#aruani analysis

Armin’s very existence becomes a contradiction Annie cannot ignore. He embodies everything she was forced to abandon—compassion, vulnerability, hope—and yet he continues to live, adapt, and even succeed in ways that shouldn’t be possible.

His presence stirs a tangled storm inside her: resentment for his supposed “weakness,” envy of his courage, and a quiet grief for the humanity she was never allowed to keep.

But beneath all these conflicting emotions lies something far more powerful: curiosity.

For Annie, Armin becomes a direct challenge to her worldview. If he can remain human in a world overrun by monsters and cruelty, then perhaps the humanity she buried deep within herself isn’t as dead as she once believed.

Yet that spark didn’t begin with him. It had already been lit before she ever reached Paradis—when her father’s wholehearted repentance and confession of unconditional love began to stir the long-suppressed longing for connection she had carried her entire life.

So when she approaches Armin, it starts as a cautious investigation—practical, strategic, easy to justify. But the more time she spends near him, the harder it becomes to maintain the emotional distance she has always depended on. Despite every intention to remain detached, Annie finds herself forming a genuine attachment, one she never planned for or meant to allow.

Armin becomes both a reflection of what she had lost and a quiet reminder of the small, fragile pieces she might still be able to keep. In him, she recognises traces of the person she once imagined she could be—kind, courageous, unafraid to hope—and that recognition unsettles her.

He becomes more than just another soldier in her orbit and more than a convenient ally. He becomes someone whose presence lingers with her, someone she finds herself returning to—not out of strategy, but out of something far softer, and far harder to name.

Over time, her bond with Armin exposes the deepest fracture within her—the divide between who she believes herself to be and who she actually is. In her mind, she is still an inherent monster who destroys everything in her wake; Yet beneath that hardened self-image remains the kind, merciful, deeply compassionate young woman she has always been—the one who still longs for connection, and who is still capable of sincere love.

Through Armin, she is forced to confront this buried truth, a reckoning that both terrifies and strengthens her: the realisation that she still has a choice.

She can retreat into the world she was shaped to survive—cold, controlled, and governed by the instincts of kill or be killed—or she can step toward the unknown, risking the fragile peace she clings to for the possibility of something more. Something better. A future richer, gentler, and more human than anything she has ever allowed herself to hope for.

But the freedom of choice never comes without freedom of consequence.

A single act of mercy would expose her darkest secret and, worse, leave her vulnerable to the one terror she fears above all:

Betrayal by the person she had allowed herself to need and trust… and the heartbreak that threatened to crush whatever remained of her as a result.

------------------------------------------------------------

His parents were the first to imprint this inevitability onto his life. They chose to venture beyond the walls without him, deciding he was too small, too fragile. They left him with his ageing grandfather and took off in their hot air balloon — a decision that would cost them their lives and leave Armin behind in more ways than one. ---

In time, even his grandfather leaves him. Drafted in the effort to retake Wall Maria, he dies while Armin — still too young, too weak — remains behind yet again. ---

Regiment training offers no comfort. His body betrays him at every turn, leaving him on the brink of expulsion — a failure that would separate him from Eren and Mikasa, the only family he has left. Every drill, every stumble, every bruise pushes the same truth deeper: No matter how hard he tries, he just can’t keep up ---

Worse still, Armin lets every loss echo back at him as a shadow of some hidden flaw he can’t outrun. Friends die because he isn’t fast enough, strong enough, hardened enough to save them. In his mind, even Eren’s death inevitably twists back toward him — to his hesitation, his inadequacy, his failure to move when the moment demanded everything he didn’t have. ---

The conclusion feels inescapable: Whatever place he hoped for was never meant for someone like him.

He is simply too weak to stand beside the people who matter to him. No matter how desperately he tries to be stronger — fearless, relentless — he always falls short.

Whenever he looks at himself, all he sees is a burden: a useless, miserable weight dragged along out of pity or reluctant obligation. Someone who has never truly belonged, only been endured.

Someone with nothing to offer. Nothing the world wouldn’t toss aside the second he faltered — the moment he stopped fighting to prove he deserved to stay.

