Slingshot -> moose, antlers mimic the wooden parts and moose heads on walls being like how his head comes off

Bread -> horse, because he is referred to as a horse in show

Lamp -> sheep due to lamb and lamp being similar words, along with lambs symbolising youth and innocence linking to how his past plays into his character. lamps are often associated with night -> sleep -> counting sheep. give him horns let him ram into people

Popsicle -> reindeer, antlers are like her sticks, arctic animal -> cold -> ice -> popsicle

Elastic Band -> Weasle, tiny but long animal, flexible to represent her stretchiness

Waw -> tuna. hes tuna

Window -> glasswing butterfly, fragile, transparent wings

Notebook Paper -> he's literally a seal. scratch his bellayyy

Cakey -> goat, horns are like her candels, goatee/fluff is like her frosting dollops, goats and sheep are often associated with each other, linking to how her and lamp's past is gonna be important. AND SHES THE GOAT!!!

Coffee -> civet, kopi luwak coffee, that animal is so non-binary

Jellybean -> fox, if the her working for mace twist is true then it works with foxes being deceitful little tricksters, other than that - red, curious and clever

Phone -> lobster, multiple arms, gun hands look like claws

Grapefruit -> squirrel, squirrels like grapefruit and hes so squirrel

Candy -> cheetah, fast, cool markings

Cup -> rabbit, ears can look like handles, social, enthusiastic

Button -> dog, dog communicate with button

OJ-> rat, "I think i'd be a wolf. I think so too" jerma clip. he'd be a rat. also eww alpha male podcaster eww rat.

Pool -> orca, killer -> dead, whale -> water -> pool