THE WAITING GAME || J.P
a/n: i am honestly not sure how to feel about this but if you love it, iâll end up loving it. Honestly its giving jeff buckleyâs yearning.
summary: James Potter touches you like it means nothing. You feel it like it means everything. Best friends caught in the in-between. Too close to be casual, too scared to be honest. Itâs all glances that linger too long, hands that almost hold, and words neither of you are brave enough to say. But how long can you keep waiting for someone whoâs already halfway yours?
including: Slow emotional, mutual pining, angst, no explicit content or character death
word count: 2k+
James Potter always touches you like it means nothing.
An arm slung over your shoulder. A hand on your arm when heâs laughing too hard at Sirius. His chin on your shoulder as he reads your Herbology notes upside down. Youâve learned to breathe through it. To pretend your skin doesnât buzz every time heâs close.
Youâre best friends. You donât ruin that.
But itâs hard.
Especially when he curls up next to you on the Gryffindor common room couch and falls asleep halfway through some dull Astronomy chapter you offered to read out loud. His head is on your chest, soft snoring, lips slightly parted. You donât dare move.
You also donât sleep.
You stare at the ceiling for two hours and wonder if he hears how fast your heart beats when heâs this close.
⸝
You get good at hiding it.
The longing. The way you look for him in every hallway, laugh a little louder when heâs nearby. The way you watch his hands, his long fingers, calloused knuckles, a freckle on his middle knuckle you once counted just to distract yourself.
He talks about girls sometimes. You pretend not to care.
âYou think Smith likes me?â he asks one afternoon, sprawled on your bed eating half your chocolate stash.
You shrug. âProbably. Youâre loud. People notice loud.â
âYou say that like itâs a bad thing.â
âDo I?â you joked.
He throws a pillow at you. You throw it back.
⸝
One morning, heâs already at your table in the library when you arrive. Thereâs an extra quill waiting for you, your favorite fruit chews, and a note folded in half.
âThought youâd forget your stuff. You always do.â
You roll your eyes but keep the note.
You tuck it in your pocket and read it again three times during History of Magic.
He never mentions it.
⸝
Sixth year feels heavier.
Heâs taller. His voice is deeper. Lily Evans finally starts looking at him the way heâs always looked at her. It makes your stomach twist.
You hate that you see it. That he doesnât seem to care as much anymore. Or maybe heâs just tired of waiting for her, the same way youâre tired of waiting for him.
You sit beside him in Transfiguration and pretend it doesnât mean anything when your knees touch.
You lend him your scarf one day when he forgets his. He forgets to give it back for a week. When he does, it smells like him.
⸝
You tell yourself youâre fine with this.
This limbo. This almost.
He doesnât say anything, and neither do you.
Because how could you? What would you even say?
âI think about kissing you every time you lean too close.â
or something even better
âI feel like Iâm falling in love with someone who thinks of me like a place to rest, not stay.â
Youâd sound crazy. Mental.
But worst of allâ youâd lose him.
So you smile. Laugh. Let him get close, but never close enough.
You wait. And wait. And wait.
⸝
It changes one night in November.
Itâs late. Past curfew. Youâre both on the Quidditch pitch, lying in the middle of the grass after James dragged you out for âfresh air and perspective,â whatever that means.
Youâre lying side by side, his fingers close to yours. Not touching. Just close enough to feel the warmth radiating like a furnace.
He sighs. âEverything feels like itâs moving too fast lately.â
You glance at him. âWhat do you mean?â
âI dunno. Lily. School. Life. Everything feels like itâs on the edge of changing and I canât tell if thatâs a good thing.â
You chew your lip. âMaybe it is.â
He turns his head toward you. âWhat if I donât want it to change?â
You look at him.
And you say the bravest thing youâve ever said âThen tell it to stay.â
James blinks.
You keep going, even though your chest feels like itâs caving in. âSometimes⌠I feel like Iâm standing still and everything else is moving on without me.â
Heâs quiet.
And then he whispers, âMine doesnât move without you.â
You stare at him. His voice is low. Vulnerable. Like heâs saying more than he knows how to say.
