sports car- t. mcrae x j. hughes x reader
miss possessive au masterlist
masterlist
warnings: angst-ish, smut (roadhead, p in v, car sex) insecurity, incorrect timeline & incorrect new york/new jersey geography, more jack than tate this time! reader is described to have a larger chest, not reread at all LMAOOO
word count: 4.2k
When she woke up, she was shocked to see how dark it was outside, it had to be 6am at the latest. She turned to see Tate gripping the pillow she put as a barrier between them in the night.
It wasn’t to be a dick, it was just so Tate wouldn’t get attached. This is a one time thing, she told herself. She has no business getting involved with a straight couple, let alone a famous straight couple.
She lifted her head a little more and turned to see Jacks arm loosely around her waist.
She got out of Tate’s bed, pulling on her discarded jeans and sweater, before stepping into the en suite bathroom, flinching as the cold marble tile shocks her warm feet. She looks in the mirror, taking in her messy hair, sticky face, and dark circles. As much as she tried to stay confident for Tate, she wasn’t a particularly frequent lover; meaning she stayed up anxiously most of the night, scared she weirded both Jack and Tate out. She dipped her face into the bowl of Tate’s marble sink before splashing freezing water on her skin. When she rose she was startled to see Jack standing in the doorway.
“I swear I wasn’t snooping, I just wanted to wash the cum and sweat off my face” she said far too crudely.
“Didn’t think you were” Jack reassured, his hands resting on his hips, “anyways, I was gonna head out in like 30, if that works for you?”
“Uh I was just gonna catch the train, one is heading that way in like 15 minutes” she said with a soft, sleepy, almost awkward smile splaying on her lips.
“What? I told you I could drive you back” he said, concerned for her safety at this time of morning.
“Like a billion people use public transit a year, I’ll be fine” she assured, not wanting to inconvenience him.
“She would kill me if I made you take the train home,” he insisted again.
“Well you’re not seeing me again, so she doesn’t need to worry about me” she said, looking at him through the mirror, not having the confidence to turn around and face him.
“Does she know that?” He asked, his eyebrows furrowed and his lips subconsciously forming a pout.
“No, I think it was implied” she said, rubbing her now damp face.
“I didn’t think it was, I know I meant it when I said that we’d make you cum next time.” He said turning back, seeing Tate stir in her sleep, sleepily gripping one of her plush pillows imagining it was Y/N.
“I don’t do men” she said looking back at the counter, her hands gripping the cool counter like it was the only thing keeping her from diving off a cliff.
He stood there awkwardly, any follow up question felt invasive or invalidating. What was he supposed to say? Some shit about being able to change her mind? Ask her if she was sure? There wasn’t anything he could say to get more clarification, not that he was entitled to any.
“I’m gonna catch that train, if you’ll excuse me,” she said, her voice higher pitched and trembling, her comment clearly bringing up something she’s ashamed of.
“I don’t feel weird about you being a lesbian” he said, the topic foreign for him. In a field like hockey, he didn’t come across too many queer characters, out ones anyway. He knew women’s sports were different, that they had more gay people, but it wasn’t something he ever commented on, or really interacted with.
“I’m not a lesbian,” she said quietly, leaving the bathroom and going down the hall towards Tates kitchen, to locate her coat and keys.
A small part of her hoped she would lose him, he’d be too uncomfortable to follow her; he’d drop it, let her ghost both of them, trust that she wouldn’t tell a soul (which she wouldn’t). She found herself to be sorely mistaken, his feet tapping against the vinyl flooring as he follows her to the kitchen island.
“You can talk to me” he said rubbing his face, trying to find leverage in this conversation, “you explained how to eat pussy to me last night, you have something on me, now please, just talk to me” he pled, his voice higher, and whiney, drawing out his vowels.
“This isn’t a fucking competition, I’m never seeing either of you again,” she said still frenetically looking for her keys.
Tate emerges from her bed, her eyes droopy with sleep.
“Never seeing us again?” She asked with a whine, rubbing her hazel eyes with a loose fist.
She let out a loud groan at yet another person coming to talk to her about her whereabouts. “Babe, it was fun, but I’m not the person you guys need” she said, her voice softening to match Tates sleepy stance.
