Do you know whether or not Yuna knew that the Guado intended to fire the rest of the party as guardians once she and Seymour got married? Seems like it would be a deal breaker for her even considering all the pressure she was under to say yes, from herself and the rest of Spira. Then again Seymour brought up being her Zaon and they way she said goodbye to the party before the crawler fight is a little ambiguous.
Thatās an interesting question! And it has triggered lots of thinky thoughts, so let me make a cut.
TL;DR: I donāt think Yuna had thought it through very clearly: she was so focused on the confrontation that she wasnāt really thinking about her guardians at that point, as Seymour had intended.
This is a side effect of the power imbalance in her interactions with Seymour. I think all she was thinking about is what am I going to say to him? OMFG Iām planning to confront⦠a MAESTER?! Thatās a 17-year-old girl challenging the Pope, or at least a bishop. Itās a gutsy thing to do, especially for someone who lived by the teachings. She was out of her depth. (She grew up quickly, though: look at her calling out Maester Mika during the trial and standing up to Maester Kelk on Gagazet).
Look at what Yuna says when sheās made up her mind to go meet Seymour in Macalania Temple:
Yuna: I have one question, if I may, sir.Tromell: My lady?Yuna: I want to keep journeying, even if I marry. Do you think that Maester Seymour would let me?Tromell: But of course, my lady. Lord Seymour wishes nothing else, Iām sure.
Thatās an astoundingly submissive thing for Yuna to say. Sheās spend years planning to sacrifice herself for this pilgrimage, she was determined to follow her fatherās example, sheās been utterly committed to being a summoner, and then suddenly, sheās meekly asking if Seymour will allow her to continue her pilgrimage. As if itās his call.
Holy hells, heās manipulated her.
Seymour had stoked the same insecurities that caused Yuna to apologize to Tidus for being āoverconfident,ā as if it were her fault heād blundered into the Cloister of Trials in Besaid. They were the same insecurities that caused her to ask Lulu, āI hope I did⦠okay?ā in Kilika. She was starting to overcome those insecurities on the Miāihen Highroad:
Shelinda: But you donāt understand! The Crusaders wonāt even listen to me. And itās all because Iām just a lowly acolyte.Yuna: Donāt say that.Shelinda: (Gasp) Yuna: Well, I havenāt been a summoner for very long myself, you see. Still, I canāt put myself down every time I fail. People are depending on me. Theyāre depending on both of us!Shelinda: Yes! Yes, youāre right, my lady. Absolutely right!
But then Seymour came along and did his best to teach her the opposite of the lesson sheād just taught Shelinda.
Yuna: Why does he want to see me?
Yuna: What could it be? Ooohā¦Ā¬[I hope] I havenāt done anything to make him mad.
We saw Seymour undermining her in every interaction. He opened the Crusader Checkpoint to her as a special favor, reframing her pilgrimage as a favor he bestowed on her. He told her that she was ātoo weakā and that āshe canātā fight Sin during Operation Miāihen. Afterwards, when she was traumatized by a massacre that would shellshock a generation of soldiers, he impressed upon her that she could only succeed as a summoner by taking him as āher Lord Zaon.ā While she stayed up all night tending the dead and dying of that horrific battle, his words were probably playing over and over in her head.
Itās not clear that Yuna got any sleep from that time until Seymour summoned her to his mansion (the perfect stage to impress/intimidate her) in Guadosalam. There he dazzled her by showing her Zanarkand, the place she was making a pilgrimage to see, coopting Tidusā promise to take her there. Maybe the rumors had already filtered back to him that she was traveling with a boy from Zanarkand (Seymour certainly knew who Tidus was later on, whose son he was and where he was from). Again, after overwhelming her with a powerful experience and reminding her that Yunalesca whom she was named for depended on Zaon, he popped the question.
Heād done everything he possibly could to knock her off-balance.
Dona, supposedly a bitchy rival, saw what Seymour was doing and told Yuna to try āstanding on her own two legsā for a change. Unfortunately Dona also told her that she couldnāt rely on her guardians during the final showdown with Sin.
Seymour gave Yuna the same message, undermining her bond with her guardians, to the point that she hid Jyscalās sphere from them and didnāt consult them. Heād even driven a wedge between her and Kimahri:
Kimahri: Kimahri not like Maester Seymour.Yuna: Aa! Shhh!¬Kimahri: Kimahri speak no more.
(Kimahri does not speak in her presence again for a very long time.)
(Tromell trying to lead Yuna away the INSTANT she arrives in Guadosalam!)
Not that sheās turned her back on her guardians completely, of course. But sheās keeping them out. Sheās ātoo quiet.ā She wonāt confide in Lulu. She runs away from Tidus in the Thunder Plains Inn. She canāt tell her guardians whatās on her mind until sheās talked to Seymour about it first:
Yuna: For Spiraās futureā¦and Yevonās unity. I thought it would be the best thing to do.
Wakka: Yuna, just one question. Canāt you just talk to Maester Seymour? Youāve got to marry him?Yuna: I donāt know. But I think it is the right thing to do.
Yuna is really, really mixed up. On the one hand, sheās half bought into Seymourās B.S. about taking him as her Lord Zaon, āfor Spiraās future.ā On the other hand, his murder of his father is a threat to āYevonās unityā:
Yuna: I wanted to confront Maester Seymour about his father, Lord Jyscal. I wanted to convince him to turn himself into Yevonās judgement.Lulu: In exchange for marriage?Yuna: Yes, if thatās what it took.
Sheās torn between following Jyscalās final request to āstop my sonā or Seymourās insistence that she marry him and bring hope to the people of Spira. Somehow, sheās trying to do both.
Either way, she is just not focusing on what this means for her guardians. Look at the following exchange, in which itās Tromell, not Yuna, dictating where theyāll go. She can only stammer, apparently at a loss about what to tell them, what they should do, what's going to happen to them, or even when sheāll be able to talk to them again:
Yuna: I want to keep journeying, even if I marry. Do you think that Maester Seymour would let me?Tromell: But of course, my lady. Lord Seymour wishes nothing else, Iām sure.Yuna: (Smiles and bows head to guardians) Goodbye.Tromell: Well⦠We must follow Guado tradition. (to guardians) Iāll have to ask you wait here a little while longer. Iāll send someone to escort you. (Leaves)Yuna: (Hangs back) Iā¦Auron: Weāre all with you. Do as you will.Yuna: Thank you. (Leaves)
She is no longer with them. Seymour played her like a puppet.
This isnāt to dump on Yuna. Auronās right: āMake mistakes. Thatās what youth is for, after all.ā
She learns from her mistakes and is soon standing up to the maesters and casting off the entire Church of Yevon when it gets in the way of her pilgrimage, just as Auron had urged. But that was not an easy thing to do. It makes her crisis of faith and her character growth far more compelling than if sheād blithely blown off the church and the maesters like Tidus did, right from the start.