(1/2) A note to anyone writing a scenario where the state of someone's living space is used to deduce that they have a hoarding problem and/or how severe that problem is: the conditions described in that post can also be caused by other things, some medical and some not. Due to multiple physical and mental disabilities, amongst other things, most of my living spaces over the past few years could easily be mistaken for the living space of someone with a mild-to-moderate hoarding problem.
(2/2) Every time an MH professional has assessed my situation theyâve agreed that I donât have a hoarding disorder. Other people often think I do, especially if theyâve known someone with a hoarding disorder before, because it looks similar. So it could be a plot point for someone to wrongly assume a hoarding disorder when thereâs a different cause, or the other way around - someone assuming a different cause because they donât notice the hoarding disorder.
I did mention in my Hoarding Demystifying the DSM-5 post that in order to be diagnosed with hoarding disorder, the symptoms cannot have been caused by a medical condition or other mental illness, but it bears repeating.
Here are some other explanations for hoarding behaviors that would not qualify for a diagnosis of hoarding disorder:
The character is too depressed to perform any cleaning behaviors or maintain their living area. Trash accumulates because they are unable to muster the energy to empty their trashcans.
The character is an avid collector who has no problems discarding or selling their less valuable possessions.
The character has Prader-Willi syndrome, a genetic disorder that causes hoarding behaviors in almost 60% of cases.
The character has temporarily taken in a great number of abused or unwanted pets, but gives them up to the appropriate shelters at the first opportunity.
The character is delusional and refuses to throw anything away because they believe that other people will collect DNA from anything the character has touched, and will use it for nefarious purposes.
Hoarding disorder can only be diagnosed when there is no better explanation for the characterâs motivation or description of the characterâs symptoms than the criteria listed in the DSM-5. See my post here for my breakdown of the criteria.