Which Arthur Is It: A Comprehensive Guide
Do you get confused by which Arthur the post on your dash is about?
Do you start reading a post about a sexy BOS bad boy only to find out youâre reading about some random cowboy?
Or are you a RDR fan who has the opposite problem (for some reason) and gets annoyed when your yeehaw post turns out to be an ad victoriam?
WELL THEN THIS GUIDE IS FOR YOU!
***Disclaimer: I have never played Red Dead Redemption 2, I played RDR 1 for like an hour, and I didnât bother to do any research. This is just meant to be a little bit of fun, your game looks great, donât get mad.***
Ever since Red Dead Redemption II came out, I get occasional posts about Arthur that turn out not to be about MY Arthur, but rather about some cowboy dude, I guess. Itâs very frustrating.
Sure you could block the tag, but thatâs work. They arenât really hurting you, and if youâre like me and canât help but click on the super obvious âHEY YOU BLOCKED THIS ARE YOU SUUUUUURRRRE YOU DONâT WANT TO SEE ITâ thing that tumblr does, and would rather just scroll past, then you need help.
To that end, I have created this handy guide.
If itâs this handsome, brooding, sexy fucker, itâs Arthur Maxson.
(pic from the fallout wiki)
Please note the indoor landscape, the piercing blue eyes, the fresh and not at all scrabby looking haircut, and the distinctive leather coat with fur. So sexy. However the most defining feature is the scar, which he earned when he fought a deathclaw with his bare hands. His bare hands. Seriously, no wonder everyoneâs horny on main for this guy.
If itâs this rugged cowboy type dude, itâs Arthur Morgan:
Please note the outdoorsyness, the purse, the old fashiony hat, and the bandana. Now he is also wearing a leather coat with fur, so it can be easy to get confused, but remember the key feature: NO SCAR. Where Arthur Maxson battled a deathclaw with his bare hands and won, I think this guy just battled a bear maybe. Just a regular one too, not even an irradiated one. And he probably had a revolver. So thatâs important.Â
But what if thereâs no screenshot, you ask!
Iâm coming to that part. Hold on to your laser rifles, my darlings.
If itâs a text post referring only to Arthur, you have some cues.
How much he hates Synths, Ghouls, Supermutants, or Toasters
Then youâre reading an Arthur Maxson post.
Uhhhh.... bandits I guess
Maybe a lost son? Or was that the first one idk I never played it
Camping! I think thereâs camping in this!
Then youâve got Arthur Morgan on your hands.
Some other things to look out for.
Other people mentioned might be a good clue too.
Some people mentioned In Arthur Maxson posts:
People with cool sounding ranks like Knight, Sentinel, or Paladin
Some people mentioned in Arthur Morgan posts:
Other old timey sounding names.
And the final clue, is the topic of the post.
If the post discusses these topics, itâs Arthur Maxson:
Wanting to kill him, either for his coat or because they hate him
Just hating him in general
Mocking him for being too young
Hating people because they like him
Sticking up for him because someone said something bad about him and theyâve just Had Enough
If the post discusses these topics, itâs Arthur Morgan:
Deep discussions on his background
His relationship with Mary or John or whoever
His relationship with his horse
The time he skinned a deer
Remember these key features:Â
Arthur Morgan is the Player Character, so people naturally identify with him.Â
Arthur Maxson is an attractive NPC who gets an inordinate amount of attention in the fandom because some people think heâs hot and some people hate that other people think heâs hot.Â
Hopefully that helps you weary Tumblr scrollers sort the two characters out. I know it certainly helped me. REBLOG TO SAVE A LIFE
Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk
Yee Haw and Ad VictoriamÂ