Changelings | Scottish Folklore
The first recorded fairy changeling was in the 16th century, but they likely have a history older than that. Changeling stories, however, are quite dark and disturbing, so leave now if you are not in the right mindset to handle that. There are mentions of child harm and murder ahead.
"When they succeeded in their felonious attempts, the elves left instead of the mother, and bearing her semblance, a stock of wood (stoc maide), and in place of the infant an old mannikin of their own race."
Superstitions of the Highlands & Islands of Scotland by John Gregorson Campbell (1900)
Both adults (particularly mothers) and babies were susceptible of being changelings. The mothers were said most often to be taken to help care for fairy babies, while the babies were taken for four main reasons.
The first is that the baby was swapped out for an elderly fairy, so that it can live out the rest of itâs days in comfort. This is why some changeling babies are said to not live long.
The second is because the fairies owed souls to the devil.
Every seven years they had to pay âthe teind to hell,â and to save them from paying this tribute with one of themselves they were ever on the alert to get hold of human infants.
Folklore of the North East of Scotland by Walter Gregor (1881)
The forth (though less common) reason is that, for whatever reason, the fairy mother can not care for her own baby, and is swapped to save it. One story that sort of confirms this (though without a changeling) a fairy woman asks a mother to nurse her child and leaves. The mother does, and when the fairy comes back, the mother is blessed with good fortune.
In the cases where the baby is simply taken, a piece of wood is enchanted to look and act like a baby.
To prevent a mother or baby being taken away, they would have to be sained. To get a baby or mother back, sometimes all it would take was saining the changelings.
"He knew at once what was going on, and what was to be done, and he ran with all his speed to the smithâs house and âsainedâ the mother and her baby-an act which the nurse had neglected to do. No sooner was the saining finished than a heavy thud, as if something had fallen, was heard outside the house opposite to the spot where stood the bed on which the mother and her baby lay. On examination a piece of bog-fir was found lying at the bottom of the wall. It was the âimageâ the fairies were to substitute for the smithâs wife."
Folklore of the North East of Scotland by Walter Gregor (1881)
Other times, the customs to get rid of a changelings either involve tricking the fairy into giving itself away, or by hurting the baby so that the spell is either broken. This is when things will get quite dark, so again, this is your warning.
"The changeling was converted into the stock of a tree by saying a powerful rhyme over him, or by sticking him with a knife. He could be driven away by running at him with a red-hot ploughshare; by getting between him and the bed and threatening him with a drawn sword; by leaving him out on the hillside, and paying no attention to his shrieking and screaming; by putting him sitting on a gridiron, or in a creel, with a fire below; by sprinkling him well out of the maistir tub; or by dropping him into the river. There can be no doubt these modes of treatment would rid a house of any disagreeable visitor, at least of the human race."
Superstitions of the Highlands & Islands of Scotland by John Gregorson Campbell (1900)
There are many historical recordings on Tobar an Duelchais of fairy changelings being put onto a shovel, and held above the fire, and in other stories (such as from The Fairy Mythology / Illustrative of the Romance and Superstition of Various Countries by Thomas Keightley (1850) ) the baby is quite literally thrown into the fire.
If the changeling was indeed a fairy in disguise, the fairy will leave the real baby behind and scramble up the chimney.
"One day an old highland woman having seen the child , and inspected it carefully , affirmed that it was a fairy child . She went the length of offering to put the matter to the test , and this is how she tested it . She put the poker in the fire , and hung a pot over the fire wherein were put certain ingredients , an incantation being said as each new ingredient was stirred into the pot . The child was quiet during these operations , and watched like a grown person all that was being done , even rising upon its elbow to look . When the operations were completed , the old woman took the poker out of the fire , and carrying it red hot over to the cradle , was about to burn the sign of the cross on the babyâs brow , when the child sprung suddenly up , knocked the old woman down and disappeared up the lum ( chimney , ) filling the house with smoke , and leaving behind it a strong smell of brimstone . When the smoke cleared away , the true baby was found in the cradle sleeping as if it never had been taken away."
Folk Lore, Or, Superstitious Beliefs in the West of Scotland Within this Century by James Napier (1879)
There is a major dark side to these stories. All it took for a baby to be accused of being a changeling was simply crying more and louder than normal, which could, of course, lead to human babies being gravely injured. As well as that, often, some people born with deformities were accused of being changelings their entire life.
There are also murders to mention as well. The best known case of this happened in Ireland. Bridget Cleary was accused of being a changeling in 1895, simply for having bronchitis. I wont go into the gruesome details, but she was tortured to death by her husband and father. She was later (including by some today) called a witch, and described as the last witch burnt in Ireland.
This led to the nursery rhyme:
Are you a witch,
Or are you a fairy,
or are you the wife of Michael Cleary?
(link) A fairy changeling forced out. 1987,
(link) A family story about getting rid of a fairy changeling. 1984
(link) A changeling left by a fairy was not a real child and would never grow up properly. 1979
(link) A family story about getting rid of a fairy changeling. 1979
(link) The hump-backed tailor and the fairy. 1954
(link) Changeling gradually tortures a family to death. 1977