#amateurmagic

If Hawkfrost never trapped Firestar by the lake and was killed by Bramble, what would he do? Would he attempt to kill Mistyfoot for deputyship? But def make it look like an accident. I feel like he's equally following Tigerstar's path but hopefully gonna be a bit smarter about it - part of me def thinks that he doesn't know what he actually wants. He essentially gets to RC, gets his warrior name, and then somehow gets obsessed with power and then dies before he accomplishes anything. If he lives longer, does he get exposed as part of Mudclaw's coup that tried to overthrow WC? Does he force himself to simmer down and play along in RC, waiting for his chance, but figures out his own happiness?

tldr; I'm gonna kill Bramble bc he doesn't become deputy (and also always bored me), but then wtf do I do with Hawkfrost? He just seemed like a huge missed opportunity so idk what to do with him

This is such a fun ask, I've been sitting on it until I had time to give a good answer!

So much of this does depend on the details of your AU and where exactly you want the story to end, and if you want Hawkfrost to be your big villain (if you even want a big villain). Your big three concerns are: Mistyfoot, Mudclaw, ThunderClan.

I would say yes, he tries to replace Mistyfoot, but your main problem there is that Hawkfrost never canonically mentors an apprentice. So! Even if he kills Mistyfoot in this AU, he still would have to mentor an apprentice to become deputy (I would say one of Dawnflower's kits: Minnowtail, Pebblefoot, or Tumblekit). After he's successfully mentored an apprentice, he would aim for deputy.

Does he kill Mistyfoot? I like the idea that Hawkfrost, much like Brokenstar, uses his words to get what he wants. When he thought Stormfur had too much influence in RiverClan, he turned the entire Clan against him and Brook and chased them out. Personally, I think it's more interesting if he tries to do the same thing with Mistyfoot. There are a lot of points he could bring up against her: she's half-Clan, she still holds a grudge after TigerClan, she talks back to Leopardstar a little too freely; he could convince the Clan she's going to be inspired by Mudclaw's coup and try to do the same thing with ThunderClan to overthrow Leopardstar. If he consistently brings up her ties to ThunderClan and her fractured relationship with Leopardstar, it could gain traction.

Re: Mudclaw, is it a secret that Hawkfrost worked with him? I don't think so? Because it was known that RiverClan warriors were helping him, and I do distinctly remember that Hawkfrost made this big deal about the tree killing Mudclaw and how it was a sign from StarClan, so I think everyone knows they worked together. My point is, I think this is a non-issue. By Sunset, no one is talking about it anymore.

Re: ThunderClan, if Brambleclaw is dead then I don't see Hawkfrost being too interested in ThunderClan. Tigerstar, however, is never letting go of his Firestar vendetta, so I would think he would want Hawkfrost to "avenge" Brambleclaw (probably by killing Firestar lmao). How he goes about doing so is up to you.

Again, how you use Hawkfrost depends entirely on the context of your AU and who the main characters are. I could make a case that Hawkfrost dies some other way, but I could also make a case that he successfully rises to power in RiverClan. It's whatever best serves your AU!

If Hawkfrost were never involved in the foxtrap mess, then my personal opinion is that he would have played the long game in RiverClan: mentor an apprentice, either chase out or frame Mistyfoot of a crime, become deputy, and then either wait for Leopardstar to die or kill her. I'm of the opinion that without Brambleclaw to manipulate in ThunderClan, Tigerstar would let Hawkfrost gain some influence/power in RiverClan before striking again. Once Hawkfrost is leader, then Tigerstar would resume turning him against Firestar. Eventually, Hawkfrost would be able to start a war with ThunderClan if he did indeed listen to his dad.

Hello, thank you for requesting! I’ll write this as headcanons :)

REQUESTS ARE OPEN!!

Alphonse and Winry:

You and Alphonse had been dating for quite a while

And you were pretty happy together

Because you liked each other a lot and understood the other

Also, you were best friends and had lots of fun together

You already knew Edward since he would often hang out with Al

Other than him, you know Al doesn’t really have more family

Except for Winry and Pinako, of course

One day you went to Resenbool to check on Ed’s automails

And they invited you to come along to meet their family

You were a little nervous, but were excited

They had told you a lot about Winry, they were really close to her

So you knew how she was, more or less

When you finally met them, they were a little different than you thought

But just as friendly and kind as you had imagined

Winry was extremely extroverted towards you

“The boys have told me about you! Al won’t stop gushing about how great you are!”

