if heather or hinako made a contract with Kyubey what would they wish for?
unprompted asks [always accepting] - @gracrofts
;; OHOHOHO you activated my tism!!!
I feel like I have talked about this before, but I'm too lazy to try and find the post if I did. But I think if I did, this'll either cover the same material or update those thoughts. I'm a sucker for Madoka AUs. It's so fun making up the bits of customization for characters, since so much of the worldbuilding for Madoka is based on symbolism and inner emotions.
Okay so for Heather. I think this one is one of the easier ones to base off, since Heather has a magical-girl-sona in the game you can unlock after your first playthrough. Her attire in that is alien themed, and she goes by Princess Heart.
In my AU, however, she would probably wear something more similar to her outfit in canon, but maybe doctored up a bit. Maybe something like Akira from the Magia Record story? She's very casual and punk in her attire, grungy.
She wished to stop her father from having nightmares, which backfired and instead opened up her mind to the nightmares her past self Alessa dealt with 21 years ago. She's able to manipulate nightmares and scary things with her magic, which helps her when fighting witches.
I think her main weapon would be a stun gun of sorts, which could freeze monsters temporarily until she can seal them or immolate them in her flames.
Her witch would closely resemble "God," appearing like a woman asleep with a deformed baby in her arms. If intruders wake the baby, the mother will burn the intruders to death. I think the best name for this witch would be MARIA - Witch of Hellfire. As a Doppel, she'd make Heather look bloody and covered in soot, turning her into a closer version of Alessa.
As for Hinako, she's a little more difficult. It depends on when she would have made her contract— if it was made when she was younger, or if it was made during the events of the game as a way to survive.
Going with the latter, I think Hinako would have wished to determine what happiness meant to her. As a vague wish, it gives her the power of quick decision making, but her anxiety over these choices feeds into the dark despair filling her town.
Her magical girl attire would resemble something like this. She'd carry a naginata, proficient at close up combat. Her Doppel would manifest as a bird with small, deformed wings and a fox's tails. In this form, she'd wear the fox mask Kotoyuki gifted her.
Her witch is pretty much just the Shiromuku. Faceless, half fox, trailing spider lilies wherever she steps.