Hii,
If your up for it could u write a fruity four x reader imagine based off of the song tongues and teeth by the crane wives where reader runs into a ex that used to treat them horribly and made them believe that all they could do was hurt other people triggering those old feelings leading them to pull away from Steve, Eddie, Robin, and Nancy
(Sorry for the long ask đ¤)
Poison (fruity four x g!n reader)
Or, You run into your ex and find yourself reflecting on your past self, do you deserve the love you find yourself surrounded with? (3.4k)
Anon, Sorry this took so long, I love the Crane Wives sm I was really excited by this request so I wanted to make it perfect and then it accidentally got really long and filled with irrelevant scenes that I had to scrap and will probably be posted at some point. I hope you like it lmk <3 Thank you so much for the request
Reader was in a toxic, abusive relationship (No scenes of this relationship and it is only briefly mentioned that it was abusive). Reader in this fic was mentioned to be an asshole in the past, but it's up to you whether she truly was or if she just thinks that bc of their ex.
Warnings: mentions of toxic, abusive relationships. Reader thinks she deserved to be hurt, the ex now has a baby. Ex threw things at the reader. Food, depictions of cooking and eating.
âYou remember the voices Eddie taught you?âÂ
Steve sighs into his bowl of lucky charms, stirring the spoon around restlessly. His cereal had gone soggy, something he hated, but he hadnât had a single spoonful since he sat down.Â
âI remember,â He mumbled, looking at the milk in his bowl as if it would conjure up all the answers of the universe for him. You rub a warm hand up and down his back to try and soothe him, it works, a bit.Â
Then Eddie's head is poking over Steveâs shoulder, eyeing Steveâs bowl in a way that you know means trouble. Instead of the usual playful spat, that always ends with Steve reluctantly sharing his bowl of cereal, Steve passes Eddie the spoon without argument.Â
Eddie kisses his cheek sweetly, rubbing his nose into the chub of his cheek before digging in. âWanna give us a taste?â Eddie questions, mouth full.Â
Steveâs cheeks are pink as he shakes his head, his perfectly styled hair not moving an inch. You can taste all the hairspray heâs used this morning. You keep your warm palm against his back, hoping some of it will seep into his bones and make him a little less tense.Â
Heâs been like this all week and you know he wonât be able to relax until the day is over. Getting a placement at a kindergarten had been all Steve had talked about all year, all he had been looking forward to. Now it was happening, he was terrified.Â
Today was make or break, it was his first attempt at a storytime.Â
He had spent a long time researching books with Nancy and had rehearsed reading the book to you and Robin and had practised his voices with Eddie. You thought all this made him overqualified for the position.Â
There couldnât be a person out there who cared so much about this. It was just Steve all over, he cared so much. He loved so much. It made you want to swaddle him in your arms and keep him safe forever.Â
âIf any of those punks make fun of you let me know and Iâll kick their ass,â Eddie garbled around another mouthful of lucky charms.Â
âYou think theyâll make fun of me,â Steve worried, his first clenching around the countertop.Â
âEddie!â Nancy chided. Eddie almost lept from his seat at Nancyâs sudden appearance. She stood in the doorway, as perfect as ever. Brown briefcase held tightly in her hand, her blazer hanging perfectly on her small frame. âYouâre overthinking this Steve, itâll be fine,â Nancy assured, kissing the top of Steveâs head. âAnd for the last time Eddie, no kicking children,âÂ
âSome kids deserve itâ He argues.
âReady?â Nancy asks you, ignoring Eddie, much to his annoyance.
You cast a wary look at Steve, you were reluctant to leave him alone like this, but you were the girlâs lift to work, so you had to trust Eddie would find a better way to comfort your boyfriend than his current tactic.Â
âReadyâ You confirmed, checking your reflection quickly in the toaster.Â
Nancy pressed a kiss to the back of Eddie's head, eyelashes fluttering against his frizzy hair. Then she moved to Steve, lips lingering a little longer on his cheek.