“What do you mean, not what we need?” Jack interjected quickly, he liked her more than he cared to admit. She wasn’t his normal type, not as thin, a little more rugged, far from the chic girls he had dated in the past; but, she was pretty, she was soft, kind, real. She was exactly what they needed, someone to care for Tate in a way he couldn’t, and someone to put him in his place, in a way Tate wouldn’t.
“You want lessons on how to make a woman cum without your cock, she wants to figure out if she likes having sex with women. That’s the job for a very well paid escort, not me,” she said, her tone sharpening as she turned away from Tate.
“I don’t want an escort, I want you” Tate whined, suddenly waking up at the idea of you being gone for good.
She let out a soft groan. She wasn’t particularly sexual, no matter how much her friends made it seem like they were all a group of whores. As much as she wanted to help Tate, if you could even use that term, she didn’t love the feeling of being disposable, of being at the bottom of the ranks, an afterthought. It would be Jack and Tate, always, with a random side character that appears on occasion.
“That’s sweet, baby, I’m not sure it would work,” she said, putting on a small fake pout, hoping she could get through this whole debacle without having to reference her sexuality, or her reasoning for not wanting to continue this.
Tate lets out a small, almost choked noise, “I feel mean for not making you cum” she frowned, letting out small sniffles.
She frowned back, opening her arms for Tate, knowing there was no way she was making the 7:15 train.
“You’re not mean, honey, I didn’t even take my jeans off last night” she laughed softly, rubbing Tates back and stroking her hair.
“I know, I know” she hiccuped, her sobs only getting louder, like she was blaming herself for Y/N not coming back, had she not been selfish, she wouldn’t be so inclined to run. Y/N looked at Jack with wide eyes, hoping he’d be able to reassure her, as he was playing boyfriend, but he remained unhelpful, mirroring her expression.
“Baby, it isn’t your fault, this just isn’t something I can do long term, that’s all, it’s all me” she promised, trying to calm Tate down, it seemingly worked, as her breathing slowed.
Jack stepped in, “why can’t you?” He asked, sounding genuinely curious, but she knew he only wanted to argue.
“I’m not a fan of being used as some sex coach, I, shockingly, have feelings and can get attached” she snarled, harsher than she intended, but making herself clear.
“Hey, hey, no one assumed you were some emotionless freak” he said, trying to reassure her, it felt foreign as their interactions only revolved around Tate.
“Do you still need a ride?” He asked, seeing that he needed to leave a few minutes ago, “actually, I don’t care, you’re not taking the train” he said. He walked over and gave a pouty Tate a soft kiss, “go back to bed, babe,” he said before murmuring something about convincing Y/N to stay.
They walked to her apartments parking complex, saving Tate and all of her guests from dealing with the awful West Village street parking. She followed him quietly, stopping at his car, some fancy sports car one of her friends boyfriends would totally drool over. He walked towards the passenger seat to open the door, before walking to the drivers side, without a word.
“Put your address in” he said, opening Apple maps on the touchscreen. She nodded, opting for putting in her college and walking the rest of the way home.
“You live in Smith Library?” he asked, squinting at the final destination.
“No, it’s faster for you and I could use the steps” she said, trying to ignore the shame burning in her chest, the feeling of embarrassment at where she lived. She wasn’t dumb, when she learned who Tate and Jack were she did her own digging. Read about Jacks hockey career, listened to Tates music; learned years of information, former relationships, if they were good at what they did (spoiler: yes they are good). She learned that she didn’t fit into their world at all. What business does a girl who deems Target sweatpants her ‘good ones’ have with a man making $8 million a year, or an international pop star who sings about people not making the cut to be deemed high class. Sure, it was just a line, something snide and snarky about an ex, but that didn’t mean it wasn’t a little true in her mind.
“I don’t mind the extra miles” he said, looking at her pouty thinking face.
She hummed giving a soft nod, changing the directions to her small apartment complex, adding an extra three minutes to the ETA. A part of her hoped the rundown brownstone would scare him and consequently, Tate off.
“All this fuss for only three minutes?” He asked teasingly.
