watching Kim Fosterās video on patreon where she discusses Israel and Palestine and sheās pushing back on some of her commenters that basically disagreed with her when she said Jewish people were likely the first people to be racialised.
a couple commenters are saying black people were the first to be racialised and how the construction of blackness and black people was antecedent to how Jewish people would be treated. and Iām sorry but I just find that extremely fucking hard to believe like even with various slave trading happening on the African continent (I specifically mean the Arab slave trade bc that was older than European chattel slavery), I just feel like thatās bold to suggest that that slave trade influenced how Jewish people were racialised?
if Jewish culture is like over 2,000 years oldā¦and a major part of their history is having to migrate to escape violence from multiple groups of people in different ethnic regions bc theyāre this āotheredā race of people, how is that also not being racialised as an āotherā with its own complicated history? you could even say Romani people are right up there too with being racialised (separate of anti-blackness) and migrating and being enslaved before white supremacy even came into the picture.
that is just such a bold thing to say that racialising black people is what drives other dehumanising atrocities historically and contemporarily. not everything that black people have endured has directly effected something else. some historical events are entirely from the ethnic tensions and histories between groups in certain regions bc the world is a big fucking place and people arenāt immune to tribalism and xenophobia.
I really do hate this afro-pessimist point of view that anti blackness is the center of every system of oppression. itās really fucking not. learn about other peoplesā histories and develop your worldview. how can you flatten other peoples histories and say it all started with your suffering and how your suffering defines everyone elseās. and even further, how your suffering is necessary for the continuation of all other societies. how can you think that and not think you sound ignorant at best and solipsistic at worst?










