ALRIGHT LADS BUT WHEN FLINT FIRST GRACES OUR SCREENS IT GOES LIKE THIS...
The sail comes first, the disembodied concept of pirate. Then the name of Flint, of course: the sailors recognise his sail, and it scares them.
You know who that is out there? That ship flies the banner of Captain Flint.
Then we see his crew, or rather first of all we hear them. (I think this is important because so often in art that which is without words/is incomprehensible carries the greatest meaning, especially in revolutionary art and Black Sails is nothing if not a song for the revolution).
We see the blasts and death and violence, and then we hear their cries. An organised crew who know the power of fear and the unknown, who use their perceived monstrosity/otherness to deliberately intimidate - yells and rhythmic thumps, teeth, warpaint, bare muscled chests etc. Itās a carefully designed sensory assault.
[Incidentally, what I find most interesting about the crew in Episode I. is that almost immediately we are shown that being a pirate is not who you are or even what you do, it is a fiction designed to deliver to you the outcome you seek. A means to an end.]
Back to the captains perspective, and we see Singleton slicing and murdering as hard as he can. To the captain, this man is the embodiment of the idea that he has most feared; this man is a ruthless pirate captain. It is this idea of a pirate that he thinks will be his death, and this idea that we are, for a heartbeat, meant to think of as The Dread Pirate, Captain Flint.
This is where I come to the point of my ramble.
Because the thing is, whenever I watch Black Sails it makes me so happy and stunned to see the threading of themes right from the start of Ep. I. - themes of identity, legacies, the myth of the monster, what āmonsterā means, to whom, and why.
This one scene alone shows, in a burst of action, the freedom and protection these men represent, how they live in reality and fiction, and demonstrates the power created by the clever manipulation of both.
It is a wonderful, allegorical portrait of Captain Flint.
Speaking of - finally, we meet the actual Flint.
First, we see his action; the thrust and clash of a cutlass.
We then hear his voice. āItās doneā.
We see his head, a splash of colour, shrouded except for his eyes.
Itās terribly enigmatic and honestly, the green, his calm voice and his reason appear like a drop of beauty and steel in amongst the smoke and bloodshed.
Then he pulls away the cloth and we see Flint, finally (though of course neither we nor the captain actually know what Flint looks like, so he is still just his actions, shouts, the fear he musters and the men he commands).
So now we have the juxtaposition of a reasonable, articulate man - wouldnāt you agree? - and the chaos of pirates behind him, and yet despite appearing nothing like the frantic, bloodthirsty captain theyāve been fearing, heās clearly in command, and terrifying. So again, the apparent dichotomy of Civilised Man and Feral Pirate is shattered and muddled, the clear identity of this enigma is lost, blurring fear and reality and clarifying nothing.
Of course I love this because it plays right into Black Sailsā whole thing re. Legends and Monsters and Stories but I also love it because to me, this is a demonstration of the layers upon layers in which James has wrapped himself, in order to protect himself from the world, become Flint, and survive.
His first visible interaction is physical, and itās violence. (Come close, cross me, touch me and you will die).
His first words are spoken by a literal disembodied voice (I have no body, I have no identity).
He turns and is seen, finally, yet he is still hidden except for his eyes (and the eyes are symbolic of truth and protection all over the world. Perhaps the eyes belong to James but they see you far more clearly than you see him, and they see your cracks before you see his). (Also, and perhaps I am reaching here, but it struck me that green is often associated with safety and ambition and that is Flint. Thatās just exactly why Flint exists).
He has so carefully removed himself from the actual person that he is, that even when we see and hear him, we are really seeing the concept, not the man.
Heās a flag, the terror of the high seas, death and blood, a monstrous pirate, the clash of swords, ruthless, powerful, unknown.
Anything to be anyone other than James.
And thatās how we meet Captain James (McGraw) Flint and it breaks my fucking heart.
All credit to @jamesflintmcgrawhamilton for the beautiful gif, without which this post would just be a terrible, weighty block of nonsense.