y’all when you’re talking about “omg they knew the whole time??? but that doesn’t fit????” in the last comic... i don’t think they did?
I think the bet was on, like, not when they’d come out but... when they’d get together. They all probably thought that Jack and Bitty had JUST gotten together, that day or the last night, and that they were telling them IMMEDIATELY. So, I think it’s a lot more along the lines of posts that had been made before where they knew Bitty was interested in Jack, and they were betting on when Jack would start picking up on it.













