âSoldier Gets Two Years For Assault,â Kingston Whig-Standard. April 2, 1940. Page 1 & 12. ---- Ward Rayworth Sentenced in Court Today - Companion Remanded --- Following a lengthy hearing in city police Magistrate James B. Garvin Tuesday afternoon found Ward Rayworth and Howard McGowan, soldiers stationed at the cereal building, guilty of assaulting and robbing Norman Carpentier of $7 at the foot of Clarence Street late on the night of March 31.
The assault took place near a C.P.R. work train on which Carpentier was engaged. They were charged with using violence on Carpentier Â
Rayworth was sentenced to two yeas in the Kingston Penitentiary as it was revealed he had a police record.Â
McGowan has no record, and for this reason Magistrate Garvin remanded him until Thursday in order to give more consideration to the case.
Evidence revealed in court showed that Rayworth had served several terms in Moncton for breaking and entering.
Magistrate Garvin stated he had been very lenient with cases in which soldiers had been involved, and that he would have to give Rayworth a sentence owing to his record to serve as a deterrent to others.
Men Identified Carpentier identified the two soldiers charged as the parties who assaulted and robbed him, and evidence was given about money being found on the two soldiers when they were taken to the police station and searched.Â
There was evidence that McGowan had two two-dollar bill in one of his boots and a one-dollar bill in his trousers pocket.
It was also revealed in evidence given by Constables William Cods and David Plotz that when Rayworth was searched, he had $2 in his trousers pocket and also had a bottle partly filled with wine.Â
There was also evidence offered to show that a button belonging to McGowanâs military coat had been found near the scene of the assault. The coat and the button were produced in court.Â
Saw the Assault Bemey Lunn, a soldier, testified that he had witnessed the assault. He swore that the two soldiers accused were the parties who made the attack on Carpentier.Â
Sergt. Henry Wolf testified that Carpentier had identified the two man accused as the parties who had assaulted and robbed him at the police station the night of the assault.Â
George Weymark, an employee of the C.P.R., gave evidence about finding the button off a soldierâs coat near the scene of the assault.Â
Pleads Drunkenness Rayworth in his defence, told his counsel H. A. McNeill that he had been intoxicated the night of the assault and robbery was charged but that he could not remember anything that had happened. He stated he was very drunk. Accused said he âhad been drinking everything" and when asked by the magistrate what he meant by this he stated he had been drinking wine, gin, and rum.Â
Rayworth also stated that he had money of his own on the night in question. He mentioned the sum of $3. He denied robbing Carpentier.Â
Denies Robbery McGowan admitted he had been with Hayworth and that he had been drinking. He stoutly denied having robbed Carpentier or having kicked him. McGowan also declared he did not see Rayworth take any money off Carpentier.Â
McGowan said that on the night in question, he had $6 of his own money on his person. He said he had $2 in one of his trousers pockets and $4 in one of his shoes. There had been evidence that McGowan had blood on his coat but aroused told Mr McNeill that the blood no doubt got on his coat while he was at work as he was engaged in the kitchen at the cereal building.
Leo Shoot a soldier rolled by the defence for McGowan stated he saw McGowan in front of the Frontenac Hotel on the night of March 31 but that he was âjust standing by" while Carpentier and Rayworth, he stated, were engaged in a row. Witness said ha saw Rayworth strike Carpentier. McGowan denied kicking Carpentier.Â
Dr. Robert E. Anderson, intern at the Kingston General Hospital, told about the injuries Carpentier suffered including fractures of bones in his face and cuts and bruises on his face. Witness said on cut under the left eye required three stitches to close.Â
McGowan stated his home was in Winnipeg. Rayworth said he had been living in Moncton and that he was 35 years old and married with two children. He had not been home for almost four years. McGowan also stated he was married.Â
Speaking to MoGowan, Magistrate Garvin stated he had learned he had no record and he believed that possibly he had been led into the trouble.
[AL: McGowan was given a suspended sentence but this crime ended his time in the military. Rayworth was a member of the Canadian Active Service Force, was 5 foot, 11 inches (very tall for the era), actually 25 years old, had been born in Port Elgin, and did have a wife, Elsa, and two kids, who lived in Moncton. He had previously been in the Dorchester Penitentiary and the Moncton, New Brunswick, city jail. He worked in the Kitchen at Kingston Penitentiary, had no reports to his name, save putting his name on a mass petition demanding radio at the prison, and was released back to the military authorities in November 1941. As always, I love that Canadians fetishize Canadian soldiers, especially of the World War 2 period, but most of them were no worse or better than non-soldiers - and plenty ended up petty thugs like this.]