âRo-â
âHere!â Robin yelled, interrupting Nancyâs call of her name. She had a reputation for being late that she was trying to put behind her.Â
âLet's go!â Nancy sang, holding your arm in one hand and wrapping her other around Robinâs waist to pull her towards the door.Â
âGood luck Steve!â The three of you called together.
-
Youâre still thinking about Steve and wondering how his story time went as youâre organising the vinyl at work. You wonder if you should call him, trying to remember when the kid's nap time is so you can get him on the phone. You donât want to interrupt, but you canât help but worry about him.Â
In between thoughts of Steve, youâre trying to keep track of which ABBA albums need to be restocked.
Youâre so busy thinking of ways to celebrate or cheer him up in case of disaster, that you miss the chime of the bell.
âStill working here huh?â You freeze at the familiar voice, all thoughts leaving your mind. The one voice you wished youâd never have to hear again. âSome people just arenât meant to change I guess,âÂ
You stand up, brushing off the dust on your knees. You hate how youâre immediately flooded with embarrassment. âCan I help you?â You ask in the friendliest voice you can muster.Â
They take it in offence, hands held aloft in surrender, âHey, I didnât mean anything by it, you really havenât changed at all,â They laugh, your heart beating faster in your chest at the sound of it. You hate how they still have such an effect on you.Â
âDid you want something?â You ask again, colder this time. Letting the hatred you feel seep through. Your arms, crossed over your chest, erupt in goosebumps. You can feel your heartbeat like itâs in your ears, pounding again and again. Itâs an effort to remember how to breathe without it sounding rugged.Â
You were both bad for each other, thatâs what you settled on after the fact. They would tear you to shreds and act as if you were the one in the wrong. You could be just as cruel, the relationship was a toxic one and it turned you both sour.Â
 It took so many nights of talking and looking back on the relationship to realise that you didnât need to be the person they painted you to be. You hadnât been perfect, no one was, but you felt you had learnt from your mistakes and hoped they had done the same.Â
 âThought we could have an adult conversation, but obviously not,â They sneered, tone condescending.Â
They looked around the store youâre usually proud of with disdain. âGod, Iâm so fucking glad we broke up,â They laugh, flicking the sleeve of a vinyl, making you scowl. You feel the same but it doesnât make it hurt any less. âMy life has been so much better ever since you left it,âÂ
Itâs like a dagger to the chest. If you were in your right mind, maybe you would wonder why if they felt like that they would seek you out. Especially since they donât even bother to buy anything before they leave.
-
When Robin had last seen you, you were pushing her out of the car, trying to stifle your giggles.Â
In her rush to get out of the house on time, she forgot her scarf. You had bundled her up in your own which looked ridiculous. Eddie had knitted it for you, but then he got so caught up in seeing how long he could make it that when you wore it, it went down past your knees.Â
You thought it looked great, but it was a bit of a tripping hazard so when it came to Robin you wrapped it around her neck over and over until it was an appropriate length. Only she couldnât move her neck to look down. You had been laughing at her the whole drive, much to her annoyance.Â
Now all she wanted was for you to look at her and laugh, but you didnât even spare her a glance when she walked into the house, or when she unspooled the long scarf from around her neck.Â
Youâre still in your work clothes, even though you must have gotten home an hour ago at least. The TV is playing credits, but youâre watching them like theyâre the most interesting thing youâve ever seen.Â
All she wants to do is touch you. She restrains herself though, she knows people donât always want to be touched and it can make things worse.Â
As if you can tell that sheâs about to ask you something, you change channels and turn up the volume on the TV. You lean against the side of the sofa, further out of her reach and feign interest in a Miami Vice episode.Â
Getting the message she leaves you to it and joins Steve and Nancy in the kitchen, who are chatting over the kitchen counter. Nancy has already started making a pot of soup.Â
Steve is dutifully making grilled cheese sandwiches and plain slices of toast. They work in unison, Nancy passing Steve the butter before he even needs to ask, Steve wrapping one arm around her hip when he joins her on the hob, warming up the pan so he can toast the bread.Â
Heâs left two cheese toasties to the side, to be grilled when Eddie gets home.Â
âNot waiting?â Robin asks, catching the pair's attention. Nancy smiles, wordlessly passing her wooden spoon to Steve who accepts it without question. She holds Robin tightly in her arms, pressing kisses to her cheeks. She didnât realise how much she needed a hug until now and how much better it would make her feel after your rejection.Â
âThought some food might cheer everyone up,â Nancy explains, nodding towards the living room. Robins nods, squeezing Nancy back, hoping she wonât let go of her anytime soon.Â
âDid she say anything?â Steve asks, looking away from the soup briefly.Â
Robin shakes her head sadly and Nancy makes a sympathetic noise in her ear, rubbing her manicured hand up and down Robinâs back. âWhat about you?â Robin asks Nancy.