“Three minutes is three minutes” she mumbled, crossing her arms and slouching low into his seat, seeing the time of arrival hit just over 30 minutes. She was dreading all nineteen hundred seconds of it.
He hummed, sensing her discomfort.
“Are you gonna talk to me?” He teased, grabbing her knee and squeezing, something she had never experienced at the hands of a man before.
“Talk about what?” She asked, sitting up a little straighter.
“Maybe this whole, ‘I can’t do it’ thing” he said, tapping on the steering wheel with an irritating nonchalance.
“What part of that is difficult to understand?” She hissed, tugging at the collar of her sweater, feeling like she’s choking.
“We both want you there, clearly you liked the idea enough to agree to it at least once” he said.
“And I thought over it and I don’t feel comfortable doing it?” She hissed, wishing she could jump out of the car, which doesn’t seem that difficult in stop and go traffic.
“What part? Can we fix it?” He asked, he had no idea why he was so committed to her staying with them.
“There’s nothing to fix! I don’t want to be a third, this isn’t the fucking big brother program. I’m not playing mentor for you” she said, her voice trembling, trying to sound more aggressive, but all she sounded was scared.
“Since when has this been you helping me?” He asked, his tone accusatory.
“Do you not remember me explaining why you should eat a girl out?” She asked, her tone still stiff.
“Okay, yeah, but that wasn’t what you were there for” he argued back, “just be fucking honest, is there anything we can do to make you stay?” He asked pleading, he didn’t want to see Tate that night with bad news if he didn’t try everything.
“I’m not fit to be a third, or some guest speaker in your relationship” she said, candid enough to make him believe her, hiding the other reasons she may not want to pursue something with them.
“What if it wasn’t a third? Well, yes you would be third, but it isn’t like, you’re just a stand in” Jack stammered, feeling nervous in front of her for the first time.
“We had sex once and you want to become a polycule, this isn’t Portland” she laughed, hoping the joke could lighten the mood.
“You’re into Tate, and you said you’re into men; what am I missing? Why can’t we do this?” He asked, his tone almost whiney; rationally he knew he shouldn’t he so attached, it was one night for him, and a couple nights for Tate, but the idea of losing her makes him feel sick.
“I’m hardly into men” she mumbled, shrinking in on herself. It wasn’t that she wasn’t attracted to Jack, or men for that matter, it was that she didn’t know what to do around them. She knew how to be good to women, how to be a guiding hand. Sure, submissive men existed, but that often involved a strap on and being called ‘mommy’ which she wasn’t fond of. All of that also ignored the glaring problem at hand—she was not rich, nor famous, she was actually poor and quite unpopular among her classmates, not someone who should be hanging around Jack Hughes and Tate McRae.
“What does that mean?” He asked.
“It means I don’t date men, kiss, sure, maybe the occasional blowjob, but I don’t see them consistently” she said, it sounded more promiscuous than she meant for it to, but there is so easy way to tell a man that ‘the idea of actually being attend you makes me violently ill’.
“Hm?” He hummed, an attempt to pry more information from her. Which shockingly worked, her anxious rambles tumbling out:
“I don’t know how to date a guy, what do you mean he makes the decisions, he’s supposed to lead, I know how to date girls, how to make them all mushy and soft” she rambled when it struck him, this was the exact issue Tate had when it came to Y/N.
“I can help you, judgement free” he said, placing his hand on her knee again.
She let out a small whine, “that doesn’t solve the fact that you’re both fucking insanely rich and I’m insanely not” she huffed, rubbing her hands over her face.
“In what fucking world do you think that matters?” He almost spat, appalled by the thought that he or Tate would be so inconsiderate about their differences, “we’re not stupid, you don’t need to worry about money, or anything like that. And you think we want another famous person for more eyes on us, fuck no” he said before she could even jump in.
“There is no way that this works” she said, seeing her apartment building coming into sight.
“Here’s my number, text me about this” he said, as he parked in front of her building, giving her a business card his agent forced him to get years ago.
“Nice cardstock” she hummed, flicking the sturdy paper with her finger.
