Ok, so I've been doing a ton of research lately because I've been planning to open an Etsy shop, but yesterday I discovered this other platform called Goimagine and I NEED to tell y'all about it! I haven't actually joined yet (still working on getting my stuff together) but here's the info I've gotten from their website and a YouTube video I found interviewing the founder.
Goimagine is a 100% handmade marketplace. They don't allow vintage, print on demand, or drop shipping
They're completely human run (no pesky bots causing problems and taking your stuff down with no explanation)
A portion of all the sales made through their website goes to charities supporting children (you can see the specific ones on their website)
Whether or not you offer free shipping doesn't effect your search visibility
There are three membership tiers that include a monthly flat rate and a transaction fee. That's it. No other fees
All of your products are listed on Google so people don't even have to be on the site to see your stuff
They seem to be really focused on giving their sellers the best experience possible and the one video I watched talked about them having an election to vote two of their sellers onto the board of directors
They remit sales tax and calculate shipping for you (I'm not sure if you can print labels from their website or not)
They only operate in the US and there's an option on their website to shop by state so you can buy from local vendors
Really the only complaint I was able to find is that people weren't getting as much sales traffic on there as on Etsy. The company has only been around since 2020 though, so it's a much newer platform than Etsy and still in the developing phase. This means there are a lot fewer sellers and therefore a lot fewer customers, but it also means you have less competition. I found people who did really well on the platform and people who didn't make any sales at all, but I feel like that's probably just as true for Etsy, there are just so many more Etsy success stories because they've been around longer and had more time to build.
Also they don't seem to be trying to compete with Etsy so much as fill a gap they feel Etsy has left open. There's even an option to import your Etsy listings onto their site.
Anyway I think what they're doing is super cool and I hope to open a shop there either instead of or in addition to an Etsy very soon. I highly recommend checking them out!