Then, suddenly, he’s standing before Annie Leonhart — someone who seems to command the world itself, complete in all the ways he isn’t:

Strength sharpened into skill.

Pragmatism honed into a blade.

Confidence that never wavers.

Independence bordering on untouchable.

Reflexes that strike before thought.

A mind of cold, cutting precision.

And above all: Annie is no bullshitter — a fact Armin feels immediately and almost painfully. She doesn’t defer to rank, doesn’t charm her way through life. She doesn’t chase approval the way he does, nor fear disapproval the way he always has. She moves through the world with an unflinching clarity he can’t begin to imitate — no masks, no excuses, no performances.

To Armin, what you see with Annie is all there is.

Direct. Blunt. Unwavering. A kind of authenticity that hits him harder than any insult ever could. Intimidating not because she tries to be, but because she simply is — everything he isn’t and everything he longs to be.

Throughout training, she sees him at his worst — every failure, every shortcoming, every humiliating reminder of his limits. She witnesses his softness, his sentimentality, his stubborn hope in a world that punishes both.

By all logic, someone like Annie — someone operating so far beyond him — should want nothing to do with him.

Yet she does.

She notices him. She approaches him. And she keeps coming back.

At first, she carries the same cold, unyielding certainty she brings to every interaction — decisive, precise, impossible to refuse. But the more she returns, the more Armin begins to catch the smallest fractures in her composure:

A pause she shouldn’t need.

A breath drawn a fraction too slow.

A moment of hesitation before she steps closer anyway.

She tries to hide it, but he sees it — the flicker beneath the armour. The part of her that shouldn’t exist, not in someone like Annie.

A softness he never imagined she possessed. A tenderness she begins revealing only to him.

Both make something twist hot and sharp in his chest — an emotion he mistakes for fear, because anything else feels too dangerous to name.

What unsettles him most isn’t simply that she approaches him, or that someone like Annie could contain any softness at all. It’s that this softness — her softness — is directed at him, and it threatens the one strategy he’s relied on his entire life to survive the world’s cruelty:

Armin must abandon himself to survive.

It is a twisted kind of protection — but if he lets go of himself before anyone else does, then the pain of their eventual abandonment might hurt a little less.

For Armin, keeping a safe distance isn’t caution; it’s survival. It’s the only way to stay in control.

To stay safe. Safe from the world’s unpredictability, its cruelty, its inconsistency — its monstrosity. If the inevitable blade of betrayal is destined to pierce his heart, then he will be the one to wield it.

So when Annie starts closing the distance between them of her own accord, something in him knots tight — sharp, instinctive, violently inward.

Because the moment she steps toward him, she forces him into unfamiliar, dangerous territory: a world where he cannot stay small, cannot stay hidden, cannot preempt the hurt by discarding himself first.

He wants to push her away — for her sake, for his own, for the fragile walls he’s clung to his entire life. Because the walls hide an indescribable pressure, a pressure that keeps building, coiling tighter and tighter, until it suddenly erupts from somewhere deep within, startling him with its force.

An anger so deep, so cold, so relentless, that he had bottled it inside himself for so long it turned inward, carving him hollow from the inside out. A directionless, mournful fury — aimed at nothing and everything at once:

At her for coming closer. At himself, for wanting her to. At the world, for convincing him that wanting anything is dangerous.

And he doesn't know what to do with any of it. Inside him coils a fire he’s certain will rise up and devour him — a furious, consuming blaze that has spent years smouldering in the hollow spaces of his chest.

Every step she takes toward him threatens to ignite it fully, to burn through whatever fragile composure he has left.

And yet —

He can’t let her go.

Because even as the flames roar higher—searing, unruly, far too fierce for any human heart to contain, fed by bitterness and the lies he crafted just to keep breathing, by the grief of being left behind again and again—something else stirs within the wreckage.

Something impossibly delicate.

Something warm in a way that doesn’t burn, but glows.

Something that feels less like fire and more like life itself, rising stubbornly through the ashes he thought would swallow him whole.

Hope.

A quiet, treacherous spark of hope that only Annie seems capable of igniting inside of him. He doesn’t understand why it’s her — why the very person who unsettles him, disarms him, frustrates him is also the one who steadies the burning inside him just long enough for something new to rise.