“Yeah, yeah, send me a text when you get in” he said laughing as she flipped him off.
unknown number: it’s y/n, got in safe.
jack hughes: reacted ♥️ to this message
jack hughes: dinner tonight, you and me. battello, i’ll pick you up at 6
y/n: ?????
y/n: $50-100????? for italian??? can we go to a fucking olive garden dawg??
jack hughes: we need to work on this language thing
jack hughes: no. part of the dating thing is letting people take care of you.
y/n: the men in my life will venmo request for a $2 coffee, i do not need to learn this lol
jack hughes: fucking ridiculous, be ready by 6, dress nice but not too nice
y/n: reacted 👎 to this message
Regardless of her irritation for the restaurant he picked, by 6pm, she was ready. In a pair of bootcut, heather gray slacks that hugged her ass and hips, and a silky cream blouse, just low enough to reveal the black lace bralette underneath. As she finished curling her hair, her roommate, Charlotte, came in, greeting her with a harsh smack on the ass.
“Where are ya going?” She asked, hopping on the bathroom counter, the faux granite vinyl peeling up.
“Dinner with some guy, should be fine” y/n said, squinting at her makeup, feelimg ridiculous.
“Guy? Like a man?” Charlotte pestered while scrolling through her phone.
“Yes, a man” she groaned, before Charlotte changed the topic, shrieking at her phone.
“Do you know who Tate McRae is… obviously you do! She’s the girl that sings sports car… or greedy, you’ve definitely heard greedy—anyways, she’s dating the the it boy hockey player” Charlotte rambled as Y/N felt her life flash before her eyes, did she know something?
“Oh, cool, not really into pop stuff, or hockey” Y/N mumbled trying to curl her bangs as fast as possible so she could escape the room, and subsequently, her own anxiety.
“Let me deal with it, honey,” Charlotte said, pulling her closer to curl the hair.
“Thank you” she whispered relishing in her nerves for her date, and how culturally aware her roommate is.
By 6 she is racing down the stairs to Jacks car and tapping on the window mouthing “let me in please” before opening the door.
“Did you tell Tate we’re doing this?” She asked, shutting the door.
“Yeah, she’s thrilled, wants to see you later this week if you’re free” he said, starting to drive.
“Yeah, yeah, should have time this week” she nodded, looking at the road as he drove.
“You’re staring off” he mumbled a couple minutes in, squeezing her thigh.
“My roommate mentioned you and Tate, like out of nowhere, I just don’t want to get caught in the middle” she mumbled, turning her attention towards him.
“We’re not serious, you know, just fun and a little PR, nothing for you to get in the way of” he reassured, something he had done a lot of over the course of the day.
When they get to the restaurant she tucks into his side suddenly feeling a little shy. He squeezed her close, patted her hip.
“Your ass looks delicious in those pants” he mumbled into the top of her head before pressing a kiss into her hairline.
“Thank you” she laughed softly, before she could say more, a host came and led them to their table in a quaint corner. He ordered a steak, she ordered a light salad, and he insisted she order a soup as well (which was a good choice). She teased him asking if he needed help cutting his steak with his injury. Towards the end of their night after a few glasses of wine, eyes began to wander, he was focussed on her stained lips and her ample cleavage, she noticed how broad he was, how muscular his arms are. When the check is set down. Jack grabs it before she can even see it was there.
“What do you want to do after this?” He asked, grabbing her hands from across the table.
“Isn’t that up to the date planner” she giggled, surprised at how much she enjoyed their time together.
“Well, if I had it my way, we’d fuck in my car after this” he said, his voice barely above a whisper.
“That’s so crazy because that was my suggestion too” she giggled showing both rows of tweet, something she only does when she’s a little tipsy.
“Yeah?” He asked, writing the tip on the check, he could tell she was watching his hands, he wasn’t sure if she was reading the bill or imagining his fingers inside her.
“It’s rude to stare, sweetheart” he said standing up and keeping an arm out for you to take.
Once they make it into his car, they both ponder the logistics of car sex.
“Well we can’t do it here” she giggled still unbuttoning yet another button on her blouse.
“Windows are tinted, we can just go somewhere a bit less busy” he murmured, thinking about the geography of the area.
