This post is for the other 5 henderhop shippers
I must say, I was just barely properly indoctrinated into this ship like 2 months ago and I freaking LOVE IT, not even in a ‘oh they’re what’s leftover if you ship Byler and Lumax’ nah, I ship them more than I ever shipped Byler and lowkey they’re on the same level as Lumax for me
Still like the concept of Mileven, was never a fan of the execution post s3
but now, especially after the finale and just… fucking hating El’s ending I found myself thinking about properly done tragedies and had the most random fic idea I’ve ever had that I’m low-key rolling around in my head since right now I’m just writing whatever I feel like
Okay so- fic idea, post s3 in a universe where the Mind Flayer/Upside Down shit ended there, Hopper lives, the Byers don’t move away and Mileven breaks up amicably but El is still struggling and she finally gets to go to school
So- this is an idea where, whilst figuring out what she likes, El finds she loves musicals and old stories because they make her think of what makes humanity, humanity and she learns about the story of… drum roll please… Orpheus and Eurydice
Through shenanigans and other random shit, this is a universe where Hawkins High either puts on a Hadestown production or El decides she’s gonna write a fucking musical just because (it helps with her vocabulary and grammar and she loves learning about music and shit like that) and dedicates pretty much all her time to it and once everyone sees how passionate she is about it, they all help and wind up suggesting she show it to the theatre club who help her figure everything out
she spends over a year preparing this so in this world, they’re a bit closer in age to the older teens (she and the party are 15 and in their second year of HS, Eddie is still on his 3rd try, met Dustin on his 2nd try, Nancy and the others are on their final year, 18)
Dustin is Orpheus cause he is canonically a good singer and he just fits and of course he’s gonna help El with her passion project. El made puppy eyes for a split second and he was like ‘Ugh fine if you insist’ (he loves it) and El absolutely does NOT take inspiration from him to write Orpheus
El is Eurydice and she is absolutely NOT projecting like crazy (‘I was alone so long I didn’t even know that I was lonely?!’ ‘Eurydice was a hungry young girl, but she’d seen how the world was?!’ ‘I don’t wanna go back to the lonely life?!’ ‘And for a moment I forget just how dark and cold it gets?!’)
Dustin is still in Hellfire and meets Eddie, whose also in theatre cause he’s a dramatic son of a bitch and of course he plays Hades, especially when, after one of his rants, El shyly approaches him and says she would like to include themes to criticize capitalism since she has learned the best musicals include heavy themes and if he can help with some lyrics since he’s already in a band and clearly knows what he’s talking about, Eddie decides in that moment he’d die for the kid and that he has to help Dustin with his increasingly obvious crush on her (he breaks up with Suzie not long after the end of s3 due to the long distance)
just imagine Eddie Munson having the ‘I conduct the electric city!’ line? Chills. Also he lowkey blackmails corroded coffin into helping out with the instrumental even if its a completely different genre
Chrissy Cunningham who is trying something new by being in theatre after either being forced to drop cheerleading or just wanting something new/it being suggested by Miss Kelley, she lands Persephone and at first plays her sweet and kind since she’s the goddess of spring but eventually realizes this is her chance to NOT be meager and controlled; after a pep talk from Eddie and El explaining her vision, she fully embraces the chance to be chaotic and crazy
Jason and her mom lowkey think she’s been possessed on opening night because she is COMMITTED to the bit of chaotic alcoholic, dancing around and giving it her all especially in Way Down Hadestown and Our Lady of the Underground, girl is (forgive my pun) livin’ it up and Eddie is losing his mind because what do you mean he gets to play his life-long crush’s HUSBAND?!
^ they’re a mess and they fall in love and they ship Dustin and Jane to the ends of the earth and Chrissy is low-key a big sister figure to Jane
and El/Jane is giving it her everything, figuring this out because she’s also trying to figure out who she is without her powers and without Mike and she just wants to make something.
Max helps with the costumes and Will paints backdrops, Lucas helps with props and choreo, Nancy is PROMOTING like crazy, you can’t turn a single street corner in Hawkins without seeing flyers advertising the play, Jonathan helps with the promo via photos and documents the progress and is the one who introduced El to musicals in the first place. Robin is in the band but as the trombone because holy fuck the trombone in Hadestown goes crazy, Steve does maybe hair and makeup idk
Mike is so proud because El is now the storyteller and, whilst they’re on good terms it can hurt to see him so he mostly tries to let her do her thing but eventually helps a bit with lyrics, just a tiny bit and helps with giving her pep talks when she’d doubting herself
and either Steve or Mike are Hermes, Steve is outta high school so it’d be hard but maybe Dustin talks him into it because he’d be perfect or Mike because he’s already a master storyteller and knows how to draw people in (he’d need so many vocal lessons though) and that’s how he and El fully become low-key besties again because El can’t see anyone else being the one to narrate the story.
or maybe Robin could be Hermes, she’d be great at it, though she’d sob the entire way through Road to Hell reprise
And Dustin gets to spend so much time with Jane, helping her figure out what she likes along with Max, helping her study and tutoring her along with Mr. Clark and seeing the way she seems to take on a whole different level of life as she figures out the story she wants to tell and reading on how musicals are structured and just pouring her heart into it and he always had a tiny crush but now he’s falling in love and OH GOD NO
And El being so grateful because Dustin was the first to take her musical seriously and didn’t hesitate to join in and he never tells her what she should do but just lets her bounce ideas off of him and he never doubts her and while she finds herself being able to teach him about music, he teaches her about the world and anything else she’s curious about but never makes her feel dumb for not knowing things and he highlights words he thinks she might like in a dictionary and is just always there
Both of them, but mostly Dustin, freaking out when they realize that the kiss scene Jane wrote is like… for them and they have to kiss and dance together and play a beautiful couple doomed by the narrative together.
Opening night, everyone is freaking out and Hopper, who is so glad Jane found something to be passionate about but is understandably hesitant about this whole thing is sobbing so badly by the end he nearly has to be taken out via stretcher.
Everyone is devastated, Melvald’s runs out of tissues by night 2, Max low-key has a crash out because everyone who isn’t in the play only ever heard snippets and Jane told NO ONE other than the theatre club that she wasn’t changing the ending and after tearing everyone’s hearts out and stomping on them along with Dustin, they just go out got for final bows with the biggest gummiest smiles.
Dustin’s mom is kinda crying for three days straight and insists on getting pictures of Jane as well
and Jane is so proud to have something that is hers and that she created and she gets to come into her own over the course of planning and practicing and everything and UGH-
I am consumed by the idea of this fic
Henderhop, Hellcheer, Hadestown, all the great Hs with a good helping of platonic Elmax, platonic Mileven, Dustin freaking out over what mike will think, Steve and Eddie giving Dustin horrible advice. Nancy giving him good advice, Chrissy and Jonathan being Jane’s big siblings, Will being her twin and absolutely NOT sobbing everytime he gets to hear a new snippet (he mgiht be the only one who gets to listen to whole songs before the play comes out)
yeah… might do it… who knows
if conformitygate isn’t real I’ll do it (so that’s an 85% chance that I will)
Thoughts? Anyone interested in this? Is this anything? Have I finally cracked under pressure?