I think a lot about how the world treats teenage girls. Like, everything that's good about us is a weakness. Our hearts, our emotions, our empathy, means we need to be protected.
- Calliope, First Kill 1x01
Compassion is not a weakness. It is a gift to be embraced.
- Sebastian, First Kill 1x02
This comparison isn’t so much “two opposing views on compassion” as it is “two unique situations centered on empathy/compassion vs violence/murder.”
Calliope never disowns her femininity or her empathy, though she does tie the two together. But she does recognize those attributes as reasons her family is sheltering her, and she resents that. Resents feeling like an outsider in her own family because of it. She doesn’t try to erase her empathy, only tries to set it aside long enough to “do what needs to be done” and finally commit the First Kill.
She never wavers from her belief that monsters deserve to be killed; she simply doesn’t put Juliette in the category of “Monster.”
Juliette has been procrastinating her graduation to Full Vampire™ as long as possible, knocking back as many blood pills and blood smoothies as she can to stave off the symptoms. She cannot abide the thought of taking someone’s life and only accomplishes it in defense of her lifelong best friend.
Her mother, her sister, her heritage as a Legacy, and her own body demand that she give in and commit the First Kill. Only her human-born father still nurtures her compassion.