Reader is gender neutral unless otherwise stated
Italic = Headcanons (bulleted format)
Plain Text = Drabble (no title with prompts)
#103. She’s my daughter, I can read her diary. (Female!Reader)
#29. You know when your phone buzzes, it means I’m trying to talk to you, right?
#53. Take off your shirt.
#2. Can you shut up for five minutes, please???
#27. “Please shut up. I can’t stand how appealing your voice is.” #47. “I love you and I am terrified.”
#46. “Just say that it is okay. I need to hear you say it.” #95. “Look at me - just breathe, okay?”
#5. “You can’t even look at me!” #6. “Stop looking at me like that!”
#5. “You can’t even look at me!” #11. “Why are you pushing me away?”
Katherine Pulitzer x Reader
#59. …or we could make out….
Friends? - Part 1 - Part 2 - Part 3 (Male!Reader)
The Meeting - Part 1 - Part 2 (1920′s Gangster AU + Librarian!Reader)
IN PROGRESS
#31. When’s the last time we went on a date?
#136. Did you enjoy yourself last night?
#43. Pick up lines only work when I’m drunk.
#81. “Hello ms./mr grumpy.”
#70. “If I marry them?” #71. “You’re my fake husband/wife/spouse, deal with it.” (Female!Reader)
Racetrack Higgins x Reader
Special Nights & Snowball Fights
Date Night (Poly Fic with Spot Conlon)
Stuck (Poly Fic with Albert Dasilva)
#131. You have a cold, you’re not dying.
#48. I bet you can’t go 24 hours without cussing.
#85. If you die, I’m going to kill you.
#53. Take off your shirt. #63. Sit still, for the love of all that is Holy.
#91. Sorry I’m protective over the things I love.
#9. “I had a nightmare about you and wanted to make sure you were okay.” #32. “You know, it’s okay to cry.”
Stuck (Poly Fic with Racetrack Higgins)
#90. “You can tell me anything.”
#4. “God, you’re pretty.” #12. “You take the bed, you need it more than me.”
#58. “Are you proud of me?” #59. “You’re so drunk.” #61. “What is that?!”
Date Night (Poly Fic with Racetrack Higgins)
#44. I can’t believe you didn’t remember
#17. “Come over here and make me.”
#81. “Can I kiss you?” #82. “Bring your pretty little butt over here.”
Jojo De La Guerra x Reader
All of the I Love You’s
#50. “I think you’re beautiful.”
#60. “Why don’t they just kiss already?” #71. “Is that a challenge?” #87. “That’s distracting.”
#54. “You’re the most amazing, incredible, beautiful being I’ve ever met.” #84. “You deserve so much better.”
#146. Pillows are over-rated.
#19. “Can I hold your hand?”
A Lodging House Holiday (not a reader insert)