Every Record I Own - Day 876: Elliott Smith Either/Or
It was July 1997, the day before my twentieth birthday. Me and my bandmate Dave drove down to Olympia from Tacoma for the annual Yoyo A Go Go festival at Capitol Theater. Built to Spill were headlining, having released Perfect From Now On to widespread acclaim earlier that Spring. Dave was obsessed with that album and had played it pretty much anytime it was his turn to drive on our first US tour a couple of months prior. I was more interested in catching Monorchid, who were also on the bill.
At some point in the early evening before the Monorchid and Built to Spill sets, a guy got on stage with nothing other than an acoustic guitar. I was just getting into songwriters like Bob Dylan and Phil Ochs around then, and the room hadn't really filled up yet, so I secured a spot up close to the stage. I didn't know anything about Elliott Smith at the time. Yoyo A Go Go leaned heavily on the K Records roster, so there were always some outsider artists doing their weird solo ventures, but it was clear from his first note that Smith wasn't just another Evergreen College student who'd heard Beat Happening and decided to give music a try, technical ability be damned.
It was really a magical moment. The quarter-full theater was dead quiet... transfixed. The music was hushed and delicate without being precious. It was pretty and sweet without being saccharine. It was smart and unorthodox without being flashy. It was intimate music, which isn't generally a festival vibe, but we were a captive audience for the duration of his set. I remember looking over at my nearest neighbor at one point to do the whole "are you seeing this? isn't this amazing" thing and realizing I was standing next to Ian Mackaye, who was every bit as engaged in the show as I was. My teenage years would come to a close that night, and as part of my transition into adult maturity, I refrained from bugging Ian to talk about how awesome Smith was. Or how awesome Fugazi was, for that matter.
I turned twenty at midnight. Built to Spill went on sometime around 1am. It was the first night of the festival... a Tuesday. Which meant I didn't get much sleep before going to my house painting job the next morning. Monorchid and Built to Spill were both great, but Elliott Smith was the artist I couldn't stop thinking about the next day. I think Dave might have even bought Either/Or that following afternoon, and since we lived in the same punk house, that effectively meant that Either/Or would also be in my general rotation that summer, along with Perfect From Now On and the early Modest Mouse 7"s. Between those three artists, you really have the Pacific Northwest music scene of the late '90s encapsulated in a perfect trifecta.
Things would change dramatically for Smith within the next year. The Good Will Hunting soundtrack introduced his music to a much broader audience. "Miss Misery" even landed a Best Original Song Oscar nomination, resulting in Smith playing the Academy Awards ceremony. A deal with Dreamworks followed. Our favorite Portland hipster troubadour had been given the Hollywood stamp of approval.
Dave moved out of the punk house, taking Either/Or with him. Smith's follow up album XO was too ostentatious for my tastes... too many strings and auxiliary instruments. I like my singer-songwriter stuff to sound like it's someone singing to themselves in their apartment, not to a full house at Carnegie Hall.
But you know how it is... a record fades out of your life until you hear it years later in a bar somewhere. And then you remember that even if the songs have been absent from your life for nearly thirty years, they're woven into the fabric of who you are in the present. So I scooped this copy of Either/Or a few months ago and I've been spinning it regularly... usually on the nights where I'm out with friends and want to wind down for 30-40 minutes before going to bed. Because while Smith would have his moment of primetime glory, his music always felt better suited for late nights and intimate spaces.








