I know people push to keep commenting on fics you like to show the author your appreciation for their work but guys...I've posted 3 long comments on one chapter already cause I'm re-read a great fic. This feels like too much. I'm almost live blogging my re-read in my comments.
Fic authors, how many comments on one chapter by the same person is too much ?
Also I sooo want to make art for this fic but art is so hard I had forgotten
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
okay hi everyone! so i asked if anyone wanted a guide on fic commenting and a few people gave the idea a big thumbs up (thank you to them!) so here i am about to deep delve into fic commenting.
if you would like a more detailed fic commenting guide with a ton of helpful tips and access points please check out this post by @thebiballerina
some disclaimers before we start (because this is the internet):
1. this is not a scientific articles, extensive research based post. this is me, an avid fic reader and consistent commenter explaining my how, what, and why of commenting.
2. i will try to make this as detailed and simple as possible however i am always open to questions, additions, and revisions.
3. the basis is just enjoy fic, it's there for you to love!
breakdown:
A. why/when i leave comments
B. how/what i comment
C. general things
A. why/when i leave comments
okay so commenting is not a necessity. it should never be a task that you dread or something you feel you must do if, and when, you reach the end of a fic. that being said, commenting does become easier the more you do it.
now i leave comments on almost every single fic i read. for two reasons:
1. i have gotten very very good at using filters and tags. ao3 is amazing with this; they really give you the full range of options to cater to your wants. so when i use their filters i'm only getting things i'm in the mood to read, which already makes the experience that much more enjoyable and that much less stressful.
2. if im not vibing with a fic i generally stop reading before i get to the end. i have learnt how to stop. not to sound like marie kondo, but if it didn't bring me joy i don't keep it. as you read fic you will pick up on what is a no-go, what is a maybe, and what is a hell yes, for you. which makes it easier to tap out or keep going.
keeping these two things in mind, when i do read a fic it is genuinely and generally because i enjoyed it. which means when i do decide to comment it's with complete excitement for the fic.
and the reason i comment: i want to let the author know that i enjoyed their fic, and what elements i loved specifically. simple as that: i want to let the author know they made me happy.
commenting is a more intimate and highly appreciated way to let an author know their work was read and loved. additionally, and i think this is even more important, it gives the writer an opportunity to interact with you as a reader. which in my opinion, is the true and wanted end result for most fic writers. because fic is often written for the author (self-indulgently) or to explore topics/
headcanons/ scenarios/ etc. but it is shared for the sole purpose of the reader. writers want your interaction. they love your thoughts and opinions and i know some, myself included, have literally gotten ideas for fic directions and other potential plots, from comments.
so if you feel you're bothering the author by commenting, please know (and i say this on behalf of every single fic writer) we love your comments and you will never bother us with your thoughts.
mini TL:DR-- i leave comments because i only read things i enjoy and am therefore excited to leave comments.// comments are much loved by authors because it lets them know just how much their work is appreciated and gives them an opportunity to interact with you.
B. how/what i comment
okay now to get into the nitty gritty of actually commenting. the first question was important because it's the basis for any comment.
so, please ask yourself when you set out to write a comment: did i enjoy this fic?
that question is gonna start a flow chart that looks something like this (the examples i use are from comments i have left on various fics. they will all be linked below under the "keep reading")
did i enjoy the fic?
no >> leave fic
yes (comment suggestion: i really enjoyed/liked/loved this) [eg. Fuck this was perfect]
if yes: why did i enjoy this fic?
no particular reason (comment suggestion, in addition to the one above, or as a stand alone: thank you for writing this)
if there is a particular reason: what did i enjoy about this fic?
i liked these lines (quote lines) [e.g. *cabled, slate blue skullcap softer than a summer breeze,* Okay this feels like one of those things where it SHOULDN'T make sense but it DOES because that is the true beauty and power of amazing writers!!! basically you're the coolest ever and I can understand this so well]
i liked that plot point/scene (briefly explain it/ quote the lines) [e.g. Oh Gods okay they were so so cute and then I read "husband" and I just PASSED away like what the fuck that's the fucking cutest thing ughhhhhhh thank you for this]
i liked your writing style [e.g. holy fuck this was haunting and poetic thank you!!!!!]