âJamesââ
âI think about it,â he says suddenly. âUs. Sometimes.â
Your heart stutters. âOh.â
He laughs softly. âThatâs all youâve got?â
âWhat do you want me to say?â
âI donât know,â he says. âThat you think about it too.â
You look down. âI think about it all the time.â
Heâs still. Like heâs scared to move, scared itâll break whatever moment this is.
But then he reaches out â slowly â and takes your hand.
Just that.
Not a kiss. Not a confession.
Just your hand in his.
And somehow, thatâs everything.
⸝
After that night, nothingâs different.
And yet everything is.
He still jokes. Still ruffles your hair. Still falls asleep beside you with a book open in his lap. But now, his fingers find yours under the table. His arm lingers around your waist longer than it should. And when he smiles at you, itâs softer.
You still donât talk about it.
Neither of you are ready.
But when you see Lily Evans look at him and he doesnât look back, you feel something loosen in your chest.
Youâre still waiting.
But it feels different now.
Like maybe â finally â heâs waiting too.
⸝
(James POV)
James Potter doesnât know when it started.
Maybe it was fourth year, when you cursed Mulciber for hexing his broom and then shrugged it off like it was nothing.
Or maybe it was fifth, when you fell asleep on his shoulder in the library and slightly drooled on his robes and he didnât even care.
Or maybe it was always there â this quiet ache that sat low in his chest every time you laughed and it wasnât at something he said.
He doesnât know.
He just knows itâs getting harder to ignore.
⸝
Youâve always been his soft spot.
He thinks he hides it well. He teases you like he teases Sirius. Shoves your shoulder in the hall.
But he notices things about you that he doesnât notice about anyone else.
You chew your lip when youâre nervous, even though it annoys you. You hate coffee but drink it every morning needing anything to wake up. You sleep on your side, always facing the wall. You pretend not to care when people hurt you, but you always go quiet after.
He notices.
He wishes he didnât.
⸝
When he talks about other girls, he watches you.
He doesnât mean to â he just does.
Watches how your jaw tenses, how your eyes flick down, how you suddenly start organizing your bag like itâs the most urgent thing in the world.
And every time, he feels like the worst person alive.
Because he wants your attention, but not like this. Not through jealousy. Not through hurt.
But if he asked you â really asked you â what would you say?
⸝
He dreams about you sometimes.
He never tells anyone, obviously. Not Sirius. Not Remus. Definitely not you.
But theyâre not always romantic. Sometimes youâre just⌠there. Laughing in the rain. Sitting on the Quidditch stands. Reading upside down with your foot tapping against his knee.
But sometimes, itâs more.
Sometimes, itâs your hand in his, your lips against his throat, your voice in the dark saying his name.
He always wakes up sweating.
⸝
When he finds you on the Quidditch pitch that night, something in him unravels.
He doesnât plan on saying anything. Just wanted to be near you. Thatâs always been enough.
But the way you look at him â like you see him, not the version he pretends to be which only makes it harder to lie.
He says everything without saying anything.
âEverythingâs changing.â
âI donât want it to.â
âI think about us.â
And then your hand in his.
Just that.
It shouldâve been too small to mean anything.
But it feels like the start of something heâs been running from for years.
⸝
He doesnât kiss you.
Not because he doesnât want to â but because he wants it to mean more than almost.
He wants to be sure. Not of you â heâs always been sure of you. But of himself. Of the version of him thatâs not just the Quidditch captain or the loudest in the room or the idiot pining after Lily Evans.
He wants to be the version of him thatâs worthy of your attention.
And maybe â just maybe â that version is already here.
⸝
Every time youâre near him after that, his whole body feels wired.
Like if you touched him for one second too long, heâd combust.
He doesnât tell you this.
He lets his hand brush yours under the table. Lets his fingers rest on your knee when no oneâs watching. Lets his shoulder bump yours when he sits beside you, like he canât stand the inch of air between your bodies.
Because he canât.
But he still doesnât kiss you.
Not yet.
Not until you look at him like you know.
Not until heâs brave enough to say the thing heâs never said
âItâs always been you.â
⸝
(Readers POV)
It starts with a glance.
Youâre in the corridor, laughing with Marlene, and James is passing by. He looks over his shoulder like he always does, like heâs checking youâre still there. Like he canât help it.
