posting my conformitygate theory (read it first, then come back) on tiktok when i had another thought (this is part two? i guess?)
let me remind you of these two scenes.
steve is theorising about vickie’s relationship with her boyfriend when robin cuts him off — in almost the exact same way dustin does in season 3 when steve starts spiralling while they’re spying on the russians.
steve, i don’t care. and i don’t understand why you do either with everything that’s going on. honestly, this feels like the perfect time for that little pull of the rug, because in the face of the world ending, the stakes of my love life feel spectacularly low.
yes, on the surface this is robin foreshadowing that her love life with vickie will get some kind of resolution in season 5 (or not — which also fits neatly into the illusion theory so far).
but it’s also steve’s foreshadowing.
steve’s entire dilemma in season 3 is him spiralling about his lack of a love life and social standing post-graduation — but dustin literally yanks him back into the mission, dismantling the importance of steve’s worries in the face of an actual emergency. steve is a great basketball player, which, narratively, means he’s a great team player — when he’s focused on the right task.
this moment with robin is doing the same thing.
she’s indirectly — but very clearly — telling steve that his love life isn’t as important as he thinks it is. she even uses the phrase “pull of the rug” — and robin has always been the character the writers used to signal to us coded hints about the story’s direction (every season, without fail).
so yes. it’s a rug pull. steve’s rug pull.
the rest of the conversation feels like perfect setup for the finale we actually got.
yeah. i mean, i get you there, but— i still have hope.
not everything has a happy ending. i’m not talking about failed romance.
robin says this right after steve looks at nancy — which directly foreshadows steve’s conversation with jonathan in the finale, when he admits that he’s realised he and nancy were never really in the cards.
i have this terrible, gnawing feeling that it might not work out for us this time.
you think we shouldn’t be doing this?
i think we’re mad fools, the lot of us. but if we don’t stop him, who will? we have to try, right?
this is the foundation for vecna’s play. after this — they do try their best to defeat him.
it is over, eleven. you have lost. you can’t stop this now.
season 5, then, becomes a mishmash of prior seasons — memories looping like camazotz. the never-ending story. this shift starts after the gates open in season 4 and the particles rise. from that point on, they’re all under a trance — believing they’re still fighting vecna while he’s slowly erasing and rearranging their memories, rewriting the story from the inside.
particular scenes from prior seasons serve as vecna’s surveillance, which is why there’s multiple scenes shot from a hidden angle, as if we’re observing alongside him.
when vecna sits the kids down in a circle and says, it starts tomorrow — he’s not just talking to them, but breaking the forth wall. he’s talking to us, telling his audience about the climax of his play — a finale that includes an epilogue, fully constructed from familiar beats and our favourite characters.
edit to add: every scene with vecna/henry where he “explains” something is a hint. he doesn’t monologue for fun — he plants rules.
which is why the chess game between henry and el in season 4 is also relevant. it’s foreshadowing will’s coming out scene (the floor pattern isn’t random) and vecna’s takeover of the narrative at that point.