“well I’m not in high school so can we at least go to the parking lot of like a holiday inn and not a motel 6” she laughed, leaning forward to unbutton his jeans, already seeing how hard he is through the black denim.
“Fuck,” he groans, “yeah, yeah that’s fine” he mumbled, biting his lip as the cool spring air hits his sensitive cock.
“Can I?” She asked, spit already in her hand, ready to stroke him.
“Yeah, yeah” he nodded, before she gently sucked on the tip, moaning at the taste of his precum.
“Yummy” she mumbled to herself, “must be that healthy hockey diet” she hummed, stroking him with her spit coated hand, relishing in his soft moans and groans as he drove. She softly blew cool air on his tip inadvertently forcing his hips up.
“Fuck, please” he whined, she had the face of the devils whining under her, the power trip of the century.
She nodded, bobbing her head down to the base of his cock and back up, getting him used to the warm cavern of her mouth, before enveloping his entire cock in her wet, warm, mouth.
“Jesus fuck!” He groaned, tugging at her hair, pushing her head down as he pulled into the parking lot.
“Off” he said, tugging her hair and lifting his cock from her mouth. She rose with a small pout, “wanted to taste your cum” she whined crossing her legs, trying to relieve the ache between her thighs.
“Tough shit baby,” he mumbled, tapping his thigh for her to join him. She whined pulling off her blouse and undoing her slacks.
“I shoulda’ worn a skirt” she groaned to herself yanking them down her legs.
“Don’t deny me the pleasure of seeing your ass in those pants,” he pouted teasingly.
“You’re lucky we’re in a car, otherwise I’d test you on my lesson” she bit, after finally pulling the skin tight pants off.
“Next time” he said, watching her crawl over him, just in her bralette and tiny lace thong, creating friction on his needy cock as she settled in his lap.
“Lots of rain checking” she giggled, toying with his teeshirt, tugging at the bottom of it.
“Need to keep you coming back” he grinned, showing off his pretty boy smile.
She nodded letting out a small needy whine, “I’m holding you to it”
“Yes ma’am” he said, pulling the gusset of her thong to the side and slowly entering her, stretching the tight cavity.
She let out tiny gasps, from deep in her throat.
“Oh my god” she whimpered in his neck, trying to think straight enough to ride him.
“Yeah, feel good?” He asked, delivering harsh smacks to her ass, the flesh rippling around his hand, punctuating each smack with a squeeze.
“Oh god, please,” she gasped airily, feeling like her brain was becoming the soup she ate an hour ago.
“You need me to do the work?” He asked teasingly, knowing she was used to being the dominant figure in the bedroom. She nodded shyly, tucking into his neck, biting in the crook of his neck, gasping when he starts to thrust.
“Wanna see your pretty tits” he mumbled, pulling her heavy breasts from the tiny halter bralette.
“You’re gonna stretch the fabric” she whined through throaty moans.
“I’ll buy you a new one. We want to take care of you, what is so hard to understand about it?” He asked through gritted teeth, rubbing her clit, so she’s too overstimulated to argue.
She nods moaning out breathily, “need to cum” she whined, her tits bouncing with each hard thrust against her swollen gspot.
“Yeah, soak my cock, honey” he groaned, thrusting himself under her, watching her tits bounce. He stilled as she clenched around him, dampening her lips, panties, his pabts and his cock, not that he minded, as she fell from her orgasm, he held her up and fucked into her until he reached his own release.
“‘S too much” she whined into his neck, biting at the crook.
“Almost there, baby” he groaned, shooting rope after rope into her dripping cunt. He sets her on his chest as the both pant. Moments after she reaches between her thighs and scoops up a bit of cum for her to taste.
“Yummy” she mumbled sucking on her cum covered finger.
“Yeah, honey, give me a taste” he mumbled, rubbing her bare back as she reached between her legs and put her dripping finger between his parted lips.
“Mm you’re right, but maybe you just taste yummy” he hummed.
“You’ll see next time” she laughed.
“Next time” he agreed.
a/n - smut always makes me feel weird but i hope u enjoyed it!!! I hope i’m not overly freaked out lol also if u have any requests or comments abt this au pls send asks bc i love yapping