And still, impossibly, he reaches for her.

For someone so naturally adept at reading others — at dissecting intentions, peeling back façades, seeing the truths people try to bury— Annie Leonhart remains the one person he cannot decipher.

Her decision to seek him out — out of anyone and everyone — whether in public or in the stolen, silent moments between training sessions, defies every explanation he can conjure.

She shouldn’t look at him. Shouldn’t speak to him. Shouldn’t choose him, of all people.

Yet she does.

And worse — beneath all that steel, beneath even the softness she’s slowly revealed over time — he keeps catching glimpses of something more, something he has no language for.

A tender tone woven into her voice.

A quiet, almost wistful gaze that lingers when she thinks he won’t notice.

A gentleness so fleeting he sometimes wonders if he imagined it.

Against all reason, Annie Leonhart lets that softness exist for him in a way she does for no one else.

She offers him slivers of something warmer, deeper — something that feels dangerously close to affection — and she does it with the same reluctant inevitability as breathing.

And if he can’t understand it — if he can’t understand her — he fears it will undo him entirely.

------------------------

He doesn’t know when his confusion and frustration toward her begin to shift — when the sharpness of it all starts dissolving into something softer, something with weight.

But the more he lingers near her, the more that bewilderment eases — giving way to an unspoken, undeniable pull he never expected to feel.

Her contradictions, once a constant source of irritation, begin to feel intentional rather than evasive — as though she’s offering him pieces of herself in the only way she knows how: slowly, cautiously, deliberately.

And with each glimpse, Armin realises she is far more complex than he ever allowed himself to imagine — not just sharp edges and guarded silence, but layers he never saw coming, layers she reveals only to him.

What once left him unsteady now draws him in. Curiosity settles into something heavier, something warmer — a pull he can neither name nor resist.

He finds himself seeking her out, again and again, terrified of missing something she might reveal without meaning to.

Because Annie listens to him — truly listens. She weighs his words, considers his advice, and offers her own without condescension or dismissal. She respects the way his mind works, challenges him when it matters, and never treats his emotions as weaknesses to be corrected.

And he gravitates toward that attention — toward the quiet, startling comfort of being understood without needing to explain or excuse himself at all.

Her presence carries a calm that slips beneath his guard before he even notices, settling into him as though it’s always belonged there.

But threaded through that calm is something else — sheer, unbridled terror.

He’s spent so long being careful, limiting how much of himself he lets anyone see — least of all Annie.

What began as awkward but polite exchanges slowly, almost imperceptibly, softened into something gentler. Something more relaxed, more familiar… and, without him realising it until far too late, undeniably more intimate.

And now he’s here, balanced on a threshold he can’t quite step back from — a quiet, unmistakable crossroads that feels as if crossing it would change the shape of his life forever.

For the first time, there is an undeniable choice that he has full control over making:

He can retreat — pull himself back into the safety of distance, into the comfort of pretending he doesn’t need or feel anything. It would be easy, familiar, the kind of self-preservation he’s trained himself into for years.

Or, he can step forward — into the terrifying possibility that she might feel something and need him, too. Into the risk of being seen, truly seen, in a way he’s never trusted himself to allow.

The thought alone sends his pulse stumbling, because he knows what he wants — knows it with a clarity that unsettles him far more than the uncertainty ever did. That wanting, that decision forming in his chest, feels like stepping to the edge of a precipice, breath suspended somewhere between hope and ruin.

But eventually, he chooses. He chooses her.

He chooses to let her see him — the awkward parts, the uncomfortable truths, the fragile edges he’s never allowed anyone to touch. And instead of recoiling, she stays.

The space between them narrows, first in quiet, nearly imperceptible shifts, then with a steadiness that feels inevitable… and with every small, deliberate step she takes toward him, something inside him begins to unfurl, quietly and irrevocably.

Letting her in doesn’t hollow him out or consume him as he once feared.

It awakens something he’d long believed had gone dormant — something warm and steady, something profoundly, unmistakably alive.