With just one sentence, she manages to embarass the three of you

But you find it heartwarming that they told her about you

She treated you almost like she had known you all her life

But you liked that, it made it easier to get along

And helped you with being not as shy

Winry began rambling about how Ed doesn’t take care of his automail

And told you how they worked and how intricate and cool they were

That helped you talk more too, commenting about the boys

Basically, you got along almost immediately

And found that you had some things in common

So you started talking more and more

It helped that she was so warm and extroverted

Always breaking the ice, linking her arm with yours and such

Also gossiping a bit, which just made you laugh

Alphonse was super happy that you got along with her so quickly

Ooh interesting one, thanks!

1. He’s Jewish

2. I once saw the headcanon that his hair is actually curly but he straightens it every morning so he can look emo and I 1000% agree

3. PAN-ACE NATH??? PAN-ACE NATH

4. He’s a hopeless dork who’s had a crush on every single kid in his class at some point

14. Dancing headcanon

Mike can only slow dance. He’d be painfully bad at anything "modern” and he’s too shy to try it. He’s pretty good at slower dances with a partner he’s super comfortable with (and that has only been his mother lmao).

(@trash-god and I have a ballet AU but outside of a Special Circumstance like that, Mike’s just not the kind of guy to feel good about dancing publicly unless it’s simple.)

Nanaba can’t dance at all and has never tried. With friends she might kind of joke around about it, be a tiny bit playful, but she’d never have the courage to just throw herself out there and actually try anything, especially in a modern AU. :/ (She’d never, ever yank Mike out of his comfort zone, either.)

Thank-you! I hope you’re having a great summer as well. (: I’m going to do headcanons for these since they are always a bit easier. :P

Ever since he inherited the Colossal Titan ability from Bertholdt, Armin knew that he had an expiration date on his life. Thirteen years was nothing, but there was no guarantee that he’d even survive for that long during the war. 

Eventually, he is given permission to rest after countless years of fighting and fighting and fighting with what felt like little to no gain. Death doesn’t scare Armin. There are so many things that he wanted to do and see, but knowing that he contributed to saving the Paradis people--knowing that he got to see the ocean beside his friends--is enough for him. 

Armin’s grandfather  is visibility upset when he realizes how young and worn his grandson appears, but that doesn’t stop him from pulling him into a tight, warm embrace. 

“I’m so proud of you. You were so brave,” he’d tell Armin over and over again. Despite everything, his grandfather had always been watching over him every step of the way. 

Off in the distance, Armin can see the silhouettes of his parents. Despite having vague memories of them, their reunion is joy-filled and happy. Excitedly, Armin would tell them that the outside world had been real, waiting to be explored by someone who could document it all. 

Kenny Ackerman!

I haven’t answered this before but it’s something I’m curious about as well. Some people I know have put a great deal of thought into this. Maybe they’ll chime in if I get something wrong. (I’m looking specifically at @julystorms @bossard and @hamburger--time.)

The only location I can think of that’s been specifically identified is this one:

Since it’s called “Trost District Branch”, it’s likely they have Branches in each district. This might be for communication purposes. Since messages are sent by horse and rider, having a small contingency of soldiers in each district would be like the pony express.

They should have a headquarters. We know of their former one, but I’m not sure I’ve seen mention of their present one. The whole purpose of the Survey Corps was to travel outside the walls, it makes sense to me that their original headquarters was close to Shiganshina since that was their exit point on expeditions.

Now maybe they are headquartered close to Karanese District since that was their exit point once the gate at Trost was sealed.

DISCLAIMER: This is my personal opinion. In no way am I stating what I say here is canon or completely accurate. if you disagree with my opinion, that’s perfectly fine! Everyone has a different point of view, but if you are going to send me messages trying to argue points of view with me or send me hate messages, do me a favor and please just don’t even bother.