I think the fictional character report category is an idiot filter, like how 4chan lets you report a post for being "low quality"
So I'm hopeful that this is the case but the wording of the policy itself isn't very promising to me. So I've seen people bring up a specific part of the new policy ("photos of real individuals, illustrations, animation, or text"), namely the part about real individuals, and using that as proof that this is strictly about actual CSAM and threats towards minors and not about fiction.
But the way it's worded made me draw the opposite conclusion? Maybe I'm just being unnecessarily pedantic, but when items are listed out like that, it's usually to indicate that they're all individual items with any shared characteristics being placed at the end. So generally speaking, if all those things only applied to depictions of real minors, I would assume that it would be worded as, "photos, illustrations, animation, or text of real individuals." But because the "real individuals" part is at the beginning, "photos of real individuals", "illustrations", "animation", and "text" are all indicated to be separate and distinct categories.
Again, I could just be being pedantic, but I'm not hugely optimistic about this. And if the fictional content report button IS just an idiot filter, then it really needs to have a disclaimer establishing that the content in question will not be reported to legal authorities under US federal law even if it's found to be in violation of tumblr's policies. Not having that disclaimer is misleading at best, and at worst, it's an indication that tumblr staff will be wasting the time and resources of these organizations by reporting drawings of anime characters as CSAM.
















