The Codeless Code: Case 28
Here the a Server Ops Monk is conducting a port scan on a system and finds some ports he believes are no longer valuable to be open and services running. he goes to tell the abbott of these services and that they should be shut down as they serve no value. The abbot then sends the monk to the mountain as punishment for a year. There he has an old terminal which occassionally sends him data. He is unable to reply with anything but the exact message that was relayed to him. Thus he was enlightened.
In this case I believe this may reveal some details about the infrastructure that the author works with. Here we have talk about Echo and Discard Protocols, which in modern computing do not serve much purpose. As the echo protocol simply returns the exact payload that was sent to it, while the discard protocol drops whatever is sent to it. In modern systems these are disabled by default as they are not commonly needed. The monk being given a VT220 is relevant information here, as terminals operate either in a half-duplex local echo, or rely on a remote echo in order to service the screen reflecting what the user is inputting. So in environments where terminals might be still in use, or old legacy code is harnessing it for some purpose that was derived from those old systems, these services are still valuable.
That said, I don’t think it was out of the question for the engineer to question why the ports were open, but he should have vetted out the reason rather than declare that they should be shut down without understanding why they might be relevant.