Re: your âCosĂŹ would be so good if it was goodâ post â hard agree, do you have any thoughts on what you would ideally do to improve it given the chance to direct a production or fully write an Improved version?
My vision for a version of the ending I desperately want to see has always been âduring the final chorus, the lovers and Despina look at one another, all very visibly have the mutual realization that Don Alfonso manipulated them into cheating/enabling cheating on each other for no fucking reason, and encircle him menacingly. The curtain falls on all five of them united in cathartically kicking the shit out of him. Bonus if his expression indicates something like âyeah, this sucks but Iâm aware I kinda deserve itâ.â
i fully support don alfonso getting the shit kicked out of him because honestly fuck that guy LOL. i would jump on that stage and join in brother. i'm also conceptually a fan of that production in the midwest(?) recently where the audience got to choose-your-own-adventure for the ending (stay together, couple swap, or divorce). really fun spin on things and lets the audience engage actively with whether the show's plot "resolution" as writ works or not.
but anyway i think my problems with cosi are sort of with enough of the work that just restaging the finale on its own isn't enough to "fix" it for me. i think the show's premise itself is too cynical, but still tries to be sincere, or at least get you to feel sincere at moments where it absolutely does not jive. like, in the second act, i'm supposed to feel sorry for the boyfriends when they're beefing with each other over their gfs being unfaithful? motherfuckers that's YOUR fault! i don't feel bad for you you played yourselves. and i cannot stand the boys being on any kind of high horse at the end while the girls are beating themselves up for doing nothing wrong in the face of being cruelly gaslit and manipulated by their loved ones. also, the fact that the entire thing takes place over, like, two days is just too absurd to take seriously.
so, barring a complete rewrite (which it might need anyway bc tbh parts of it really drag for me. could at least use some trimming) my ideal version of cosi really leans into the cynicism and immaturity of the situation. so my production concept takes place in a high school LOL. the boys are like football or lacrosse jocks. "going off to war" is like, traveling out of town for the tournament or whatever. their girlfriends are cheerleaders. alfonso is their crazy unethical AP psych teacher running an "experiment" with them. i haven't settled on what despina is yet but maybe like a really cynical admin or custodial staff member at the school who has rapport with students but also despises having to work for idiot teenagers day in and day out. i'm not sure if this alone would 100% "fix" cosi for me (i think cosi's problems with tone and misogyny are just really difficult for me to reconcile tbh) but i think it would go a long way in addressing my distaste for the show's stupid plot and the way it wants me as a viewer to engage with it. because, like, if they're explicitly a bunch of idiot 16 year olds, then yeah, it makes a little bit more sense when they act that stupidly and over-the-top, lmao












