#atg sutton

Instead of a strict ranking, here are their general vibes when those feelings creep in:

Pike (N): They would see the competition simply as an opportunity to show you why you should choose them. Fighting or arguing with someone else over you? Nah. Pike would focus entirely on you, do their absolute best, and leave the choice in your hands.

Fox (R): They would feel a bit insecure at first, but then they'd remind themselves that you chose them when you could have chosen Sutton or Pike. That has to mean something, right? They would handle the feeling in a mature way and choose to trust you.

Navarro (T): He is used to watching you from afar, so his jealousy is more about quiet resignation and putting his professional walls back up. He wouldn't make a scene; instead, he would take a step back, quietly thinking you have better options than him.

Cross (S): As the ex, he definitely thinks he still has a say. Expect some very territorial, passive-aggressive comments disguised as "concern."

Sutton (C): They are definitely prone to jealousy, but they are not ones to make a scene. Sutton would pull you aside privately, express their concern, and talk it out. They might hide a lot from the public, but they absolutely do not want secrets in their private life.

As for the second part of the ask (omg it truly is long lol):

Sutton

Want: "I want us to be real."

Need: "You don't have to put on a show for me."

Dread: "This whole thing was just a business transaction to me."

Fox

Want: "I feel completely safe when I'm with you."

Need: "I'm not going to leave you behind."

Dread: "You're just a distraction."

Pike

Want: "Everything is better with you."

Need: "You belong here, and you are doing amazing."

Dread: "You're too naive."

Navarro

Want: "I want you, despite everything."

Need: "I trust you with my lowest moments."

Dread: "You're just another paparazzi trying to ruin my life."

Cross

Want: "After all these years, I still feel everything when you’re near."

Need: "I will always care for you."

Dread: "You're my biggest mistake."

1. Their Perfect Date 🍷

Sutton (C): Since their entire life is a public performance, their perfect date is the exact opposite. Staying in, ordering takeout from a place nobody knows, wearing sweatpants, and watching a terrible movie. No cameras, no PR rules, just being completely normal and relaxed without having to perform.

Pike (N): Something active and playfully competitive! Go-karting, an escape room, or an arcade. Pike wants a date where you can banter, challenge each other, and laugh out loud. And yes, they will absolutely try to win, but they'll buy you dinner afterwards.

Fox (R): Something completely unplanned and away from the crowds. A spontaneous drive to a scenic overlook at sunset with a bottle of good wine, some cheap takeout, and just talking for hours. For Fox, the perfect date is one where they don't have to manage a single thing.

Navarro (T): An underground, hidden gem of the city. A rooftop with no public access or just walking around the streets at 2 AM when the city is asleep. Navarro wants to escape the Hollywood bubble and share a quiet, unfiltered piece of the real world with you.

Cross (S): Something nostalgic. Cross misses the times before the fame complicated everything. Their perfect date is recreating an old memory—going to that dive bar you both used to frequent, or just driving aimlessly listening to a playlist from years ago.

3. How they react when the MC is silly 🤪

Sutton (C): At first, their PR reflexes might kick in and they'll look around to see if anyone is watching. But once they realize it's just the two of you, they'll hide a fond smile behind their hand. They absolutely love that you feel safe enough to drop the glamorous facade around them.

Pike (N): They will immediately match your energy. If you make a terrible joke, Pike will make a worse one. It instantly becomes a competition of who can be the most ridiculous.

Fox (R): They will sigh, shake their head, and say something like "What am I going to do with you?" while fighting a massive smile. They'll probably tease you about it later, but secretly, they find it incredibly endearing.

Navarro (T): Quiet, genuine laughter. Navarro is so used to celebrities being fake, guarded, and hyper-aware of their image. Seeing you be completely unfiltered and silly feels like a rare privilege.

Cross (S): They will give you that specific, fond look that says "I know exactly who you are." They'll roll their eyes affectionately and banter right back, effortlessly falling into your old rhythm.

Sutton (C): They would look the MC up and down. A real, slow, deliberate glance from head to toe, taking every single detail in. Then, they'd deliver a line along the lines of, "Glad to see you dressed up for me," in their characteristic, unimpressed tone—but that intense eye-scan definitely happened, and they aren't fooling anyone.

Pike (N): They would feel incredibly lucky to see the MC in their most casual state. To Pike, this would feel like a huge milestone, a sign that says 'we're close enough for you to be comfortable around me'. They'd give you the sweetest smile and say, "Next time, I'm wearing my comfy clothes too!"

Fox (R): It completely depends on whether they are there for work or not. If they're in work mode, they would stop dead in their tracks for a second, quickly avert their gaze, and immediately force themselves back into professional mode. If they're off the clock, they'd stop in their tracks, look away blushing, and nervously ask if they dropped by at a bad time. Once the MC says, "Don't worry, come in," Fox would remain a bit flustered for a while, but secretly feel happy that the MC trusts them enough to share their most natural, chaotic look.

Cross (S): You might think they wouldn't care, and you might think the MC would try their absolute hardest to never let Cross see them like this. But if it does happen? Cross would look away instantly, flashbacks hitting them of a time long ago when they used to see the MC like this all the time. They would spend the rest of the day completely distracted, wondering why seeing you like that still affects them so much.

 Visual Profile & Styling Notes

Shared Features: Striking, piercing icy blue eyes, rich dark brown hair. High-contrast face that the camera absolutely loves. Peak physical condition.

Carter (M-version): Hair is styled short with a rugged but polished edge. Strong, clean-shaven jawline, broad-shouldered action-star build.

Cora (F-version): Hair falls in loose, elegant waves over her shoulders. Toned, lithe silhouette from intense combat training.

Dakota’s Intel & Personal Remarks

The Persona: Everyone on set calls Sutton a consummate professional—polite, punctual, and cooperative. But don't let the charm fool you. They are highly guarded and watch their public image like a hawk. They know everyone in the industry, yet keep a steel wall around their private life.