@conorace

I love the call back here and especially how dividing the effect of Martyr of Sands and including Sand tokens substantially alters this and allows some new strategies, particularly in a white weenies build. For this you’ll get a bonus point!

@nine-effing-hells

More work with tokens to create a neat riff of Lotus Blossom. This is especially cool in that it encourages plant tribal outside of just the tokens it creates on its own. That’s good for a bonus point!

@origins15

Way to bring the color pie back into alignment with your callback card! This references Rimescale Dragon from Coldsnap and origins15 was the only person who dared brave the icy art for this challenge, assuring themselves a bonus point!

@outerspace-messiah

This was a really popular art for this challenge and this wasn’t the only callback card to Solemn Simulacrum, but it was a beautifully designed card that evokes the original while doing something entirely different. A well-won bonus point!

@thekillershrub

@dimestoretajic

It’s still in the spirit of the challenge if I take inspiration from TWO cards, right? :D

I dunno, man. I just got a soft spot for Rusted Relic. I figured the least I could do for it is make it more like Solemn Simulacrum. Hope you like!

This is a neat combination of the two though I’d consider upping the mana cost a hair as I don’t think the Metalcraft requirement is a big enough barrier for that body. The biggest problem I think this card has is some potential rules confusion. Did you know if you don’t have Metalcraft and this is destroyed you won’t get the dies trigger? I was in error here. It works just fine though it sounds kind of odd.

Two points!

@conorace

A card inspired by Matyr of Sands for CFAC04. I thought about doing a card inspired by something more iconic, but Matyr of Sands is pretty neat and the art just fit with it.

Okay, this is really clever. I’ll save people the searching; Martyr of the Sands has an ability where you reveal any number of white cards from your hand and then gain three times that much life. This puts a step in between to allow it a powerful white token strat and bonus if Ladael dies. Great use of the pre-existing Sand tokens as well. This joins Dune-Brood Nephilim in being the second card to create those.

Two points!

@amtgplayer

This card is inspired by Eternal Witness, as well as the recent Wildest Dreams. At first I didn’t want to add the exile drawback because it would be awkward on a creature, and you have like a million ways to get around it anyway. However, the whole thing reminded me of the classical scene of flower-burial in Dream of the Red Chamber, where Dai-yu mourned her own destiny to be forgotten after death. It was so strong an image that I decides to leave the whole thing as is.

By the way, today I just realized that they gave Genesis Hydra a cast trigger not to make it feel like an Eldrazi, but because ETB triggers and X don’t work well within the rules. (See: the unintuitive template on Quarantine Field).

Good catch on that rules stuff. It also helps balance this--you can’t abuse flickering effects to net even bigger card advantage. Eternal Witness is one of my favorite cards so I’m excited to see something like this. But comparing it to Season’s Past, I think you’ve hampered this design too much. At 6 CMC X is 2. Season’s Past doesn’t have a body, but it probably grabs 4 or more cards for you when cast (I’ve never seen one get less) and it has the ability to let you get it back later. Season’s Past does require you select cards of different CMC, so I wouldn’t want something like XGG here, which would put 6 CMC at 4 cards, just like what I think a baseline Season’s Past is, but I think X and 3 or 4 G wouldn’t be far off. I don’t feel the exile bit is necessary here.

The alternative is to decide a set number of cards and a hard mana cost (which could then allow this to be an ETB trigger and necessitate the exile bit, which I would then change to “If ~ would leave the battlefield, exile it.”).

Two points~

@thekillershrub

I love the Magus Cycle. Lots of them reference powerful lands, and I feel like Valakut is powerful enough to have one. Multiple of these is scary, so 5 mana instead of 4. 

This is definitely scary. Great take on expanding a cycle that’s pretty much all about referencing other cards. You have altered the Valakut ability in a significant way though--Valakut requires five other mountains so it only triggers on the sixth and beyond. This would count the fifth and trigger earlier... except that if you cast this on curve then you’ve already played your land for the turn and can’t get the trigger right away.

I also was wary of the body and entering tapped bit--doesn’t feel red to me--but it’s growing on me as this would help to enable a mono red control archetype as both a repeatable free Bolt and a win con. Still think the body might be too big since you don’t want to attack with this anyway, so I’d knock it down to a 3/3 probably.

Two points!

@ubervores

Who doesn’t like burn? the person on the other side of the table that’s who but nonetheless banefire has some pretty sweet art so a referential card would have equivalently sweet art (in my opinion this is the better art.) So I mean what more can I say than Its bane fire lady? I didn’t want this to be goblin guide with a banefire stapled to it so she costs three when not spitting fire making her a haste-y bear with an almost banefire stapled to it.

I hear ya! Technically red gets can’t be countered on instants and sorceries and green gets it on creatures, but this is a fair bend in my eyes. (Akroma is exception and she was printed in Planar Chaos, which is not a real precedent) Otherwise this looks like a whole lot of fun to me. I think you could probably split the difference so to speak on casting cost and put it at XRR. A haste bear for RR is definitely not breaking anything and at mythic X should be pure bonus.