âNothing,â Nancy sighs, pulling away from Robin when she realises that Steve has stopped stirring her soup. She bats his hand away and hip-checks him out of the way, deciding to take charge again. At least that's something she has control over.Â
The rest of the dinner is made in relative silence, Robin sets out the cutlery on the living room table, along with everyoneâs preferred drinks. At one point Robin can tell youâre about to make an excuse not to eat at all, but a raised brow from Nancy has you sinking to the floor.
Robinâs eyes have been nervously flickering from her soup to you. Sheâll see your lips part for a moment like youâre about to say something, but you close them just as fast, swallowing down soup and tearing at your bread.Â
You all eat hunched over the living room table, Eddie is missed even more than ever as silence haunts the table. No one can work out what to say.
You can feel yourself putting a dampener on everything but feel so shaken from the interaction this afternoon that itâs all that you can think about. Youâve heard people say their exes were the worst things that happened to them, but you never thought you would have been one of those.Â
Had you truly been that bad?
When Nancy leans over to grab your hand you smile at her or attempt to. Then when she lets go your hand sinks off the table and down to your thigh out of reach.Â
What if one day they thought about you like that? What if one day theyâre glad that you broke up? They continue without you, happier without you.Â
Itâs then that you remember, to your horror, all about Steveâs story time. The cake you had planned to buy him in celebration. How could you be so selfish, forgetting about something Steve had been worried about for so long?Â
âHow did story time go?â You ask, timidly.Â
Robin and Nancy are patient, but Steve has never been. Heâs going out of his mind with worry. Perhaps it's because heâs suddenly lost a girlfriend before. Thought she had loved him the way he loved her until she pulled the rug out from under his feet and told him it wasnât working and that they were nothing.Â
It took so long for him to come back from that, even though heâs over the girl who said it, he still occasionally fears that all this love could be fleeting. Â
He smiles, abandoning the last of his toastie to thread his greasy fingers between your own. They slip against your hand and when he squeezes, he tries to push as much love into it as he can. âIt went really well,â
âYeah?â You ask more enthusiastically. Steveâs smiles have always been contagious. The pretty curve of his smile and the movement of his freckles as his cheeks apple, itâs the kind of smile that makes you believe in love at first sight.
