March/April 2017: "Someone for whom the examination of life still offers the promise of revelation or escape.âÂ
Books Bought
None
Books Borrowed (all @ Multnomah County Library)Â
What Belongs To You by Garth GreenwellÂ
The Abundance: Narrative Essays Old and New by Annie DillardÂ
Youâll Grow Out Of It by Jessi KleinÂ
Elephant Complex: Travels in Sri Lanka by John GimletteÂ
Day Trips from Portland, Oregon: Getaway Ideas for the Local Traveler by Kim Cooper Fielding
Books Read
What Belongs To You by Garth Greenwell
Euphoria by Lily King
Sherman: A Soldierâs Life by Lee Kennett
What Belongs To You is certainly beautiful, with workshop-tight prose and smart provocative plotting; but reading it requires a certain amount of heavy emotional lifting. My time with the slim novel was peppered with gloomy sighs after devastating paragraphs like this one where the narrator talks to his younger sister about her difficult relationship with their father:
âThere was a note of defiance in how she drank, an assertion of adulthood, but also something desperate, I thought, an escape either from or to. Her estrangement from my father was recent enough that the loss still held a kind of electric charge for her, so that at times as we spoke I thought I could see her jerk with the pang of it. All my life, she told me in those first nights we spent together, speaking with the wonder of someone for whom the examination of life still offers the promise of revelation or escape; all my life Iâve lived to please him, she said, every choice Iâve made has been his choice, itâs like nothing Iâve ever wanted has been my own.â (pg 66)
Reading What Belongs To You means taking breaks from it on the Portland Tri-Met train to stare off into the middle distance while shaking your head to marvel at what insights are achieved in so small a space. Consider this one about coming of age sexually:
âI grew up at the height of the AIDS panic, when desire and disease seemed essentially bound together, the relationship between them not something that could be managed but absolute and unchangeable, a consequence and its cause. Disease was the only story anyone ever told about men like me where I was from, and it flattened my life to a morality tale, in which I could either be chaste or condemned. Maybe thatâs why, when I finally did have sex, it wasnât so much pleasure I sought as the exhilaration of setting aside restraint, of pretending not to be afraid, a thrill of release so intense it was almost suicidal.â (pg. 122)
Rereading this passage, Iâm stunned by how clever âflattenedâ is in a sentence about sex, and those poetic turns of phrase dot nearly every page. If you can bear the weight, Greenwell rewards you deeply.
I also took breaks while reading Sherman: A Soldierâs Life, but for entirely different reasons. This time it was to consider fate and luck and life-defining moments and the patience to wait for them. I must share that part of my fascination with the man comes from the fact that itâs well established (but dubiously sourced) family lore that Iâm related to William Tecuseh Sherman, whose infamous March to the Sea in the Civil War brought about the frightful enactment of âtotal war,â where general destruction of military enemies and civilians was either encouraged or allowed. But the most amazing thing about the man that emerges from Kennettâs fascinating account in Sherman: A Soldierâs Life is that mere months before he was to become one of the most famous people in the country for his military exploits (and set up for life as a result), he was perilously close to financially ruin, and being unable to support his family. Sherman, as he had done so many times in his life, was living far away from his large family to work, and during this spell was having a particularly rough go of it.Â
âShermanâs diary in those spring months of 1859 tells just how far the officer and banker had fallen. He laid out building lots and fixed up his one-room dwelling: most of April he worked on a barn and a corn crib; on May 3 he planted sweet potatoes and tomatoes and on the fifth âwent to buy a cow.â He spend whole days hauling and plowing, days that started early: â6AM- Yoked upâ ran one entry.â (pg 84)
And yet within months he was called back into service, and toward âa profound change of fortune, one such as he could never have imagined.â (pg. 97) But what if he hadnât been called back? How many times would he have yoked up at daybreak before his finances and family imploded? And how did he speak about his life when examining it? I would imagine with the promise of escape far more than revelation. But Shermanâs life reminds us that opportunities come to us ill-timed and indirectly, and our patience and ability to withhold judgment are perhaps our most important virtues.  Â








