Sarah Paulson Characters Headcanon: Them flirting with you plus having a crush on youâ¨
Cordelia Foxx (Pre-Supreme)
shy, subtle, coy
-She is very shy and holds back on expressing her feelings and emotions
-Delia would notice her heart fluttering a little, whenever you passed her in the hallways or whenever she would notice you watching her silently in the greenhouse
-You would have to make the first steps, otherwise she would be way too shy and insecure, thinking this is all in her head
-After she notices that she isn't reading the whole thing wrong however, she will often give you her dopey, adorable smile
-Her whole face will light up whenever she sees you pass her, her nose scrunching slightly and even her eyes reflecting the happiness she feels when seeing you
-Would compliment your outfits or praise your improved magic but be an absolute blushing adorable mess
-''Well done Y/N'' she will tell you and bite her lips in that adorable shy way
-Red cheeks, trembling hands and heart beating out of her chest whenever she attempts flirting with you but she makes it very obvious by being so adorable
-When you walk up to her eventually, feeling confident you whisper ''Why won't you just admit you have been trying to flirt with me Miss Cordelia?'' and she would be an even more blushing mess and avoid avoid avoid the situation
-After that her concern, insecurities and doubts leave her and she feels confident, will openly flirt with you, just not around the girls because she is too shy for that
Cordelia Goode (the fucking supreme)
direct and obvious but thoughtful
-confident, boss Delia is a completely different story than Cordelia Foxx, shy adorable headmistress
-She would openly flirt with you and not really caring who is there to witness
-Cordelia isn't like too forward or bold or anything but she does for sure flirt in her own way
-She would always flirt through her eyes, either giving you the most loving expression, showing how much her heart desires you
-But she definitely also gives you bedroom eyes, from across the dinner table, undressing you right there simply with her eyes, before undressing you later on with her hands
-Would praise you a lot in front of the other girls and it's quite obvious by then how much she likes you
-Cordelia has a massive soft spot for you, not scolding you for things she would usually scold Madison for like leaving the greenhouse a mess or breaking a few of her other rules like coming home later and stuff
-She is a very touchy flirter. I feel like one of her hands would always be lingering on your body somewhere. Rubbing your shoulders in a comforting manner, putting her hand on your thigh while having dinner with the rest of the girls, in a possessive manner
Ally Mayfair-Richards
direct and obvious
-Ally will have a hard time hiding the fact she likes you, like a whole lot
-She is a bit careful at first, wanting to get to know every aspect about you because of all the crazy things that had happened in her life
-But in the process of getting to know you better, she completely falls head over heels for you and it's that obvious that her ten year old son manages to figure and point it out
-''Mom do you like Y/N?'' he will ask, after also meeting you a bunch of times and you often playing with him
-That's when Ally noticed and she stopped trying to hide her feelings or affection towards you
-She is a direct and obvious flirter, not trying to hide anything
-Will shower you in compliments, your hair falling perfectly, your outfit looking stunning and sexy or her loving your wine taste
-Ally asks you on a date to her restaurant eventually and she can't stop flirting with you, making you blush several times that night
-A lot of openly flirting and winking ''Yes I am trying to flirt with you sweetheart''
-''I really want to kiss you right now'' she will tell you after having dinner, while she walks you home that night
-Indeed the senator is the one making you blush like a mess and quite literally melt in her touch
Wilhemina Venable:
hard to get
-Mina will play hard to get with you
-Of course she will notice the way your eyes would scan her features, every time she walks past you
-The way you would be all nervous around her, fidgety and stumbling over your words
-There is nothing Wilhemina hates more than fidgeting or anyone unable to speak properly in her presence but secretly she thinks it's adorable how nervous and speechless you get around her and how intimidated you clearly are
-Wilhemina will enjoy playing with you and teasing you, making this whole thing a game
-She would cause you to squirm whenever she would give you that glance, looking up and down your entire body or whenever she would call you by your full name
-A lot of cane banging and her scolding you for random stuff just to make you even more nervous and it definitely gives her a tingle
-She also flirts by doing stuff that isn't like her, like her eventually calling you by your first name
-She takes it a little too far, to the point where you have no idea whether she likes or hates you and so it's up to Mina to clarify her feelings and fix this
-Mina will fix it by asking you out ''So would you accompany me for some lunch?'' she will ask randomly one day, lunch break at Kineros Robotics approaching ''As in like a date?'' you asked dumfounded
-''Of course not... unless you would like it to be'' she will reply, her little insecure side showing even if it's just for a split second
Audrey Tindall
direct and obvious plus hilarious
-She will not hesitate showing her affection towards you
-Gives you bedroom eyes from the first moment she ever sees you
-Openly, happily and directly flirts with you
-Very cheesy flirting though and silly pickup lines like ''Are you wifi? because we have a great connection?''
