I am TRYING to pick a scene from Secondhand for the commentary ask but there are just. All of it is my favorite. But I think maybe...the scene where Midoriya and Nana talk about going to fight villains, and the USJ attack?
me, rereading secondhand for this: wow i love this
i was going to start with just nana & izuku, but iām so soft for nana & gran, so i included fighting villains like you asked with a little bit of that dynamic! so of course this is going to be a long one i hope no one minds, i couldnāt help myself.
[Sorahiko] paused to look at Nana. "And you'll come, of course," he said, but it was half a question. From here, Midoriya couldn't see Sorahiko's faceāalmost pleading.
"I'll come, of course," Nana said softly to her friend. She turned back to smile at Midoriya. "Don't worry."
Nana and Sorahiko were partners, so this part is Sorahiko tentatively reaching out in this familiar-unfamiliar relationship. But of course Nana will go with them. TheĀ ādonāt worryā is directed at both him and Izuku.
Midoriya finally started working again as they stepped through the door, and ran to catch up, bursting between the two of them. He apologized hastily, and then looked at both of them with wide eyes.
"Don't- worry?" He looked at Sorahiko, flippant, and Nana, who was used to this kind of thing. "Wait, wait, what do you mean, don't worry? We're going to, you're taking me to fight, villains?"
I thought the first line here was a little bit funny, like Izuku.exe had stopped working once he heard they were going to go seek out and fight villains. Obviously, as we see upcoming in this scene, Izuku has a very different definition of villains, so he sort of shut down for a second.Ā
Heās super incredulous, while Nana knows Sorahiko is just Like That. Sheās not fazed at all, because theyāve known each other for years, and itās certainly something he made Toshinori do.
His voice grew small on the word villains. He was scared.
Nana frowned at the look on his face.
"Have a little more courage than that," she said, patting him on the shoulder. He flinched, and she pulled back. "I meanā Sorahiko used to make Toshinori do it all the time, when they were training without me. And I used to take Toshinori on patrol with me when I could. It's good experience."
Hereās the part where Nana almost-disapproves a little bit. Itās okay to be scared as a hero, but because a large part of it is fighting villains, she doesnāt understand why Izuku has such a strong reaction. It actually concerns her, because right now it seems like he might not be brave enough. They donāt know each other very well, so I thought this was a reasonable reaction, especially with how important One for All is.
But Nana is also very attentive.Ā
"Villains?" Midoriya said again. It was like he'd gotten stuck on the word and was now circling it, tethered by a line. "Don't you think that's a littleā I hardly have any control overā I mean..."
"That's why we're going with you," Nana said soothingly. "We'll make sure nothing goes disastrously wrong. Chin up."
On the other side, Nana knows a scared child when she sees one. Sheās definitely a mom, and someone who cares, so after she tells him he shouldnāt be scared she also tries to reassure him that she and Sorahiko both will be there.
And a little peek of Izukuās inner thoughts, as best as I can show them through Nanaās perspective. Heās freaking out a little.
"Villains," Midoriya mumbled. He wrung his hands together; he looked a little reassured by Nana's offer of safety, but not by much.
"Oh, get that look off your face," Sorahiko said, spinning around. "It won't be as bad as you think. You'll be fineāyou might not be able to take me, but you can handle a crook or two. It's not like we're facing S-Rank villains."
Color returned to Midoriya's face. "Okay," he said quietly, and that was that.
Now, Sorahiko does know about USJ (of course), so after Nana only semi-succeeded at reassuring Izuku he finally gives up and just tells Izuku itāll all be fine. No S-Ranks here. Itās the reassurance that he really needs.Ā āCourse, Sorahiko has to sound grumpy-old-man while doing it.Ā
She'd seen the way his brow had creased when Sorahiko had mentioned the villain classification ranks they all followed. Most villains, of course, tended to be on the lesser scaleāpetty crime using Quirks was much easier, but there was always going to be the villains lurking in the shadows. All for One, looming, the puppetmaster of a whole organization of crime that haunted the streets and back alleys of Japan. That crept its roots of corruption into every crack it could squeeze through.
She bit the inside of her cheek and closed off her expression.
