hi :) first of all thank you for scanlating wisc, it's looking really interesting so far! I'll definitely keep reading it. but also I randomly want to whine to you about something. there's this manhwa called freezing point and I want to read it so bad but it's not translated. I've been learning korean for the past two years and I can read enough of it to get me super interested but not enough to be able to read it freely and it's so frustrating! I have to look up so many words while reading. 1/2
2/2 I hope to soon be at a level where I can read it without having to figure out every sentence and where I get all the nuance in the dialogue. I'm thinking I might try my hand at scanlating too if I ever get there. I'd love to scanlate freezing point. anyway this was super random but I thought you might get my pain :D
I originally wanted to learn Japanese as a kid to read my Japanese Pokemon cards, but my mom thought that was a stupid idea, so I didnāt get back around to it until the start of college, and even then, it was so I could read manga before it received an official English translation. I was impatient, lol. I used to be embarrassed to admit thatās why I wanted to learn Japanese, but whatever.Ā
I started out translating manga because I was getting impatient for Acid Town updates and people used to post raws sometimes on the MangaFox forums. It was just practice at first and I only ended up taking over after the previous scanlator got hit with a DMCA. I think translating manga when youāre not yet fluent can be very stressful but fun.Ā
The part I enjoy most about translating is thatĀ āsolving a puzzleā feeling of trying to figure out how all the parts of the sentence work together, and then the best equivalent for that in English. An exciting part of learning Japanese is when you eventually get to the part where some things just makeĀ āsenseā even if you canāt explain it. Like if a sentence sounds wrong, you know itās wrong, but might struggle to explain why. Or you understand the feeling or intention behind a sentence but canāt explain it in English. Iāve translated enough manga now that when I see a sound effect I understand the sort of sound thatās meant to evoke in Japanese, but itās always an enormous struggle to convey in English.Ā
I think the more challenging part of doing scanlations when youāre not yet fluent is you feel a lot of pressure to do everything right. You feel the weight of knowing that whatever you put out there is what people are going to believe and how theyāre going to understand the story, so you really donāt want to mess up. Mistakes can happen even for professionals, of course, so itās not a huge deal. But I still stress over it a lot and will try to reach out for help from native Japanese speakers if thereās something Iām truly, terribly stuck on.
I managed to pass the JLPT N3 with decent scores, but I donāt want it to seem like Iām in any way fluent. When I do translations itās with a complicated set-up of the raws, the document Iām writing the English script in, a browser opened to Jisho.org, a browser opened to Google Translate (for when Iām REALLY stuck), and the Google Translate app open on my phone (for looking up kanji without furigana). I think some people call thisĀ āmachine translationā because Iām leaning on the dictionary for unfamiliar words or phrases, but Iām still mostly using my knowledge of Japanese to translate, and you wouldnāt necessarily get the same results if you were to just run the Japanese through Google Translate. Iām at the point where I can turn around a chapter a lot faster than I used to because I can just read and understand without having to constantly pause to look up everything. In a way it feels like I magically got to this point, but I also know that behind that is countless hours of studying kanji. :\Ā
Iām rambling a lot but what I want to actually say is that if you have an interest in understanding manga in another language and want to practice your language comprehension by translating, definitely go for it! Itās going to feel really tedious and slow and difficult but itās worth it. Find a series youāre really interested in and passionate about to keep you motivated. Keep a log of words you looked up so you can make flashcards of them later. Make mental notes about how the word was used. If you know native speakers who can correct your entire translations thatās the ultimate bonus, but Iāve never had that luxury, haha. If youāre feeling really frustrated at your pace you can also try looking for something easier to translate, like something aimed more towards children or general audiences that has easier language. This is kind of a gamble in Japanese because stuff aimed towards little children doesnāt have kanji, and if you donāt know the words and how to discern the breaks between them, all youāre looking at is an endless string of hiragana vomit, lol. Like in Japanese youād want something with kanji but with the furigana at least. I found the Kingdom Hearts manga series really easy to read, for instance. It might not be as interesting as a series meant for adults but if youāre really struggling it might be worth that stepping stone.