âMrs Lemon wants me to read again tomorrow,â Steve grins.Â
Everyone at the table erupts in excitement at Steveâs news. Robin drops the last bit of her toastie into her soup and has to fish it out with her spoon, fingers turning red in her attempts. Nancy's hand rubs up and down Steveâs thigh, in congratulations for his good news and for bringing you out of your melancholy.Â
Robin has you hold up her glass to her lips so she can take a sip of water without getting her soupy fingers all over the glass. It causes her to dribble water all over the table and she canât even find it in her to be embarrassed when it results in giggles and your fingers brushing across her chin to catch the drips.Â
When everyone finished youâre quick to gather everyone's bowls and dismiss any help. You want to feel useful after sulking on the sofa while everyone else has made dinner.Â
-
This whole weekend you had been a whirlwind of productivism. Unless Eddie was forcing you to sit on the sofa with his head in your lap, you were doing something for someone else. Any errand anyone was putting off was finished by you that weekend. You had gotten the juice stains out of Steveâs jumper, sewn up the hole in Robinâs jacket pocket, reorganised Nancyâs toiletry cupboard and buffed her briefcase. Eddie had to coerce you into a cuddle to stop you from sewing up the holes in his favourite socks.Â
He hadnât attended last night's dinner but had heard all about it from a concerned Nancy and spent the whole weekend attached at your side.Â
He did everything one-handed, not wanting to spend a second not touching you. It was so out of character for you to be so withdrawn. Steve and Robin assumed it was a bad day or more specifically a bad customer.Â
Nancy and Eddie had a gut feeling it was something more important. You didnât often keep things to yourself, you found talking about problems usually stopped them from bothering you so much. If whatever happened hadnât felt fixable to you by a rant and a cuddle, something must have happened.Â
Eddie wanted to be there, ready, for when you wanted to tell him. He never wanted anyone to feel as alone as he once felt, drowning in his worries, before his uncle took him in.Â
Nancy, though claiming she was taking a more relaxed approach, glanced at you about every two seconds, checking your reactions.Â
So when you had said you needed to go out to the store, Nancy and Eddie shared a look and insisted they both needed to come with you. Eddie for some smokes and Nancy for a specific body lotion she claimed would be too hard for you to find.Â
They were so obvious it would be annoying if they werenât so endearing.Â
-
You ended up in Bradleys.
You had been antsy to get in, buy the cake you planned to get for Steve on Friday and then transform yourself into the partner your lovers deserved.Â
Instead, Eddie had taken his sweet time driving you all there, even though normally he called the speed limit a suggestion. Then he convinced you that you needed to walk up and down each aisle to make sure you didnât âforgetâ anything. It would have been an accomplishment to forget anything when you only have one item to obtain each.Â
The basket hooked on one arm, you hooked through the other, Eddie was strutting down the isles bobbing his head along to the pop songs he âhatedâ. Even though Eddieâs reasoning was ridiculous, it did feel relaxing to take your time walking through the various aisles together.Â
Eddieâs fingers were tracing up and down Nancyâs spine as she held two types of tea in her hand, reading the backs carefully. âDo you think these work?â She asked, holding out the packages for you to inspect, two different teas both promising to help with sleep.
You took one out of her hands, to inspect the ingredient list. Robinâs mum had said something about lavender last time you had spoken, but you werenât sure that was digestible.Â
âIf you need help sleeping, Iâve got the perfect solutionâ Eddie teased, arms snaking around Nancyâs waist and squeezing as he dipped his face against her neck. Nancy shivered, feeling his cold nose trace her neck and his curls tickle her collarbones, the basket digging into her sides.
âStop!â She said, trying not to smile, wiggling out of his arms and lightly slapping at his arms, âI canât take you anywhere,âÂ
Eddie pressed a wet kiss to her cheek. His arm went over her shoulder, grabbing the box of tea out of Nancyâs hand and dropping it into the basket. âMrs Norris used to drink that one,â He explained, taking the other one from your hand to put it back on the shelf. âAlways knocked her out cold when she was supposed to be babysitting meâ
Nancy huffed, crossing her hands across her chest as Eddie encouraged you both to the end of the aisle, hands wandering. âYou have no shameâ She scolded, cheeks burning at the wink he gave her in response. Still, he dropped his hands from her but continued to lead you both down to the frozen section, in search of ice cream.Â
She stopped at a display of lip balms, letting the two of you go on ahead. Her gaze did not linger on his fingers curled around the basket handle, or the dip of his spine that his cropped band shirt exposed.
