me and my english degree would LOVE to hear about ej and nate as narrative foils whenever you get around to it
this story, like a lot of stories in hockey, starts with sidney crosby.Ā
in 2005, a year after a lockout, sidney crosby was the Next One, the boy from cole harbour made good, and the sidney crosby lottery was a heartwrenching battle of luck and odds, a spectacle that the penguins won, and they have three cups for their trouble. when sidney crosby was drafted, the only question was that who could follow. this story isnāt about crosby, really.Ā
this story is about his shadow.Ā
in 2006, the year after crosby was drafted, erik johnson was a dynamic defenseman fresh out of catholic school in minnesota tearing up the usntdp and earning two straight gold medals at the wjcs. nathan mackinnon was another boy from cole harbour, watching his hero put nova scotia on the map, and wanted to be right there with him. heās going to be a hockey player. he has no other plan.
ej was drafted by the perennially cup-hungry st. louis blues in 2006, the first american-born defenseman to go first overall. in hindsight, the 2006 draft class was exceptionally stacked, producing players players like jordan staal, jonathan toews, nicklas backstrom, phil kessel, claude giroux, and brad marchand. and at the very top, the first overall: erik johnson.Ā
ej, no matter where he went, was committed to the university of minnesota, set to be a golden gopher on the advice of his mother. but then, no first overall goes to college, right? no first overall defers their chance at the nhl. but ej does, spends his freshman year in college, and becomes the first top draft pick to go to college in 44 years. hockey pundits questioned it, and the bluesā decision to let him, instead of throwing him into the fire the way every other first overall would before and after him, but he went.Ā
a season later, ej has his rookie season and itās...fine. he puts up 33 points in 69 (nice) games, respectable for any high end dman, and his third highest point total of his career. but for a first overall? in a draft class like his? was it the right choice? was he worth it? the questions mount, and come to a head in 2008, when ej crashes a golf cart during a team party, and tears the ligaments in his knee. the official team statement is that his foot got caught between the pedals of the cart and twisted wrong. all the gossip around the league knew that he was drunk.Ā
he comes back the next season blazing, setting a career high in points, and the next year he wins a silver medal at the olympics, but the damage was done, to his knee and his relationship with the blues. his injuries flare up, and he puts up less and less points, his playmaking ability and defensive smarts are questioned more and more. in january of 2011, ej gets hit in the face with a puck during practice, knocking out several of his front teeth. two weeks later, heās traded to the colorado avalanche.Ā
heās given a swedish underwear model for a roommate and a captain, and a chance to be the number one defenseman for a team that needs him, and he takes them both.Ā
the consensus among hockey media was clear: if it werenāt for nail yakupov, erik johnson would be the worst first overall draft bust since rick dipietro.Ā
two years later, in 2013, the other boy from cole harbour is all grown up. rocketing through shattucks, and running roughshod over the qmjhl (to the point where he refused to play for the team that drafted him because he didnāt speak french, instead opting to play for his hometown halifax mooseheads), leading the mooseheads to their first memorial cup. nate is finally good enough that crosby takes notice of him, and he beats out seth jones to be selected first overall to the colorado avalanche.
he walks into the locker room and demands they all call him dogg, after his other hero, nate dogg. he has a rookie season that earns him the calder, and the first taste of playoff hockey for them both. and then, for the next few seasons, nate starts to regress. the team around them starts to breakdown, chafe under the aggressive coaching style of patrick roy. all through it, nate can look to ej, the teamās other first overall, earning his way back into hockeyās good graces.Ā
in 2015, ej matches his career high in points and gets selected to be the avalancheās representative at the all star game in columbus. and like every other time heās set to hold the world on his shoulders, his knees buckle under its weight. right before the all star game, he gets injured again, and replaced by another rookie first overall, the panthersā aaron ekblad.Ā
and then comes 16-17, the worst season in franchise history, their coach abandoning them. they lose, and lose, and lose. ej gets his worst injury yet, breaking his leg, and duchene loses faith. nate hits his lowest point, frustrated and mortified, to the point that he sees staff waving at them at the rink, and all he can see is their disappointment, their embarrassment.Ā people talk about ripping the team apart and setting fire to the remains, trading gabe, trading everybody. the leadership team, including nate and ej, refuse to give up on themselves.Ā
nate changes his workouts, his diet, starts seeing a sports therapist. he becomes one of the best players in the league, one of the best players in the world, dragging his team with him to the top. heās a hockey player, and thatās all he knows how to do, and he refuses to let them call him a bust.Ā
ej has been an av almost five times longer than he was a blue, and he has been their unquestioned number one defenseman for years. as heās gotten older heās stepped back, focused on helping the younger, faster dmen who would replace him, but is just as capable of throwing himself back in when heās needed. heās broken, over and over again, but every time, heās put himself back together with a toothless smile and a quip for good measure. heās taken all the people who wrote him off, and built a career for himself, despite everything. despite everything, heās still him.Ā
two first overalls, alike in dignity. two sides of the same coin, two careers branched out and intertwined. they are what each other could be, and what they could have been. when nate wants to shoulder the world, ejās there to remind him he doesnāt have to do it alone.Ā