For the Writing meme, from bring your heart back (to my island): From: "It was better that way. If as the years passed..." to "...even if he would, given the chance."
Ooooh, yâall are going after all of the angst today. :D First of all, Iâve never quite forgiven @persian-slipper for making me associate the Indigo Girlsâ âGhostâ with TFA-era unrequited (or just unconsummated) Luke/Leia. That STILL hurts. ;)
It was better that way. If, as the years passed, people wondered why Luke Skywalker never married, well, it was easy enough to point to the old Jedi code. Easy to make a virtue out of vice. Easy to pretend that his heart was still his to give, and he just chose not to.
A little piece of his soul withered every time someone praised his dedication.
You ever write something that you wish you could take back after you wrote it, but you canât because itâs right even if it hurts? Here we are again, on the Luke Skywalker Oh-Shit-Iâm-In-Love-With-My-Sister Guilt Train.
He thinks Ben knew. As a child Ben was eerily perceptive. One afternoon, during one of the last times Luke had visited their home, as the two of them sat side by side in the study, Ben had asked, âDo you hate my dad?â
I couldnât imagine that little Ben wouldnât have picked up on all that pain flying around, even if he didnât understand it.
âNo!â Luke had laughed, because the idea was so inconceivable. Hating Han Solo for the situation made as much sense as hating the wind on Ahch-To for a sandstorm on Tatooine. âNo, Ben. Hanâs my best friend, my brother.â
âHe makes you sad, though.â
Confession: I like that wind metaphor a little too much.
âNeither of them makes me sad.â Heâd hugged the boy, who was often sad himself, and Luke didnât know how to fix it. âYouâre my family, all of you. That makes me happy.â
Luke had always tried not to make a habit of lying to children, but heâd discovered that it was sometimes necessary. The boyâs namesake would have appreciated the irony.
Poor Luke. Now he understands why Ben couldnât always tell him the truth about things. Also, I hope get a glimpse, somewhere in canon, of the relationship that Luke and Ben had, because I canât imagine that it wasnât close, and itâs gonna rip my guts out.
Ben had let it drop, but Luke knew he wasnât satisfied with the answer.
Luke still wonders what he could have said differently, that day or any other, to keep Ben firm in the light. He wonders if itâs too late to save him, and if he even would, given the chance.
I think ultimately, Luke would be in favor of trying to redeem Kylo Ren, because thatâs in his nature, but I think itâs going to be much much much harder for him than believing in the good in Darth Vader was. I think heâs going to struggle with it, a LOT. Vader may have killed Ben Kenobi, but thatâs nothing compared to the relationship Luke and Han shared. I have a hunch weâre going to see Luke struggle against taking the path to revenge in the coming movies.