"Briallyn sucks at making plans!" ā another rant by yours truly
(this wasāagaināsupposed to go into the notes of my fic but turned out too long)
And then it was time for another lengthy rant, because the plot holes in ACOSF specifically are a gift that just keeps on giving. Especially anything concerning Briallyn and her stupid-ass plan to lure Nesta into her Evil Trap.
Alright. So. If you really think about it, Briallynās plan in ACOSF makes ZERO sense. None.
As far as we know from canon, the end-goal of her convoluted kidnapping plot was always to kill Nesta. Both to get her revenge on Nesta for taking too much from the Cauldron and Briallyn ending up old and frail as a result (which⦠dramatic, but I guess), and then to take the Dread Trove items from Nesta (to achieve world domination, original).
So she has Nesta kidnapped from Emerieās house. Great! She now has Nesta tied up, drugged and unconscious. Plan complete! Right? Wrong.
She proceeds to SET NESTA FREE. Into the Blood Rite. Where she could be killed by some random Illyrian at any second and render Bri-Briās grand plans of vengeance null and void.
So Nesta is now fighting her way through the Blood Rite, to āwear her down.ā After Briallyn literally already had her in prime-kidnapping-condition of drug-induced grogginess, but I digress.
In the meantime, Briallyn doesnāt watch Nesta struggle or get chased by her Illyrian lackeys though, which seems like something that wouldāve gone well with her allegedly sadistic plan of revenge. No. Briallyn then⦠kidnaps Eris. To⦠lure Cassian??? In what absurd world is ERIS the correct person to kidnap if you want to draw CASSIAN out of Velaris? Did I miss something? The one thing about this entire part of the plot that makes sense is that Cassian immediately went āWell, too bad. Sucks for him.ā when Azriel told the IC that Eris had been kidnapped. Thereās also never an explanation as to WHY Briallyn chose to kidnap Eris specifically, which still seems wildly suspicious to me. Any other Night Court ally would have been more enticing to Cassian. Literally anyone. Even someone like Keir, probably, just for the satisfaction of killing him himself.
Anyway, Briallyn brainwashes Eris with the Crown and parades him around for a bit so Az and Cassian (whoās there only because Rhys ordered him) can watch from afar. She brings Eris to Koscheiās lake to lure the batboys there and makes a half-assed attempt to have Eris stab Cassian. Thereās a brief moment with Koschei that feels very āyou havenāt unlocked this villain yetā and then Az whisks Eris away while Briallyn uses the Crown on Cassian and takes him back to Nesta for⦠reasons. Probably to distract her so Briallyn can hold her evil monologue.
After explaining her motives and plans to Nesta like some 2000s cartoon villaināinstead of just, yāknow, putting her under the Crownās thrall while she has the chanceāshe of course loses spectacularly to the Power Of Love and Lazy Writing. Because somehow, the least believable part about this is that a human queen who has both a vendetta against and obsession with Fae would be defeated by her own unfortunate wording in her command to Cassian. Who the fuck just says āKillā in the most dramatic way possible, without specifying WHO to kill?
Nesta, whose power wasnāt drained or worn down in the least from Briallynās fun little plan, simply erases her from existence.
The End.
And Iām still here wondering what the point of all of that was.