as they cut the part where she calls andre an asshole.

✎ NOTES

cate’s awkwardness with comfort really stands out—she doesn’t know how to console others because she’s spent so much of her life isolated, without compassion directed toward her. so when someone finally leans on her, she clings to it in her own way, even if it feels unnatural to her.

✎ NOTES

cate is also shown as the one specifically tasked with escorting the cardosa family to safety. it’s a small detail, but it frames her as someone trusted with responsibility and actively protecting others.

✎ NOTES

at this point, andre clearly believes cate has never used her powers on him or even threatened to—which makes this moment especially serious for her. what’s clear, though, is that she doesn’t want to follow through, and instead her desperation leads her to distract him with sex in order to stop him from doing something reckless.

✎ NOTES

the final scene’s order differs slightly from canon: here, cate says “i can’t lose you” after the initial kiss, whereas in the show it comes before. while this doesn’t change her motive much, andre leaning away is an interesting detail—suggesting he wasn’t planning on kissing her or felt it would be wrong. cate clinging to him in this way reads as a move rooted in grief: after losing luke, andre was the closest person she had to anchor to for comfort.

✎ NOTES

the “intercourse” line is a gem—cate awkwardly blurting it out and then berating herself immediately after. maddie’s expressions in the final cut probably carried that same awkward self-awareness without needing the extra dialogue, which might explain why it was trimmed. but i wanted to include it anyway because it’s one of my favorite line deliveries of hers despite being so simple.

✎ NOTES

most notably, this establishes that cate was SIX years old when the caleb incident occurred, which would mean she was confined from ages 6 to 17—ELEVEN years of isolation. later episode scripts retcon this (as well as show canon) to list her as nine at the time, locked up for nine years before indira meets her at 17. still a little off mathematically, but it at least aligns more closely with the established timeline. though, i would like to note that this seems to be a bit of a trend…the script also lists the scene with cate comforting luke after sam’s “death” as taking place two years prior to the current timeline but the show canon states it as happening three years prior. this is likely due to a disconnect between the various writers, as they’re not consistent across each script…

✎ NOTES

the closing action lines are telling: they show how both cate and marie are haunted by the “loss” of their parents, though their grief manifests in very different ways. it’s a small but meaningful parallel between them.

✎ NOTES

this scene would’ve been helpful to keep—it highlights how when cate uses her powers non-consensually, it’s often in moments of distress where she isn’t thinking clearly, rather than calculated malice. this also rings true for the stairwell scene with the woods guards—though there were no major changes worth noting in that scene which is why it’s not included in this project.

✎ NOTES

i also wanted to include the description of cate’s dorm room simply because it’s sweet that the script takes the time to detail her space—the little touches really add personality and grounding to her character.