A tiny bit ofĀ āworldbuildingā to slip in there, though this is more-so based off of what we already have in canon with the classification. Also, it makes sense to me that it would be common to have a lot of petty crime, such as the bag-snatcher or the thugs the League hired. People who donāt get to use their Quirks in the system and resort to crime, etc, etc, because the definition of villain is so loose.Ā
But then of course there are villains like All for One. Nana hates him. Deeply. So much that sometimes it frightens even her how angry she is, but she doesnāt want to show it in front of Izuku right now, so she closes herself off.
"I don't know about you," Sorahiko started, "well. I don't care what you do, but leave me alone."
He glanced at the time, then nodded to himself and disappeared. Nana laughed.
"I don't suppose youāre leaving me alone, too?" Midoriya asked, a little sullen, and Nana shook her head. She'd hardly done anything all morning.
Sorahiko just doesnāt care. Heās done with people younger than twenty for now. In case anyone was wondering, he went off to take a nap, leaving Izuku and Nana to their own devices.Ā
I just thought it would be a small light-hearted break in the somber tone of the conversation, before we go back to it.
"Would you," Midoriya began, then dropped his gaze. "Would you spar with me then?"
"I shouldn't." She shrugged at his pleading look. "Sorahiko's right. You need a break before we go out tonight. You don't want to be in a real fight and be dead on your feet."
When Izuku asks, Nana doesnāt agree to spar with him. Here, itās because she believes sheās not his teacher. His training should be Toshinoriās responsibility, and then Gran Torino because of the internship. Nana will help eventually, but to her, itās not her main role in the relationship with Izuku.Ā
They walked to the kitchen together. "I still don't understand why we're going to go fight some villains," Midoriya said offhandedly. "I mean, getting experience, sureāall my other friends are doing some light patrols, I think, but seeking out a fight?"
"Sorahiko can't just train you for the rest of the, what is it, the week? You'll get too used to his fighting style, and you'll get stuck. It's better if you're out there experiencing things yourself."
"If you say so," Midoriya said. She didn't think she was meant to hear that.
A little more slight disagreement, though of course from misunderstanding. Izukuās a little disrespectful at the end there (and even, a little hypocritical considering the way he gets himself into things) but his point stands - that heās concerned about a pro hero sanctioning him to go seek out villains, rather than how other pro heroes might work by assigning interns to light patrol, learning about agencies, etc.
"Can I ask you something?" Nana leaned back against the counter and watched Midoriya fill a glass of water. He handed it to her, then took another one out, and she nodded in thanks.
"Uh-huh," Midoriya said, filling his own glass.
"Why did you react like that?" Nana asked. "When we were talking about villains earlier."
Midoriya's face darkened. He stared into his glass, like he was looking for an answer in the way the water distorted his vision.
"You don't have to say," Nana said. "I understand being scared of villains. Everyone's scared. But you seemed to have a..."
She didn't know how to describe it. But she'd seen that look before on a few facesāand she'd seen it on Shinroku's face, struck pale.
Like I said, Nana gets that villains are scary. Of course they are, but it is a heroās job to face them. So she still doesnāt get why Izuku is acting like this, and why heās so scared, to the point where it reminds her of her own mentor facing All for One. (Haha, fun reference, yeah? Successor facing successor and predecessor facing predecessor.)Ā
"I don't think you know much about Class 1-A, do you?" He peeked at her face. "I guess you wouldn't know. Er, well... earlier this year, when we- when we went to the Unforeseen Simulation Joint, for training... the League of Villains attacked us. It wasā bad."
"The League of Villains?"
The League didnāt exist, to Nanaās knowledge, and sheās basically been given the Cliff Notes on everything happening. So hereās the start of the explanation... she hasnāt had a chance to learn much about 1-A or USJ or the League.
"That's.. yes," Midoriya said, "and they weren't just aā I mean, it was planned. They targeted us specifically. And the Nomu... Shigaraki..."
"Shigaraki," Nana said. She couldn't say she'd heard the name before; actually it was entirely unfamiliar to her. "He's a villain?"
