Prodigal Son and why Living Shouldn't Be Controversial
Originally posted 1/27/2021
After my last post I wasnât sure what I would write about. Several of my upcoming posts are research intensive and potentially controversial so as far as Iâve gotten on them was to put them in my book for blog post ideas and thatâs about it.
And then Season Two of Prodigal Son aired. So what am I doing? A research (not so intensive) and potentially controversial post. At least Iâm on brand.
For those who donât really know the show: In its second season Prodigal Son is the story of ex-FBI profiler Malcolm Bright who was fired for his risk-taking habits and came back to the NYPD at the request of Captain Gil Arroyo. Malcolm Bright is also Malcolm Whitly, the son of the influential and extremely wealthy Whitley family. The Patriarch of the Whitly family, Dr. Martin Whitly, a convicted serial killer known as âthe Surgeonâ, is currently in a secure psychiatric facility. His son Malcolm put him there. Malcolm now works for the NYPD under Gilâs team that includes Detectives JT Tarmel, and Detective Dani Powell and Medical Examiner Edrisa Tanaka. While not solving crimes, Malcom must deal with his tenacious television reporter sister Ainsley Whitly and their wealthy, hovering mother Jessica Whitly. As well as his father who is trying to make his way back into his familyâs life via Malcolm by assisting via telephone with certain cases.
Except for the Whitlyâs (who while wealthy are probably not very good role models), the entire main cast is made up of people of color: Filipino, Black, Asian. While the first season was introductions to everyone and dealing with Malcolmâs lost memories regarding his father, the father/ son dynamic, cultivating a loyal fanbase and potentially starting some ships both purposefully and accidentally (Iâm looking at you Brightwell and Maldrisa shippers), this second season started off with a bang. Something that might have been relegated to a side plot, I feel, had become larger than this seasonâs overarching plot and will end up and absolutely deserved to be in equal standing.
In the first season, we are introduced to JT, the by the book detective who doesnât like Bright in the beginning but by the end of the first season, theyâreâŠokay. We also meet JT frankly adorable wife Tally and discover that heâs going to be a dad.
In season two, months have passed, and JT is acting Captain while Gil is out on medical leave. He brings Bright in on a case involving a justice killer. At the end while back up is being sent to Brightâs apartment for the final conflict, Dani rushes up while backup is on its way and JT is right behind her. He arrives moments before the back up and when they arrive, he directs them up to the apartment. What happens instead is something weâve all seen on the news this past summer. The first cop that arrives tackles JT and presses him against the wall, baton at his throat telling him to stop resisting. The terror in JTâs eyes is startling as he realized that these officers, the one holding him and the other five who have their guns trained on him are not going to let him explain that heâs a cop. It isnât until Dani runs out holding her badge and Malcom following close behind, both of them yelling to stand down, that heâs a cop does the office let go of JT and step back. Back at the station, Gil is furious and wants to take it to I.A., but JT insists it wonât do any good and he needs to think about it. He has a family now and he doesnât want the retaliation. The scene ends with Gil, Dani and Bright supporting his decision and telling him they have his back. JT is emotional and for good reason. The people who are supposed to be working with him just tried to kill him.
Episode two didnât let up; in the middle of a chase, Gil tells JT to call for back up and what happens is enraging. As JT calls on his police issued walkie for backup, the person manning the other end tells him that the line if for police use only and uses the term âboyâ before disconnecting. Later, it shows JT and Dani standing outside the office watching Gil yell at the dispatch for not sending officers for a potential hostile situation. JT decides to not file a report mentioning that he has a family to worry about and he must work with these people. It is harassment and emotional terrorism at its worst.
In the first episode this season, Dani and Bright are talking and Dani mentions the institutionalized racism sheâs been dealing with. With this show being categorized as a police procedural, showing this sort of dangerous institutional racism within the police force is both tricky and important. While police shows have mentioned an episode or two of racism within the force, itâs usually an episode and the one bad cop is taken to task by the white Captain and the entire thing is brushed over. The good thing about this show is so far, all the people in power weâve seen on the force have been people of color. It also makes it harder to pull the âwhite saviorâ role as Bright, while on the team, has no real standing with the NYPD and could be kicked off cases in a heartbeat. Jessica, with all of her wealth and ties (or not, make up your mind Jess) to Gil, canât really do anything expect throw money at the issue. The brunt of the conflict will lie between Gil and his team facing the police force including these cops who âare just doing their jobâ and the veil of secrecy that lies within the Thin Blue Line. Itâs not something that can be erased in a five-episode arc and I really hope itâs not. The racism within the department has been established, it canât be erased with the firing of the cop who attacked JT and it canât be addressed with the Commissioner coming in to make everyone go to training to make it all magically go away.
The showrunners spent the entire first season introducing us and making us love these characters and given the current climate of the world, this was a bold and correct decision, one that needed to be addressed. I know there is talk on message board stating that this season is too âpoliticalâ. Black Lives Matter, is not political, institutionalized racism within the police force is not political. Men and women of color that are on police forces are risking their lives to do good and make streets safer and do not deserve to wonder if theyâre going to take âfriendlyâ fire from one of their own.  This year weâve heard too many stories of officers who were threatened out of uniform and officers who spoke up only to be removed from duty. This isnât a new thing. Nobody should be murdered for living their lives, for sleeping, for complying with proper police requests.
Personally, as a white person, watching these scenes hurt. Watching JTâs reactions hurt. Hearing someone who was supposed to have his back use a term that has racist undertones when said as it was, made me furious. Which is what itâs supposed to do. But this is also a dangerous road the showrunners are taking. There is no clean and easy way out of this, to have it discussed and âfixedâ isnât reasonable nor believable anymore, to ignore it after three episodes isnât doing it justice. I donât know how this will turn out, but it absolutely needs to be addressed this season. To the extent of having it a plot equal to Malcomâs covering up a murder and hiding the body without getting caught.
If you want more information or want to get involved, please look at the websites linked. It shouldnât take a television show to spread awareness, but if it does, so much the better. People are starting to get involved with activism because media and itâs good (sometimes). Television should start a conversation, thatâs when itâs working best.













