Full Organized Analysis: What Exactly Is GMK Godzilla?
1. Official Canon Facts (Toho + film dialogue + official books)
This is a second, distinct Godzilla (called “second-generation” in Toho Special Effects Movie Complete Works, 2012).
The 1954 Godzilla was 100 % liquefied by the Oxygen Destroyer; nothing physical survived.
The new creature is a living animal (a mutated prehistoric reptile, just like the original) that has been possessed and transformed by the restless souls of everyone who died because of Imperial Japan’s actions in WWII (Japanese soldiers + millions of Asian civilians).
The souls give him supernatural powers, white eyes, and a specific hatred for modern Japan that has “forgotten” the war.
2. Observed Behaviour Pattern (chronological)
Early film
Ignores civilian ships, submarines, fishing boats
Steps on a few houses in the Bonin Islands during a storm, then simply leaves
Stands motionless on the shore at night (Baragon fight) – looks lost, almost in a trance
Walks calmly through countryside, not rampaging (Mothra fight)
First two Guardian Monster encounters
Baragon: Godzilla is completely still → Baragon attacks first → Godzilla snaps and brutally kills him
Mothra: Godzilla is just walking → Mothra attacks first → Godzilla reacts and sadistically kills her → In both cases he does not initiate; he looks confused until something attacks him.
Ghidorah & final battle (turning point)
Sees Ghidorah flying in → immediately opens fire (first time he is the clear aggressor)
By this point he has absorbed Baragon’s and Mothra’s souls
From here on he is fully sadistic, gleeful, and proactive against military, civilians, and Ghidorah alike
End of film
Explodes, but his heart keeps beating on the seafloor → the collective vengeful spirit now has enough power to exist independently of the animal host
3. The Marvel 2024 one-shot (same exact heart concept)
The Hand feeds the still-beating GMK heart more blood + a piece of All-Black the Necrosword
Result: the entity loses all focus on Japan and becomes an omnicidal “God Butcher” that devours planets and realms
Even after Thor apparently kills it, the heart continues beating in Hel
4. The Four Possible Interpretations (all supported by evidence)
Innocent animal hijacked by souls (pure “forced into evil”) The reptile itself is neutral/confused. The souls are 100 % responsible for every act of cruelty and the Japan-specific targeting. The animal only provides the body.
Naturally malevolent animal using the souls as an excuse The second Godzilla was already a hateful, violent creature (like almost every other Godzilla). The souls simply gave pre-existing rage a direction. Once the souls are removed or overpowered (Marvel comic), the creature’s true omnicidal nature shows itself.
Symbiotic corruption – the feedback-loop theory (most textually supported) Animal = raw power, primal brutality, and the sadistic streak Souls = supernatural endurance, specific grudge against Japan, escalating hatred Every kill feeds both sides. The more the animal kills, the stronger the souls become; the stronger the souls become, the more they unleash the animal’s cruelty. By the Ghidorah fight the partnership is complete and indistinguishable. When you super-charge the heart with the Necrosword, the animal side finally overpowers the souls’ original focus and goes full cosmic destruction.
Fragment of 1954 Godzilla survived in spirit A tiny piece of the original Godzilla’s own pain and hatred somehow escaped the Oxygen Destroyer and merged with the Pacific War dead. GMK Godzilla is therefore partially the first Godzilla, willingly participating because he still remembers the H-bomb and Serizawa.
5. Final Conclusion – Why There Is No Single Answer
Shusuke Kaneko deliberately made GMK Godzilla alien and unknowable. Every single piece of evidence in the film supports multiple readings at once:
The motionless, lost stance against Baragon → supports 1 and 3
The gleeful sadism once fighting starts → supports 2 and 3
Never attacking another country → supports 1 and the souls’ agenda
Turning omnicidal the moment the heart gets more power (Marvel) → supports 2 and 3
The heart surviving everything → supports 3 and 4
The film (and the Marvel continuation) refuses to tell us where the animal ends and the collective oni begins. That refusal is the entire point.
GMK Godzilla is not just a monster. He is the walking question mark over who is truly responsible for Japan’s sins, the animal that carries them, the ghosts that scream inside it, or the unholy fusion of both that no one can ever separate again.