-''Are you a fruit? because you are a fineapple''
-Audrey is very proud that she is finally able to show off all her jokes and flirting
-She will for sure, tickle you or make you smile and burst out laughing because she loves the sound of that
-Will be so soft with her british accent and act all proper around you to impress you
Billie Dean Howard
very direct and obvious, master at flirting
-Hear me out: from the first moment she sees you, she is determined to be the medium of your heart
-She will never hold back, no matter if someone else is speaking to you, even a possibility of someone else dating you, Billie doesn't care
-Billie is a master at flirting, she knows everything, all the tricks and things she has to say or do to make you blush or wet
-She technically wouldn't even need to do much because the silk blouses, acrylic nails that would sometimes tap on the counter making you all nervous, or scratching against your shoulder gently would make you so nervous
-Let's not talk about the way her smoking and how she inhales and lights a cigarette makes you feel
-Petnames, petnames, petnames: Babydoll, pumpkin, sugar, kitten
-She loves exploring different sides of you, the shy and nervous side, the playing hard to get side or the side where you would flirt back
-Billie is full of herself and knows she can have you if she wants you and she does want that more than anything
Sally McKenna
direct and obvious + shy
-Sally is a mix of every type of flirting to be honest
-I feel like at first, she will not hold back and openly flirt with you, showing you how attracted she is to you and that she likes you
-She will act very confident and full of herself around you even though on the inside she's a soft insecure bean
-Will wink at you or keep eye contact while lighting a cigarette
-Would happily and confidently walk up to you sitting at the bar and say ''What are you drinking sugar?''
-A lot of old fashioned pickup lines and flirting
-Eventually, once she notices that you also seem to like her a little and attempt to flirt back, she would get a bit insecure, unable to believe someone likes her back
-She would definitely give you bedroom eyes all of the time and undress you with her eyes
-Sally will at some point have a ''fuck it'' attitude and if you would allow her to, just take you straight to her bedroom
Lana Winters
waiting for first move
-Even though past asylum Lana is confident and a tough cookie, she would wait for you to make the first move
-She isn't oblivious though and quickly notices your affection towards her and she will secretly love the way you make her feel
-Definitely feels a boost of confidence through your flirting
-Once Lana is ready and starts flirting back, she won't hold back but she will be subtle, not too direct or extreme
-Will shower you in compliments
-Often blushes around you but she will make you blush in return
-With Lana it will be one of those adorable but also powerful kind of falling in loves, holding hands in public, kissing each other's cheeks, whispering secret love confessions and kinky stuff
-However Lana is a tough cookie and if she wants you, she will have you and won't hesitate to do anything it takes
Bette and Dot Tattler:
Bette: shy, subtle coy, Dot: thoughtful
-Bette will be an adorable, shy, blushing mess around you
-It will be so obvious to anyone around, including yourself that she has developed a crush on you
-Will say dopey stuff and have that one very special smile, she only shows around you
-Whenever she talks to you she will embarrass herself by saying stuff that makes zero sense because her brain stops working around you
-Dot will be very annoyed by her sisters behavior and often tell her she needs to stop ''For gods sake Bette will you stop this''
-She hates whenever her sister has a fantasy or sex dream about you because she will see it too, but she secretly likes it because she secretly likes you too
-Dot will be very thoughtful and think things through before talking to you or flirting with you
-She will play hard to get with you and so you would be the one making the first move
-The feeling in her chest and stomach, whenever you walk past them, smile at them or do anything, scares her to death
-They often try to distract themselves when you are around and so they wouldn't embarrass themselves or make it even more obvious than it already is. Bette will think of a soft field of flowers to distract herself and Dot will think of destruction of the earth to take her mind away from you
Mildred Ratched
thoughtful flirt
-Even though Mildred is a badass, she is very careful when it comes to flirting with you and showing her affection
-Multiple reasons, one being her worried you don't feel the same way back and her also being a bit oblivious sometimes plus her not really understanding her own feelings that much
-Once she realizes that you like her and that she likes you in return, she wouldn't be so subtle and thoughtful anymore
-She will give you compliments, telling you she likes your outfit choice that day, the color of your hair or how pretty your eyes are and how she could get lost in them
-Mildred can be very romantic and sweet
-Her dominant and possessive side can very easily show too though