--------------------------

Somewhere in that unexpected warmth, Annie becomes his mirror — one he never asked for, never expected, but somehow desperately needed. She reflects him with a steadiness he doesn’t know how to meet, casting light onto the parts of himself he spent years trying not to see.

She refuses to reflect him as the hollow, pitiful shadow he’s always feared he might be. Instead, through her gaze — quiet, deliberate, impossibly discerning — Armin begins to see something more than the flaws he obsesses over or the pieces he once tried to bury.

He begins to see the full, intricate spectrum of his own humanity.

Annie’s presence forces him to confront a truth he has avoided for far too long: the world can be cruel and hateful and unbearably unforgiving, yes — but it is also still good. Still capable of gentleness. Still capable of love, of compassion, of beauty. It is a world with inherent worth, one still worth living in and fighting for.

And somehow — impossibly — Armin starts to realise that this worth, this fragile but fiercely persistent goodness, extends to him as well. That his own humanity is not a weakness to hide or amputate from himself, but something that matters. Something that deserves to exist.

And this — this rediscovered humanity, this terrifying, luminous truth Annie coaxes him toward — becomes both his greatest strength and his greatest vulnerability.

Not just because of how clearly she sees him — but because of how deeply he wants her to keep seeing him. To peel back every distorted belief he has ever held about himself, to steady the places inside him he’s always feared were irreparably broken.

This fragile sense of hope — this trembling, hard-won feeling of belonging she draws out of him — becomes the first thing in his life that feels real. Solid. His.

Annie becomes the anchor of peace he tethers himself to, the quiet centre of gravity he trusts when everything else around him feels volatile, uncertain, impossible.

With her, he begins to believe he is not simply changing, but uncovering the person he was always meant to be — someone worthy, someone whole.

For the first time, the world doesn’t feel like something he must endure just to survive; it feels like something he might actually belong in, just as himself.

But that same trust — the trust that steadied him, that coaxed him back into the light, that taught him how to breathe without bracing for the next blow — is exactly what destroys him when the truth of her betrayal finally pierces through.

It doesn’t just hurt. It annihilates.

Because in the instant he understands what she’s done, something in him gives way — quietly, catastrophically — as if the very foundation he rebuilt himself on has been yanked out from beneath him. The girl who taught him to hope becomes the proof that hope is a cruelty he should have never dared to touch.

And all the warmth she rekindled inside him doesn’t fade; it implodes, collapsing into a hollow ache that spreads through him like a slow, merciless winter.

To Armin, her betrayal is not merely the breaking of trust.

It is the shattering of the one place he allowed himself to be unguarded — the single fragile corner of his soul where he dared to believe he might be seen and not discarded like everyone else who ever chose to leave him. The sheltered space inside him that he had never let anyone else touch.

Because it wasn’t just trust he offered her — it was faith. Quiet, cautious, desperate faith that she was who he believed she was, who he needed her to be. A faith he had never afforded himself, let alone another person.

And in the end, it is that faith — fragile, precious, all-consuming — that betrays him most.

And from that belief grows a terrifying conviction — slow, cold, merciless in its clarity: that to survive what comes next, he cannot simply harden himself against her.

He must strip away the parts of himself she awakened. He must smother the hope she stirred. He must abandon himself entirely.

Because in the ruins she left behind, Armin understands something with unbearable finality: what she gave him — that warmth, that gentleness, that impossible sense of belonging — was never meant for someone like him.

And if the world is so quick to tear away anything soft he dares to hold, then it leaves him no mercy, no alternatives. Survival demands a sacrifice — not of blood, but of the very pieces of himself that let the loss cut so deeply. The parts that hesitate. The parts that feel. The parts that make him vulnerable enough to break.

So he turns back to the only defence he ever knew — sealing himself away, forsaking himself all over again.

Only this time, he does it with a certainty as bleak and absolute as the world that taught it to him…, burying whatever remains before it can be torn from him again.

Cold resolve settles into the hollow of his heart where the warmth of hope once stirred. And in that quiet, merciless hollow, something inside him falls silent — numb, emptied — with only the faintest, ghostlike ache for what he almost had lingering at the edges of what’s left...

-------------------------------------------------------------