i liked your use of (insert writing device; i.e. poetry, descriptions, humour) [e.g. I'm obsessed with this with your writing style with the way they interact with the poetry sprinkled in you dear are killing the game]
i liked the way you wrote the characters [e.g. Also Sukunas pet namesđĽşđĽşđĽşđĽşand yuuji being so so gentle with megumiđĽşđĽşđĽşđĽşđĽşstopppp im gonna scream// love the dynamic of these four. But I love the way YOU write them specifically]
i liked your regard/disregard of canon [e.g. Your characterizations are immaculate. And I appreciate that although you bring in elements of canon (for the characters) you still keep them far enough away that they feel completely yours.]
i like the way you write angst/fluff/smut [e.g. Oh my gods I adored this thank you it was so gentle and soft and sweet and ughhhhhhhhhhh my babies// Holy hell this is so sad?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?! But Ughh I love it]
i like the pairings you came up with [e.g. It's them >>>>>>>>>> everything else for me]
other things to consider in a comment:
what you were doing/where you were at the time you read the fic (t's amusing and a gateway conversation opener for you, the author, and anyone else who might read the comment) [e.g. okay before I start let me set the scene (because you're used to my over excessive sharing nonsense by now): it's like 9:20 pm, I'm in bed and I've just put on my "Greek deities? no baby we're Greek tragedies" playlist.]
if you are listening to music: what song/playlist you're listening to [e.g. right now "anti-romantic" by TOGETHERXTOGETHER is playing (adore this song)// (also in the time I read that the song moved to "Genghis Khan" by Miike Snow which, side note: I think is defs something Percy would listen to and possibly also Jason, maybe even he introduces Pers to it)// Now to the next scene (song is "Slow Down" by Chase Atlantic)]
what time you're reading (it's hilarious to realise how many readers are doing a late night fic read) [e.g. Okay friend I justâ it's 10:05 pm I'm in bed (I have to be up early tomorrow) and I usually read some fanfiction before I sleep]
emojis are always a good way to express your love without using words. hearts (<3 or emoji hearts); pleading/soft face; shocked faces; angry faces [e.g. This was so sadđĽş]
exclamation points and question marks are easy and convey a lot [e.g. đWhy???????]
key smashes are also well received. (the idea that the fic made you incoherent is diamond-appealing and very satisfying) [e.g. cdaaqrgbkoiutrewtikmbcsaqg YOU CAN'T JUST WRITE POETRY AND THEN EXPECT ME TO BE OKAY??????gods this was amazing// Shkoyeaxbnlotewaaasfcbmlograshh yess]
stating your emotion(s)/actions as you read the fic [e.g. "or how he never pushes him away, never far enough." never *sobs* far *sobs* enough *sobs* why are they sooo perfect????// And this fic, this specific chapter, actually made me cry. Tears pouring down my cheeks, sniffling into my pillow kind of crying.]
explaining what you think may happen or what you hope doesn't (work's best with multi-chapters but if you're like me and like to write comments as you're reading it also works then) [e.g. Oh gods I hope this fic doesn't rip my heart out because I adore these two so much!??!!!]
C. general things
1. You don't need to have extremely long comments, but also don't be afraid to blabber on into mini essays. some of my comments are legit two words and some of them are like five hundred words. there is no such thing as a too short comment or a too long comment.
2. don't be discouraged if the author didn't reply to your comment. some writers do and some don't. that doesn't mean they don't appreciate it. trust me they probably did a little dance in their room with happiness when they read what you had to say
3. your comments could never get boring. if you comment "im in love with this" every single chapter of a 30 chap fic it is still appreciated. you took the time to say something and the writer is probably extremely happy and excited that they consistently gave you the happy chemicals with something they wrote
4. if you're really stuck for commenting a simple "thank you for this" always goes a long way
5. don't comment if it feels forced. comment on what you enjoy. if you see commenting as a chore you're going to make yourself miserable and make reading fic a task rather than an escape or a dose of serotonin (or whatever reason you may enjoy fic for)
6. if you're a re-reader it's always a wonderful thing for an author to hear "I've read this before but I love it so much I'm back". it's like: wow you like this enough to always read it?? I heart you. It's like getting an extra squeeze in a hug.
