#ebonyviolin

Ivory Watcher AU

think about it, in her backstory videos, we see her with wings, and then later they're gone, but she has red marks/scars on her back from where they were. She told Ebony that it was her who'd made Ivory kill people, and that it wasn't her own choice. Ivory and Ebony are beings that can clearly travel to different worlds, even creating portals to them. They're some sort of higher being.

So imagine this.

Ivorycello becomes a Watcher. Her task is to find and kill certain humans, while being reassured that they will simply respawn in a different world. She does this task well. Too well. People stop respawning. So the Watchers send Ebony, a dark replica of herself, to lead Ivory somewhere far from civilization, where she cannot harm more people. The Watchers see and speak through Ebony, making Ivory atone for her mistakes and punish her for speaking up.

I think it is so interesting to see the difference in Whitepine Ivory and the Ivory we see in the unlisted videos as well as the videos that are on her channel that seem to be connected to Whitepine (going off of the playlist by Inkydiamonds) because they are the same person yet they are so different, i also got into watching some of the Kaboodle SMP because of Whitepine and it is so interesting to see Ivory’s character there as well, i love all of her characters

But i did want to talk about Whitepine because we are all patiently waiting for episode 11, which also people are saying it will be the last episode of Whitepine which I don’t think is true and I’m not sure exactly why people think that is a confirmed fact because I’ve looked to see if Ivory or any of the cast members have said anything in the discord but there is nothing on it there and I have looked to see in some other places but I have found nothing, I know i saw someone say that 11 has been an important number and that is why but I think if that does correlate to the series I would assume the 11th episode is going to be an important episode (which would also explain the wait as this seems to be one of the longest waits for an episode so far) but if anyone knows more about that please tell me

Anyways i did want to talk more about those unlisted/secret videos, as it seems most of the fandom knows about them but I don’t see many people talking about them except in the comments of those videos and of course since we have been waiting for the next episode I’ve been trying to see as much content of Whitepine while waiting, i’ve seen very few edits of the secret videos on tiktok which i did expect more, and the fanfic department I do understand as i have been combing through all the Whitepine fanfics on Ao3 (which if anyone wants fanfic reccomdantions I have many to offer) 

But I do think the unlisted videos are so important to the lore. We see who Ivory was and why she can’t remember things as well as why she is such a mystery. She isn’t from that world and therefore has no ties to it 

It does bring up the question of how much Ivory remembers, considering we are under the assumption that she doesn’t know much about herself, and I assume she has very little of her memories. She obviously has enough to remember her name and also to remember she used to be a “hostile person,” as she told this to Div in episode nine

I do wonder if it is more that she feels like she was, or she knows because she remembers she was, because she said she was a hostile person, but in the videos we know are of Ivory before Whitepine she is much more than hostile, that Ivory in the lore videos is hostel but also a bit manipulative and power-hungry and has gone through many different worlds and whipped out a lot of people within those worlds 

I also had a small thought in my head of what if she remembers everything but is actually trying to improve, however i dont think that’s the case but also how did Ivory forget, because it doesn’t seem like Ebony did anything to her when she pushed her into the world of Whitepine but maybe she used somesort of magic of sorts that she had to take away most of Ivory’s memories or maybe because Ivory was severely injured when she was pushed into that world it messed something up or maybe she had a head injury and that combinded with her being left in the snow did some damage to her memories

But i think Ebony erasing Ivory’s memories is more plausible at least to me as Whitepine Ivory doesn’t seem to understand certain things and things can easily go over her head, Mintuetech even says in the first episode that she has a bit of trouble learning things and he gave her a book to read on the train and how she stayed up all night trying to finish it (assuming he meant for her to read the whole book), which is very different from the Ivory we see in the lore videos, she is clever, extremely skilled, and is a bit more socially experienced than Ivory seems to be in Whitepine 

Another thing is how Ebony came to be, it’s mentioned Ivory tried to go into another world (for the first time?) and almost tore herself apart and that seems to be where Ebony came from (this is unconfirmed but i am very confident in the theory) and she has been bringing Ivory to different worlds after that, but that is until “Killing God” (which is a video on Ivory’s channel that seems to be connected to Whitepine) where Ivory does it herself and after that Ivory and Ebony are separated until Ivory’s “death” in “How to Beat Minecraft’s SCARIEST MOB (cavenoise.jar)” where she bleeds to death after fighting the Cave Dweller, which i think leads to the first unlisted video (which was unpoloaded before Whitepine’s first ep) that is just called “1” and we see Ivory in a white void thing and she meets with Ebony 

I do have a theory that kind of comes from that information im going under the assumption that Ebony came from when Ivory tried to hop into another world and she spilt and Ebony was made because of that considering Ebony is apart of Ivory somehow and Ebony herself considers her and Ivory the same person saying “you’re me, dumbass” to Ivory in “1” which I think is very interesting given how Ebony feels about Ivory and what she does to her but anyways continuing with the theory I have is when Ivory hoped worlds in “Killing God” she split again and made another version of herself like Ebony and that why that exit way in “7” appears as well as that is who is talking to Ivory in “9” when she is in that wooded radio tower area as the voice on the radio tells Ivory she is her and she tries to convince Ivory to let her through but Ivory doesn’t want to and the voice says that it is okay and comforts her saying no matter how bad it gets that she loves her 

Another thing also is the wings which this is also brought up on the “Whitepine Theory Doc” which is a google doc who can access via the discord (you can just search the word Doc on the discord and find the link) which it is made by fans and does a deep dive into the details of Whitepine and the lore videos while also giving different theories that have so much thought put into them and I highly recommend reading it or atleast taking a look at it but it also talks about Ivory (and Ebony’s) wings which are seen in some of the lore videos, during the videos sometimes Ivory and Ebony have wings while in others they don’t and sometimes one of them will have wings while the other doesn’t 

I was personally going off of the lore that is given about Ivory in KSMPI (Kaboodle SMP), which KSMP is not confirmed to be related to those Whitepine (and it probably isn’t) but I assumed that atleast some of the character background we get for Ivory’s character is the same or atleast similar, as most of the things were about things on her skin like the thing with her eye we see is mentioned to be a birth defect in KSMP and her wings were toren out by someone which is why she has scars on her back, which in some of the videos she is in servers and those severs might not be compatible with the mod she uses for the wings but i think it is important to note that she doesn’t have any wings in the unlisted videos so im assuming by that time she doesn’t have wings anymore and for some reason they were taken 

Which is interesting as in KSMP her wings are important to her character at least i think they are mostly as they are brought up a good bit because another character in SMP also had wings but hid them for reasons so Ivory would talk to them about it, which also another thing about Ivory’s character in KSMP is she is from the Nether and expresses that she enjoys fire as it reminds her of the Nether in the unfamiliar environment she is in (aka the Overworld as Ivory’s character had never left the Nether before so it was very strange for her) and i point that out because the only thing she keeps from the room she destroys in the unlisted videos is the fireplace, she tears apart the entire room trying to find a way out and that only thing she keeps is the fireplace which i think does hint to a similar backstory atleast and she even cries when it is taken away as it seemed to be her only comfort

"Make, no mistake. There's no escape." -Right Behind You (run away) by Jack Harris

Those song lyrics inspired me to make this! It fits the vibe of the bedrock box so well.