I’ve been thinking about the structure of classical Christian antiJudaism lately and how dependent it is on Plato’s framework of the Realm of Forms. The Christians who view this physical world only as a means to get to the true world of the afterlife are spiritually enlightened, while the Jews who are concerned with living well in this world for the sake of this world and not the world to come, are considered base, materialistic, and animalistic.
I think there’s a parallel to be made here about antizionism. To the antizionist, the philosophical framework is not a means to an end, but the end itself; it’s all that matters. The Jews squabbling about the petty facts of the situation are demonstrating that they haven’t transcended to the Realm of Forms. It doesn’t matter what Israel does, it matters what it represents; the actual acts of the IDF and the Knesset are shadows of the True Forms of Imperialism, Colonialism, Racism, Apartheid, and Genocide, on the cave wall.
Every time I read antizionist writing, it feels like we’re talking about completely different things. Of course they don’t have a practical answer for the difficult material questions; that’s not what they’re arguing for. They’re arguing exclusively on the metaphysical plane, knowing that their soul (or at least their social status) has been made pure and righteous by the revelation of this great knowledge. To them, Israelis and Palestinians are shadows of Evil and Good, not real people making difficult decisions in impossible situations.