But then Lily catches up to him and links their arms.
He doesnât look back.
You laugh a little too loud after that.
Marlene notices. She doesnât say anything.
⸝
Later that night, youâre curled in a chair by the fire, pretending to read. James flops beside you with a sigh and that familiar look â one part affection, one part restlessness.
âEvans thinks Iâve been distant,â he says.
You donât look up. âHave you?â
He shrugs. âDunno. Maybe.â
You flip a page. You havenât read a single sentence.
âDo you want to be with her?â you ask, and it sounds calm, but your knuckles are white on the book spine.
James hesitates. âI thought I did.â
You nod, like it doesnât cost you anything. âWell. Let me know when you figure it out.â
You stand.
He grabs your wrist.
âWaitâwhat does that mean?â
You donât answer. You just look at him â really look â and see it: the confusion, the fear, the same ache youâve been carrying all year.
âYou donât get to hover near me forever, James,â you whisper. âYou donât get to want me halfway.â
Then you walk away.
⸝
( Jamesâs POV )
Sheâs pulling away. He can feel it.
Not all at once â no, that would be easier. But piece by piece. The long looks become quick glances. The silence between them stops feeling comfortable.
He misses her in the small ways first.
Misses how she always passed him a sugar quill when he fidgeted. How she said âyouâre fineâ every time he doubted himself â not in the loud, Gryffindor way everyone else did, but in a quiet, real way that actually worked.
He misses her voice.
He misses her attention.
But he doesnât say anything.
Because saying something makes it real. And if itâs real, it can break.
⸝
Sirius elbows him one day in the courtyard. âYouâre brooding. Stop.â
âIâm not brooding,â James mutters, lying badly.
âYou look like youâve just been dumped.â
James doesnât reply.
Sirius raises a brow. âWaitâdid you? Did you and Y/Nâ?â
âThere was no me and Y/N,â James snaps.
But the words taste wrong in his mouth.
Because maybe there was. Just in a way he never had the guts to name.
⸝
That night, he finds her by the lake.
She doesnât look surprised.
âI figured youâd show up eventually,â she says.
He runs a hand through his hair. âCan we talk?â
She stays silent.
âOnly if you stop pretending you donât know how I feel.â
James stares.
âIâve loved you since fifth year,â she says flatly. âAnd Iâve waited. And waited. And youâve spent every second dancing around it like it might ruin your perfect little world if you say something real.â
James feels like the windâs been knocked out of him.
âI never wanted to ruin what we have,â he says.
âWell, you did anyway,â she says. âCongratulations.â
He steps closer. âThatâs not fair.â
âNo?â Her voice cracks. âYou donât get to hold my hand like it means something and then tell people youâre not sure how you feel.â
James opens his mouth. Closes it.
âI wanted you to say something first,â she says quietly. âJust once. I wanted it to be you.â
Silence.
Then James says, hoarse, âI think about kissing you every time Iâm near you.â
She goes still.
âI think about how you smell like cinnamon and ink, and how you laugh when you think no oneâs listening, and how I started waiting for you at breakfast even when I wasnât sure why.â
He exhales. âIâve been in love with you so quietly for so long I didnât even realize it until I thought I lost you.â
She swallows. âThen why didnât you say something?â
âBecause Iâm terrified,â he says. âBut Iâm more terrified of never trying.â
A painfully long pause.
Then, finally, she whispers, âSay it.â
âWhat?â
âSay it. Like you mean it.â
He steps forward. Takes her face in both hands.
Iâm in love with you,â James says. âNot just in the way people say it. I mean in the way where youâre the first person I look for in every room. The one I canât stop thinking about, even when Iâm trying not to.
Then he kisses her.
And she kisses him back.
Itâs not soft. Itâs not careful. Itâs everything theyâve held back for years pouring out all at once.
It tastes like relief. Like maybe they were always heading here.
Like they were always going to break just to fall into each other.
leave recommendations in my inbox and check out my masterlist .á
a/n: i wrote this a 6 in the morningâŚi am running on fumes
tags: @lydiascabinsix @lydiasfalling @laufeysvalentine




