God, Iām terrible, truly. Haha. The mention of Shigaraki... just a little bit of dramatic irony here where weāre all likeĀ āheās your grandson!!!! Heās your grandson!ā and Nana does not recognize the name at all. And this sets up for later: the only identity Nana knows of Shigaraki is that heās a villain.Ā Ā
"The leader, I think," Midoriya said. He tugged his lip between his teeth. "He was directing the others. He gave orders. And he hurtā it was re- really bad."
What Izuku was going to say here was how badly Shigaraki and the Nomu hurt Aizawa, but he couldnāt get the words out. It was really bad. I mean, timeline wise, Aizawa only got his bandages off basically after the Sports Festival, so the memories are still very fresh.
He tipped his head back and drank from his water deeply so that he wouldn't have to keep talking. Nana paused. She hadn't expected that.
"You're a first-year student," she said. "You..."
And now Nana is absolutely horrified because he is a Baby, U.A. Heās a baby!
"They want to kill All Might," Midoriya said suddenly. He set down the glass, and it rang dully. Water sloshed against the side. He gripped the edge of the counter with both hands. "And theyā it wasn't human, it was- it was- strong... I couldn't do anything!"
A chill ran down her spine as more and more of the story unraveled. A creature, barely human if at all, that Midoriya referred to as a Nomu. A creature that had been built to kill All Might.
And sheās even more horrified because thatās Her Baby. It does not matter that Toshinori is like, four decades older or so, because heās still her boy and they were trying to kill him. Specifically.Ā
Good day slowly turning to bad day.
"He beat it," Midoriya told her, but he seemed less happy about it than she would have assumed. "But... it was a real threat. It withstood him at a hundred percent of One for All.
āAnd that- that leader, Shigaraki, he would have killed⦠ā
Nana set down her empty glass. She lifted a hand, then remembered the way he had flinched when she had put it to his shoulder earlier and dropped it again.
Shigaraki would have killed Aizawa, and Tsuyu, and probably him and his classmates, and All Might.Ā
Here, Nana assumes Izuku would be happier because of the victory, but Izuku really isnāt. All Might won but the Nomu was a real threat to him, and his time limit was already so dangerously low. Izuku remembers All Might pushing himself past his limit.Ā
And back to earlier, Nana notices Izukuās reaction. She wants to comfort him, but she thinks he might flinch away if she does.
āIām sorry,ā she said, though it didnāt quite feel like enough. āYou shouldnāt have had to go through that.ā
He was a kid. Strong, yes. Smart, yes. But in the end, Midoriya was at most fourteen or fifteenāno one his age should have encountered and seen what he had just earlier this year. He was already carrying enough of a burden, she thought, the legacy of the number one hero and the heroes before him.
Not much to say about this part besides it reads as it is on the tin, you know?
Midoriya shrugged uncomfortably. āAnyway, thatās all.ā
That's all, like it was fiction, just a tale recounted. Nana didn't feel it. Horror was coursing through her veins. She couldn't even imagine what it must have been like for him.
It was true Nana had lived a rough life, but she had never faced anything like that so young and almost alone.
Nana adopts a child again. I think USJ was a really sad event, too, of course it shouldnāt have happened. And it was a bunch of kids who wanted to be heroes suddenly thrust into an extremely dangerous and traumatizing situation, their teachers were dying, and they were split up and scared and very much in danger.Ā
I tried to express that too, how horrifying it is as someone who is older than Izuku, to try and treat such an event so casually as a way of dealing with it. Like itās over, itās done. But itās really not.
She certainly has a hard time in life, but Nana sympathizes a lot because sheās never lived something like USJ. No one should have to.
"I'm sorry," she said again.
"It's over," Midoriya said. "Everyone lived, and recovered. So I'm grateful."
"It's good to be grateful," Nana murmured, bowing her head. Not everyone lived. Not everyone recovered.
And cut, here at least. Izuku doesnāt really want to talk about it too much more. Heās ready to move on from USJ, and get stronger... for himself, his classmates, and especially for All Might. And he really is grateful everyone came out alive though not unscathed.Ā
Not everyone lived, not everyone recovered. Tadao didnāt live, and Nana hasnāt recovered.Ā
send me your favorite scene/chapter from one of my works + iāll write commentary on it!