jadagul replied to your post â____ arenât funâ
"Are you Thor, God of Hammers"? And I was just thinking about how great and thematically resonant that line was last night. Though it's the knock on the last Wheel of Time book that really gets me---that's on my shortlist of things I go back to reread when I want to cry.
Sorry about that. Half this categorization is very subjective - people will find different things resonated with them - but half is the somewhat more objective claim about what has stuck in the cultural consciousness (which has a tricky relationship with merit.) And I donât think itâs a hard argument that Ragnarok has many supporters, but few devotees. Itâs still âby that guy who did What We Do in the Shadowsâ and no one is agitating for the characters it introduced to be in future MCU films (I canât even remember their names.)
I specifically mentioned T:R because *I wanted to like it.* Not just a priori, but after I saw it, it had so much I thought I wanted in a movie. A truly revolutionary, apocalyptic message; its own cinematographic style and this who prog rock vibe. It had Loki and Jeff Goldblum. I wrote all this at the time. But to what end? I at least donât think about it one tenth as much as I do about Brigsby Bear, and none of the marvel fandom I ever encounter has conflicted with this.
When it comes to Wheel of Time I admit I was being more capricious. I havenât read any of the books so I only know of them from my friends talking about them. And they do talk about Wheel of Time a lot. Some friends of mine even wrote a good RPG based on them during the long interregnum. There was constant mockery of that one book where nothing happened. And a great deal of excitement and anticipation for âMemory of Lightâ the last book. But for the life of me I couldnât tell you what happens in it because no one talks about that book.
Concluding books of sagas probably suffer unduly from this problem though (see also early GoT vs recent.) It has to: satisfy the original audience without upsetting them, offer something new and revelatory, and compete with out it felt to read the first book. Thatâs a really high bar to meet, so itâs unsurprising that many final chapters are repellent to fans, or just good enough to be forgotten.