abt arya's list, and what u said abt it being for justice, it made me think abt how for a long time i was confused as to why the mountain was on it, bc as far as i can remember (i haven't read the book in awhile) he didn't kill any of her ppl or hurt her personally? but it became more clear to me, he was just such a monster, that arya who is such a righteous character, wants him punished enough that he's on her list. so her list, its not just abt wrongs done to her its what injustices she's seen
or maybe im completely wrong! lol i hope im not too far off, its just that i know that ppl like cersei and joffrey and meryn trant, all did something to her or her family, but the mountain she saw torture other ppl, and it seems to me she was so horrified she takes it onto herself to seek justice for his crimes??? ur so good with arya meta i dont want to come across as too simple
so her list, its not just abt wrongs done to her its what injustices she's seen.Â
youâre not wrong--youâre bang on the nose. Â thatâs exactly what it is, and itâs part of why it being construed as vengeance bugs me so much because that doesnât fit for the vast majority of the people on her list, specifically the mountain and his men. Â itâs about miscarriages of justice that sheâs seen and how theyâve gone completely unpunished. Â every single person on that list is not someone who has necessarily wronged her personally (though obviously there are those who have), itâs people who have done wrong by what should be the law.
i say what should be: westeros has no rule of law, and no real good justice system.  so when arya sees what âshould be,â itâs based entirely on what she perceives to be right and how her familyâs moral compass has shaped her.  sheâs a character who knows very much that life isnât fair (an important lesson from her first chapter) but thereâs a difference between the societal âlifeâs not fairâ and the âweâre actively going to harm people because no oneâs going to give us shit about it,â thatâs a major thing for her.
the mountain and his men are on that list because they torture people. Â part of the reason she has jaqen kill chiswyck off her list is because heâs bragging about the gang-rape of a girl only a little older than arya herself. Â her going to jaqen is about her own fear (same for weese) because these men have power over her in a way thatâs terrifying for a ten-year-old; theyâre on her list to begin with because she sees what they do to people and knows that no one in charge of them is going to do anything about it because the people in charge of them set them loose to do exactly what theyâre doing.