You were still smiling over Eddie as you watched him search the freezers for the giant tub of Neapolitan-flavoured ice cream. He always made a big display of it, sometimes he and Robin would compete to see who could keep their hands in the freeze the longest.Â
Nancy soon floated behind you, her floral perfume altering you to her presence long before she slid her hand into your own. She leaned into your space, so close you could smell the curl cream she and Eddie shared. The pair, despite their differences, had a surprising amount in common.Â
âHow mad do you think heâll be if we refuse to hold his hand when he gets the ice cream?â Nancy whispered.Â
âI think weâll hear about it for the rest of the night,âÂ
Eddie cranes his head, looking you both up and down conspiringly. He fished the last tub from the back of the freezer and dropped it into the basket with a thud. It crushes the flimsy box of tea, but Eddieâs attention is on the guilty expression youâre wearing.Â
He holds his freezing hands out expectantly, wanting you to come and warm him up after his valiant efforts of searching in the freezers.Â
Nancy shakes her head at him, but his doe eyes canât hold you off for long so soon heâs holding one of your hands in both his. You flinch at his touch and he pouts childishly, lashes fluttering.Â
âI risk my fingers for you, and this is the thanks I get,â Eddie huffs at Nancy over the top of your head, âAt least you love me, sweetheart,â He coos kissing the side of your head.Â
âYou hardly risked your fingers,â Nancy says rolling her eyes as she tugs your hand to lead you down to the toiletries aisle. You think half-heartedly about the cake, vanilla and shaped like a heart, that you wanted to get Steve, but then think of the crushed box of tea, it might be best to leave it for last.Â
âI was very close to hypothermia,â Eddie dramatises, flexing his fingers against yours. You feel the cold bump of his rings, theyâre usually cold but feel even more so after being in the freezer.Â
Nancy ignores him and walks straight to the body lotion, hand reaching out for her usual choice, but lingering on a couple of new scents. Strawberries & Cream sounds like it would smell pretty nice, plus the bottle matches her nails.Â
She picks it up, dropping your hand in the process and uncaps the lid to give it a smell. Eddie takes your dropped hand before it can even fall to your side, now, he threads his fingers through yours with a giddy smile.Â
He pecks a kiss on your nose catching you off guard and pulls you off to the side next to the baby powders, moving you away from an oncoming cart.Â
You lean in to kiss his own but are brought out of your lovesick stupor by a harsh cough. Eddie glares at the culprit, kissing your lips extra firm. The person coughs again and you push Eddie away from you and try to move out of the way, catching sight of the person coughing at you.Â
Itâs always a shock to see your ex unexpectedly, itâs even worse when theyâre with a beautiful partner and they have a child sitting in the cart tugging a little plush to their chest. It shocks you for about a million reasons, the most hurtful being that the entire time you had been together they claimed to never want children.Â
Yet here, in front of you, is the clear proof that they did.Â
âNancy!âÂ
Itâs a small town, everyone knows everyone. Still, it shocks you that their new partner knows Nancy. You feel so different from your old self that a reminder of it is terrifying.Â
Suddenly youâre scared, what had your ex told them? How badly had they painted you? what if they tell Nancy?Â
The worst part is that if they were to tell her, it would have been entirely your fault. How could you be mad at someone for telling the truth? You hadnât been the greatest partner in the past, but you were trying to make up for that. It felt like you had made up for that.Â
You make eye contact with your ex, who isnât even trying to hide their disappointment at seeing you twice in such a short amount of time, still, itâs obvious by the conversation Nancy is getting into that theyâll be standing around for a while.Â
Your eyes try to look at everything, but the person whoâs fucked with your head for the last couple of days. The child, old enough that it must have been born within a year of your breakup, hair a dark brown colour, coils around their shoulders. They look so happy, a picture-perfect family.Â
You excuse yourself, using the cake you need as an excuse to go to a different aisle. Eddie tries to go after you but is cut off by an old lady jamming her shopping cart in front of him with a rude huff, muttering about young people these days. She runs over his foot and he almost takes down the entire shelving unit when he backs into it.