7. the main rule is: be kind, have fun, say good thoughts out loud, and if you can make someone smile do it.
thank you for reading and i wish you all the happiest bubbles during your fic reads <3
fics i used in examples:
(all links go to ao3)
Here in Our Bed Until the Morning Comes. by pythia (melancholic_piegon) @stillneedsmorekissing
our year by halpsur
warm leatherette by LowerEastSide
focus by ceinno
make a mess of me by auravere
our good boy by ohmytheon
tree by jeanjacketlesbian
hokkaido by rooted
my hot blood's been burning for so many summers by brightlyburning
this thing between us by chiuwurita
the space between by ohmytheon
night encounters by akamurasaki (cxlmberry)
why did you leave? by firerose17
knb kinktober 2020 by rhapsie
you promised by firerose17
we should have each other with cream by pythia (melancholic_pigeon)
I mentioned earlier I have been having trouble creating lately. I have read about other fan creators experiencing this as well. Hitting some kind of metaphorical wall. It maybe be the times we are living under, it may be those of us who are in frozen seasons under layers of snow, it may just be the rhythm of being human, but it is one where I am at present a leaf being carried by the stream instead of the force of the current.Â
It has been very close to a year since I watched my first episode of Chen Qing Ling. And 6 months since I wrote my first fic in that fandom. I had written my first fic 4 years earlier. It was massive and after I completed it, life drifted in and I didnât really think I would write again. But creators in the CQL fandom changed that. I had never immersed myself in fanworks as much as I did in CQL and all of it, every bit of it, helped me get through the last year.Â
And so in August, I got an idea for a fic, one that really got to the heart of why I loved Wangxian so very much and I wrote it for the fandom:Â
Closer - Wangxian, Lan Wangji has a lot of feelings about wanting to be closer to Wei Wuxian.
Someone commented on that fic today and it reminded me why I started writing again. And that was something I greatly needed. I am sharing that fic again here as a recognition of that, my love for fandom at its best, the love for an original work that is shared by people and fanworks given to each other just to make others who share that love feel something.Â
Cherry Magic came along and taught me that if you can really connect with people in a fandom on a personal level, the experience can be so much more meaningful. There are so many amazing people in this chaotic, often nonsensical world and knowing them makes it all just a bit better.Â
With all the things I have been feeling, writing is usually what makes it feel better. But it isnât just me being creative, that part is wonderful and a gift, but it is the people who have engaged with that creative process that have made it worthwhile. I miss that part most of all. Anyway, I have an appointment to write tonight and I intend to keep it.Â
Thank you to the commenter on that fic. It was their second comment on this fic, six months later. It was simple, but it reminded me that people are still engaging with what I create even months after I have moved on to other projects. Fanworks are something lasting, something others can continue to have. Something that can take fans and creators back to those works they love the most whenever they need it. It is really truly beautiful. I needed a reminder of that.
As a fanfic writer, the only âpaymentâ I will ever receive for my work is comments. Likes and kudos are nice, but comments (including tags people put on reblogs of my work) are what make my heart sing. Especially when someone finds something I wrote years ago (not-so-secret secret: Iâve had other usernames where my stuff is still posted, because I am adamantly against removing my work from where a person might want to come back to it) and leaves a shiny new comment about it.
It seriously makes my day.
HOWEVER!
I do not expect or require people to give any sort of feedback to enjoy my work. Feel awkward, shy, low-energy, lazy, etc., and all you wanna do is read? Thatâs awesome, and you should read the heck out of my stuff.Â
Look, Iâve been through some tough times in my life when all I wanted to do was read a fic and escape for a few hours. And when I was done, I didnât really feel up to doing any sort of interaction. And Iâve had times when I felt like anything I said would sound stupid (protip: most authors wonât think you sound stupid, theyâll be too busy grinning like a fool that you took the time to comment) because I suffer from really bad self doubt a lot of the time.
So I get it. Sometimes you read a fic, you love a fic, and the kudos button makes you freeze up with anxiety. And that is okay! Keep enjoying the fic, because...
Well, one reason I keep my really old work up is for those of you (of us) who are sometimes silent readers. Because whatever the reason, itâs okay. Because back in the day I used to back button out of fics that were âheld hostageâ for reviews (remember âIâll post the next chapter when this gets 50 reviewsâ notes? Those really rubbed me the wrong way).
I absolutely adore every comment Iâve ever gotten on any of my work, and I would absolutely love to get more than I do. But it is absolutely not a requirement for anyone who reads my fic. If all you ever do is read it and move on, you are still a valued reader and I appreciate that you chose to give my work a bit of your time. You donât need to give it any more than that.
