#ipaws

Hi y’all, this is just gonna be a short post about the legality of the EAS tone. 

As some of y’all might now, I’m a game developer, and I spend a lot of time playing and studying games. And I’ve seen a lot of misuse of “the EAS tone” in this, as well as online in ARGs or other creative projects, commercials, and movies. 

The FCC prohibits the use of actual or simulated EAS tones during non-emergencies and outside of proper testing or public service announcements. EAS tones are defined as: 

“An Attention Tone: which lasts between 8 and 25 seconds, depending on the originating station. The tone is 1050 Hz on a NOAA Weather Radio station. 

On commercial broadcast stations, a "two-tone" attention signal of 853 Hz and 960 Hz sine waves is used instead, the same signal used by the older Emergency Broadcast System.” 

The WEA also has its own standard tones that are protected by the FCC. Essentially, if it is at all a part of IPAWS standards, it is legally protected. 

So what does that mean for creators? 

It means that “The Walking Dead”, “Jimmy Kimmel Live!”, “Olympus Has Fallen”, “Lone Star Law”, and many other shows and movies have broken the protection of this tone, and subsequently faced very steep fines. 

It also means that SCP: Containment Breach, the Half-Life fan remaster Black Mesa, several dozen Fallout series mods, and many other indie games have also violated the terms of usage of the EAS tone. I don’t know of any games that have been fined, but if the FCC gets wind of these things, they very easily can and will fine the creators. 

This also applies to those “Fake EAS scenario” videos you can find on YouTube, ARGs, video art projects, and etc. 

While this seems harsh, it’s for the safety of those the EAS is designed to protect. False alerts can cause panic, and panic can have fatal consequences. These legal barriers are meant to protect the integrity of the tone and system as a whole as well. If we trivialize it as “just some sound effect”, when a real emergency happens, we will not take it seriously. 

Many of us, including myself, grew up terrified of the Emergency Alert System. The two-tone header tone was one of the few things that would cause me to run, screaming and crying to my mom. I remember one time in particular, I was home alone downstairs watching TV and a severe thunderstorm warning came across the TV, followed by the power cutting out. To this day, that remains one of the scariest moments of my childhood, trying to navigate my dark basement after hearing the weird, disembodied voice speak “a severe thunderstorm warning has been issued for your area.” 

As I’ve gotten older and gotten more interested in emergency preparedness, civil defense, and everything generally related to the emergency alert system, the sound doesn’t frighten me as much anymore. In fact, I actually kind of look forward to getting alerts, and in my free time, I watch videos of alerts. I have my IPAWS certification from FEMA and even gave a speech about IPAWS at my university. But with this, I’ve started to realize how incredibly broken IPAWS is. 

If you aren’t aware, IPAWS is our current national warning system. It was created in 2006, replacing the Emergency Alert System, which replaced the Emergency Broadcast System, which replaced CONELRAD. Replaced, however, isn’t exactly the correct term. IPAWS, or Integrated Public Alert and Warning System, is comprised of the Emergency Alert System, the Wireless Emergency Alert System, the Commercial Mobile Alert System, and local warning systems, including sirens, automated phone calls, text messages, or digital signs. 

The Emergency Alert System (EAS) is concerned with television and radio alerts. 

The Wireless Emergency Alert System (WEAS) and Commercial Mobile Alert System (CMAS) are concerned with mobile telephone alerts.

IPAWS works in a three step process. First, a local, state, territorial, tribal, or federal authority encodes a message in a format called the Common Alerting Protocol. Second, this message is sent through a gateway, known as IPAWS Open. It’s a secure, designated network solely for IPAWS. Lastly, the encoded message reaches the alert disseminators, which are the public systems such as the EAS, WEAS, and local systems. These systems decode the message sent and push it out to the public. 

In theory, IPAWS is a centralized, organized system for alerting the public of everything from inclement weather to biohazard attacks. In practice however, IPAWS leaves a lot to be desired. 

From its inception, IPAWS has been plagued by accidents and failures. From a Lady Gaga song playing during a national test to the ballistic missile alert in Hawaii, IPAWS is non-functional. I am writing this during a severe thunderstorm warning, and the EAS that scrolled across my TV started with the header noise, said “A severe weath-....The National Weath-....” and then stopped. Last night, an EAS test woke me up four separate times, and this happens almost every night. Sometimes, I get the alert on one TV but not another, or one channel but not another in the same house. I never get CMAS/WEAS alerts despite getting the monthly tests. Most of the time, even during tornado warnings, I don’t get any alerts besides for ones from the Weather Channel and WeatherBug. 

And I am definitely not alone in experiencing this. People across the country constantly report garbled alerts, tests at random hours of the day, or just no alerts at all. 

I want to like IPAWS, I want to support it and convince people who have lost their faith in the system that it is a vital program that keeps us safe. But increasingly so, it is failing to do exactly that. There is no reason why this system is so flawed. There is no reason why FEMA continues to ignore the glaring issues with IPAWS. It is an incredibly important system that keeps people alert, informed, and more importantly, alive, when things go wrong. This consistent failure to know is dangerous. 

CONELRAD, even in its infancy, even with its limited use and glaring issues such as requiring a radio to be on 24/7, was almost better than IPAWS is right now, and that’s...terrifying. 

"The national test will help ensure that Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA) and the Emergency Alert System (EAS) continue to be effective ways to warn the public about emergencies, particularly those on the national level.

If your mobile phone is on and within range of an active cell tower from a participating wireless provider, you should receive the national test. "

FEMA NATIONWIDE EMERGENCY ALERT SYSTEM TEST on Wednesday, October 4th at 11:20 am PST/2:20 pm EST.

From FEMA website: "FEMA, in coordination with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), will conduct a national test of the Integrated Public Alert and Warning System (IPAWS) on Oct. 4, 2023.

The test will reach millions of mobile phones across the country via Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA), radio and television via the Emergency Alert System (EAS), and other communication pathways.

Test will take place at approximately 2:20 p.m. ET on Wednesday, Oct. 4, 2023.