When Eddie finds you, standing in front of an empty shelf, sniffing into your hands, heâs crushed.Â
-
The drive back had been awkward.Â
Nancy had found you both and sent Eddie to pay for everything while she took you to the car. You refused to cite anything but the cakeâs being sold out as the reason for your tears, but itâs clear that there was something more.Â
It isnât until youâre home, that the extent of your upset is clear. At the supermarket, you had clung onto Nancy and Eddie for life, feeling personally devastated at the thought of either of them leaving you.
Now leaving was all you could think of doing.Â
You had packed your bag, unpacked and re-packed it again. You just couldnât get it out of your head, how much happier everyone might be without you. Your last relationship played through your mind like a reel.
All the times your exe had yelled at you, called you a bitch, the problem. You could be forgetful, self-absorbed, hurtful. You thought you had changed, but you had proved yourself wrong on Friday, ignoring Steveâs accomplishment to stew in your self-obsession.Â
There was a knock on your door, but it was a warning rather than a request as Steve and Robin barged in without waiting for a response.Â
âAre you ok?â Robin asked, skirting around your clutter to land on the bed, beside the duffle bag you were about to re-pack. âActually no, I know youâre not ok, so donât bother lying,â Robin huffed, pushing the fly aways from her face and staring at you in determination.Â
Her hands darted out to your sides, holding you firmly in place. On her knees, on your bed, she begged you to tell her exactly what was wrong, âYou always feel better after talking to me, I can help you, whatever it is. If itâs working at the vinyl store weâll get you a new job, you could come to work with me in the museum archives?âÂ
âItâs notâŚitâs not that,â You stutter, fingers feeling tingly as your eyes dart nervously from Robin to Steve, who hasnât moved from standing at the door. You canât see his expression, but the vein on his neck is close to bursting.Â
Iâm the problem, you think, but youâre all too sweet to realise and youâll be too kind to tell me when you do work it out.Â
Robinâs nose bumps your sternum bringing your attention back to her. She presses a kiss to the swell of your stomach. Her hands are ever wandering, frantic in their need to comfort you, but unsure where to go. âYou can tell me,â She promises, her sea-blue eyes boring into yours. Your eyes water as you try to think of what to say.Â
âYouâre leaving,â Steveâs voice is cold, and his stare is even colder. He nods to the duffle bag on the bed, glaring at it with the heat of a thousand suns.Â
Robin looks at the bag that she hadnât registered, shaking her head in disbelief, until she sees the crumbling expression on your face and realises itâs true. Her hands drop from your body and she darts from the bed like a person burnt. She brushes past Steve, rushing out of your room and you can hear her fast footsteps retreat down the hall.
âYouâŚyou donât understand,â You try to defend, hands falling into fists in frustration.Â
âNo, I understand,â Steve spits, arms crossed across his chest, muscles clenched, âYouâre just like her, only so much worse,âÂ
âSte-â
âDonâtâ Steve scoffs âYou promised us you wouldnât do this, promised me.â His voice breaks and he has to turn his face to the side, collect himself and wipe the rouge tears that he let escape.Â
You sink in on yourself, âItâsâŚitâs for the best, IâmâŚI,â
Steve laughs, fist banging against the door frame, startling you, you have to steady your hands on the bed to stop yourself from falling.Â
Your stomach lurches, it doesnât feel right. Youâre last breakup hadnât ended like this, they hadnât been mad at you for leaving, they had been mad you hadnât broken up sooner. That they hadnât been the one to dump you.