I give my fanfic to the people who want it as a gift, and if any of you choose to give me a gift of a comment in return, thatâs just... bonus.Â
I am occasionally blessed to have someone write a really long comment or ask analyzing one of my fics or sharing personal headcanons about the story or even just reacting to the story, and more often than not they are accompanied by some form of apology. Like, âsorry if this comes off as creepyâ or  âif this is allowed.â And I get that a large part of that is this person being polite and solicitous of me and my time, which, thank you, that is so kind. Also, it sometimes seems to be almost apologetic of the time it took to think about my story, like their comment somehow betrays that they spent time thinking about the story and analyzing it, rather than just passively enjoying it. Like maybe thatâs embarrassing or something?
Let me just say, my lovelies, my darlings, Iâve spent nearly EIGHT YEARS now writing and thinking about The Changeling and the Armistice Series. Like, on a daily basis.
All that to say:
A) There will always be someone who has spent way more time thinking and overthinking about these stories (me), so no worries about that making you weird or whatever
B) The fact that you would think about my story at all is like the most amazing thing ever to happen and fills me with joy and YES I sure as hell want to talk to you about it (at great length, if you know me at all)
C) Your every thought and headcanon and analysis and question and theory and reaction give me life, make me feel like those years were worth it and writing the story was worth it, make me feel warm and seen and appreciated, and most of all, make me excited to keep spending the next eight years thinking and writing about it.
So please, my radiant kumquats, donât ever feel the need to apologize for that.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Because writers will stop fucking writing if you donât.Â
It is extremely sad to hear one of your friends consider the possibility of deleting all their fics and WIPS - something they spend hours on for free - because of a lack of feedback. I have entertained that thought too, many times. Writing is exhausting, time consuming, and sometimes frankly depressing and discouraging. As a reader, you can make a difference. This is not just about a writer leaving a fandom, because that happens all the time - itâs about a writer leaving a fandom and taking all theyâve offered to it with them because they feel worthless. Which is just revolting.Â
Fic writers lose sleep and gain anxiety over the work they decide to share with the world. If you donât show a writer your appreciation, you will get nothing in return. Nothing.Â
If you tell someone you like their work, you get everything. More stories to read when itâs a Friday night and youâre exhausted as hell, more fluff to comfort yourself with when youâre feeling cold, more fucked up stories when you feel in the mood for them, more smut when you need to relax. I donât know, man. Itâs just so fucking precious and rich and important, all these people who decide to take you places because it makes them happy to, but if you donât say a word of thanks, their carefully crafted world crumbles and turns to dust. Itâs as simple as that.Â
Comments make a writer write more. And not only for your entertainement, because it was never about that - not at the beginning - but for themselves. Knowing people appreciate the work they do helps us gain confidence, and confidence makes people. I never considered writing as a possible career option, but now, I have plans to develop a story thatâs been blooming inside my head properly on paper and put it out there, in the real world, to see if it worth it. I believe in it. I believe in the stories I tell, I believe in my writing, and it is only because of the positive feedback I have received for the past year.Â
This rant is a jumbled mess, because I am pissed off as hell. This shouldnât happen. Commenting on fics should be a given. Just comment on fics, acknowledge the writerâs work and you. Will. Get. Everything. You. Ever. Wanted. Do nothing and you will get nothing, and then you will wonder why this or that fic hasnât updated in months.Â
Guess what - itâs because I have better things to do with my time than spend hours working on a fic for people who donât care. I am done. Â
So I've been trying to figure out why exactly I'm so hesitant to leave comments on fics that move me. I keep saying I'm going to leave more actual comments and not just kudos, and then I keep not doing it. I think what it boils down to is, if someone writes 30,000 words that make me sigh and laugh and hold my breath, then saying "oh my gosh, I adored this, thank you" doesn't seem like an even exchange. And I know, I know -- saying "I liked it, thanks" is never a bad thing. I know from my own small collection of posted works that it's as exciting to read "loved this!" as it is to read an entire breakdown of favorite lines. But I realized -- I want to do justice to my experience of the story with my comment, and I freeze up trying to compose something that comes close to doing that. I've read stories that literally made me cry, or laugh out loud, or shriek at the big reveal. I've read stories that I kept thinking about for DAYS after I finished them, and stories that I've gone back and read over and over again. So I guess the way to comment on one of those would just be to say, "I thought about this for days after I finished it." But it still doesn't seem fair.