You fear you might have made a terrible mistake, but then remember what they had said when you broke up. That you were poison, that you ruined everything that you touched, how much happier they had been before you. Now you knew how much happier they were without you afterwards too.Â
They would thank you in the long run.Â
âIf you walk out this door right now, Iâm never going to forgive you,â Steveâs heart was cracking. Just like last time, he was caught off guard. His voice was stern, but his expression was heartbreaking.Â
âSteve!â Yelled Nancy, pushing past him in the doorway and walking over to you instead. Her hair was half dry, one side still dripping water onto the collar of her shirt.Â
Eddie, hair wrapped in the band shirt he had worn to the store, mirrored Nancy, only taking Steve into his arms instead of you. âLetâs all just calm down a second,â Nancy suggested, pulling you down to sit on her lap. She threw your duffle bag off the bed, sending it clattering into your wardrobe.Â
âTake a deep breath,â Eddie suggested, palm warm over Steveâs chest. Robin fiddled with Steveâs fingers, eyeing everyone warily. Steve matched his breathing to Eddieâs, lips wobbling as Eddieâs thumb wiped the sticky tears from his cheeks.Â
If you felt awful before, now you feel diabolical.Â
âIâm sorry, Iâm so sorry,â You confessed, trying to push out of Nancy's soothing hold because you felt so undeserving. She had a surprising amount of strength though and held you firm against her chest, âI didnât mean, I donât want to hurt anybody, this is exactly what I donât want, I just want you all to be happyâÂ
Robin, tentatively let go of Steveâs hand, who Eddie was leading further into the bedroom. Nancy wrangled you so you were leaning against her where she sat against the headboard. Her head resting on your shoulder while her hand was rubbing up and down your back.Â
Robin sat down at the foot of the bed, hand reaching out carefully to rub at your leg. âPlease can you explain? So we can all understand, why you want toâŚleave,â Robin asked, hardly able to say the word.
The bed dipped as Eddie sat himself down to the side of you and Nancy, but Steve still refused to sit, standing up with his thighs touching the bed, hand clasped tightly in Eddieâs.Â
You took a deep breath and tried to explain âI saw, my ex, first they visited me at work-â
Steveâs grip on Eddie white-knuckled as he scoffed, assuming the worst. You shrunk further back into Nancy making her glare at Steve who rolled his eyes. He was still sure you were about to rip out their hearts.Â
âGo on,â Nancy encouraged.
âHe said, he was glad we broke up and at first I just thought, yeah me too, but then I started thinking and,I was awful,â
âDid you start thinking that? Or did he make you think that?â Nancy asked.Â
âWell, I mean, I guess he implied it and he always used to say it, like I would ruin things and he would throw things, sometimes, when I did something bad,âÂ
Steve sat down on the bed, looking at you tearfully, âHe would throw things at you?â Now he felt himself crying for an entirely different reason.Â
âIt wasnât- I was just as bad,â
âDid you throw things at them?â Questioned Robin.Â
You shook your head, âNo, but I de-â
âI know youâre not about to say you deserved it, no one ever deserves that sweetheart,âÂ
âI was an asshole, I was cruel and hurtful.â You explained, âYou can say they shouldnât have hurt me, but I hurt them just as much with every word I said. How can I deserve to be happy like this? Iâve been trying to change, but what if i canâtâÂ
Steve feels a rush of sympathy through his chest. The anger that surged through his body turned from a fiery rage to a simmering heat, directed at whoever made you feel like this. He knows exactly how it feels to try to change, but not be given a chance.Â
To this day the title of King Steve follows him around like a bad dream. Heâs taken responsibility for his actions and changed for the better, but for a long time, he wondered if it would ever be enough to make up for the hurt he had caused. Did he deserve the friendship Robin offered, that had led him down the path to this?Â
You gulped eyes starting to water. âI just donât want to ruin things, I donât want to hurt anyone I love again, Iâm so sorry Steve, I already hurt you so much and if I stay I might-â
Steve shuffled forward, pulling you roughly from Nancyâs embrace into his own. His strong arms wrapped around you and his tear-stained cheeks stuck to your own. âThe only way you could truly hurt me is if you left right now,â He pulled himself out of your embrace so he could hold his face in your hands.Â
âYou deserve to be happy, you deserve a chance to change,â Steve promises, tacky lips pressing into the top of your head over and over again, trying to let it sink in.Â
âFor the record, this version of you youâre describing, I donât think Iâve ever met them,â Eddie says, palm firm as it rubs up and down Steveâs quaking back.Â
âBut I- I forgot all about Steveâs big day,â You huff, voice thick with frustration.Â
âHoney, you spent the morning comforting me and asked me about it when you got home.â Steve placates.Â
âNot right away though, I sat on the sofa for ages, just thinking about myself,â
âThink thatâs understandable after the run-in you had,â Steveâs hand keeps a warm grip on your cheeks, eyes softening as he kisses underneath your teary eye.
âLovely, youâve never made any of us feel anything but loved and I hope you feel the same about usâ Nancy offered, stroking your shoulder with soft fingers.Â
âIâm sorry, Iâm sorry I even thought about leaving I was just, so caught up and I wasnât thinking properly.â
 âDo you still want to?â Asked Robin tentatively, hands ghosting the sides of your leg.Â
You shook your head, lip starting to wobble, âI never wanted to, I just thought- I thought I had to,- Oof!â You exclaimed, Robinâs soft body dropping on top of you and Steve, squishing you down against Nancy, who took the weight like a champ.Â
Her arms winded around Steve, you and Nancy, squeezing Steve so tight he thought she might break one of his ribs. âI think as long as us five stick together, we can get through anythingâÂ
âWell said Buckley,â Grinned Eddie, reaching over to ruffle her hair.
Eventually, you all moved from your room into Nancy and Steveâs which had the biggest bed.Â
Nancy was removing the decorative pillows from the bed to place them on the ottoman instead. Eddie was helping, but his idea of helping was throwing them at Robin who was trying to dodge them while drinking the tea Nancy had gotten her at the store. A potentially deadly combination that required Nancyâs intervention.Â
Steve was with you in the en suite, the two of you hadnât spent much time apart since the earlier misunderstanding. Steve had joined you in the shower while Nancy and Eddie finished drying their hair.Â
You had shared a bowl of ice cream, even though Steve didnât like ice cream all that much anymore while watching the Documentary Eddie borrowed from the library for Robin.Â
Steve had just finished washing your face for you, letting you sit on the counter. Now you were brushing his hair for him. You started carefully combing it back with a fine-tooth comb, but now we're just using your fingers, styling it wildly to make him laugh.Â
You were currently attempting a mohawk with little success. He had one hand wrapped around his toothbrush while the other was holding your wrist, fingers pressing into your pulse. It felt good to be the reason Steve laughed instead of the reason he had been crying.Â
âIâm sorry Steve,â You whispered again, against his forehead, pressing a light kiss between his eyebrows.Â
âAlready forgiven lovely,â Steve promised, bending his head to kiss your pulse point. â but, please tell me what I did wrongâ He murmured, turning bashful.
âWhat?â Now it was your turn to look at Steve in shock. âYou didnât do anything wrong?âÂ
âPlease, you can tell me, otherwise how will I not do it again?â Steve spares you a glance with eyes so earnest it breaks your heart.Â
Steve had felt so guilty since he heard your confession, you had thought that you would make them unhappy, in his head it translated that he hadnât made it clear just how much he adores you.Â
âYou didnât Stevie, I promise. I was too in my own headâ You kiss him gently âI still am, to be honest,â You confess smoothing his hair down behind his ears, kissing him once again for good measure. âI promise Iâll tell you next time I start spiralling,â
He burrowed his face in your neck, inhaling the smell of strawberries and cream. It scared him to think he would never be this close to you ever again, that he could lose out on all this. âGod I hope there isnât a next time, I love you, you make me- you make us so much happier,â
âThank you for caring about me, I know it can be hard,âÂ
âCaring about you is easy, itâs like breathing I donât even have to think about it, I just do itâÂ
âStevie,â You mumble, tucking yourself against his shoulder, âYouâre such a loverboy,â You peck him again.Â
After another five minutes of cuddling, you go into the bedroom and find yourself in a love pile on the bed.Â
Robin is smushed, out cold on top of you and Nancy. Nancy flanks you one one side and Steve is on your other, breath puffing against your neck. Eddie is wrapped around him, his heavy leg draped across you and Steve.Â
If he was ever right, about you being poison, youâre certain youâve found your antidote.Â
masterlist












