Something Has Gone Horribly Wrong: Dawnlight Theory
So far we have very little knowledge on what the plan pre-DL Rythian had. All we know/can easily infer is that it is to try and stop the âendfallâ, but what has become abundantly clear is that something has gone horribly wrong.Â
Rythianâs tattoos existence and insistence on finding the journal make clear that either as part of the plan or as a known side effect, DL Rythian would lose his memory. What is most striking about this to me is that *he couldnât read them* (unless there is some big twist later on about him hiding how much he knows).Â
If you are physically tattooing instructions on someoneâs body so that regardless of what happens, they have access to them, you would obviously choose a language they know.
With Rythian nearly getting himself killed in chapter 2, you would think if pre-DL Rythian understood just how vulnerable he was going to be, that more precautions would be taken, and maybe they were but something went wrong. Maybe the egg wasnât supposed to crash, maybe something went wrong when he received whatever power has led to the change in eye/hair color, maybe something else entirely.Â
Again and again in Dawnlight we see that Rythian remembers basically none of the knowledge of his past life, only really maintaining some muscle memory and a strong sense of intuition (with his description of every feat of âknowledgeâ being that âit felt rightâ). He felt that the darkstalkers are dangerous and shouldnât be in the nether. It felt right that the flame he can produce would be able to light the portal, etc. If they knew that this was going to be the case, his tattoos wouldn't have been in a language he can't remember (they could have been in a more normal code that takes time to crack so only the person with the tattoos has access to the code for long enough to crack it or something).
Furthermore, the logs for the black box are scattered and potentially damaged. The homing on the blackbox makes sense, but either you trust that whoever has it is who is supposed to and you put the logs in one stash or you don't. Scattering them separately strikes me as unusual. It is possible that they were scattered in the crash, and in that case, how log 24 ended up in a cave is concerning for the safety of the main trio.
With these things in mind, whatever plan was made either was extremely rushed and all of this is a consequence of that, or something has gone horribly wrong. If you put safeguards in place to guide a version of yourself through a plan and 1) they can't protect themselves and are thrown into a dangerous world with know skills/clothing and needs to trek across it to find any information, putting them in grave danger, and 2) they can't even read the instructions you gave them, then clearly something happened between making the plan and when that version of yourself wakes up. I don't know what the plan was or why Rythian has lost his memory (or if it has anything to do with why Zoey lost hers in the destruction of the old world), but it being this bad was clearly not expected.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Initial Thoughts/Theories on Dawnlight Rythian's Tattoos
Although most of the message is/feels pretty straight forward, with how the possibility of mistranslations is treated, there is certainly some things that we donât know right now (but just how many important mistranslations is unknown). Thoughts under the cut:
âStyx washâ and âup the Styx againâ - both sentences feel like idioms (and therefore donât immediately stick out to me as important on their own) but both of them using âstyxâ is really interesting both because the river Styx is obviously from real world mythology and because the repetition draws attention to this choice. Because of this, it is a strong candidate for an important mistranslation but without more information as to if it is possibly a name or a real location (or a reference that Rythian would understand with his memories like a code word) will stay unknown until we get more information. Also the phrase âStyx againâ is really interesting and likely refers to something that happened between Blackrock and dawnlight (if dawnlight is canon which it probably isnât). Regardless, the usage of âagainâ almost certainly refers to something specific.
The âJournalâ - As far as can be seen with Rythianâs inventory/the books available through the akashic tome, Rythian does not have a physical journal (although with the retcon inclusion of enderbade/a still standing prequel house in Blackrock and the secrecy of Rythian about the flame in dawnlight chapter 2, that doesnât rule out a physical book). A journal is a record of knowledge which could be referring to his other (untranslated) tattoos. Although you can obviously be given someone elseâs journal, the use of that word specifically could also imply that whatever form it takes, it was written by Rythian before losing his memories. With the importance of journals in Blackrock (the canon gametee journals, Rythianâs season 3 journal, and Zoey keeping a journal in season 2) also feels relevant here. Either if dawnlight is canon/canon adjacent or if the journal was written by Rythian/Zoey and it is a continuation of their character habit of keeping journals.Â
âThe chantâ - This was the first thing that I felt confident about assuming there is any meaningful crossover with canon lore (not that dawnlight is canon, but if knowledge from canon magic can be applied). The chant instantly reminded me of the âhealing Wordâ (capitalization in the original) that Rythian wrote about using to save Zoey after the end of Blackrock season 2. Spoken magic/spells of that kind is a system that wasnât really elaborated on with the series being cut short, so this could be a chance to use interesting lore elements that never got their time to shine. Alternatively (and more likely if no canon knowledge can be used) is that âthe chantâ is referring to the rest of Rythianâs tattoos or possibly the plan in general.
âDead-bookâ - This immediately reminded me of Saint Peterâs book of names and the sentence being a way to say âif he hasnât died alreadyâ, but 1) I donât think they are trying to make Christianity canon, and 2) it feels like a weird sentiment to use in the limited space of *tattooing something on someone*. The exception to this is if the text was written by Zoey, and then a less-than-efficient message is to be expected. My second thought is that it has something to do with the necronomicon (or equivalent book). This tracks with Zoeyâs Gideon the 9th/skeleton inspired skin, so it fits thematically with future elements of the series. It is unclear if âgoing toâ the book would still mean dying, being jumanji-d, some sort of backup plan, some side project/distraction, or something else entirely. (unless we are going full evangelion and the dead book is the dead sea scrolls in this cristian minecraft server lmao)
âThe scholarâ - perhaps the most discussed bit since chapter 2 dropped, I am not confident in any prediction ideas that I have had so far. It initially surprised me that âscholarâ wasnât capitalized with how it is used which indicates that it is more likely âsomeone involved in the planâ than someone with cosmic/political/innately magical importance. Most of the characters most heavily associated with death (and therefore most likely to be involved with whatever the âdead-bookâ) are women. So unless one of the translation errors is âheâ instead of âsheâ, that really limits the options as far as theorizing with 0 information goes (and although I would usually call this kind of mistranslation in a series without prominent gender themes (and it would be too early to tell on that front anyways) somewhat of a cop out, because there arenât a lot of pre-existing female characters in the canon, I could understand wanting to keep it from being too obvious from the jump). ANYWAYS my crack theory idea is that it is Lalnable. Is it likely? Hell no, but âdoctorâ being mistranslated to âscholarâ makes sense, and a connection with the âdead-bookâ would also track. I am NOT up to date on my Lalnable lore so that makes this idea additionally cursed (istg if âscholarâ is a mistranslation of âdoctorâ but referencing the doctor who themed episode of blackrock /lh)
âWhat happensâ - it is way too early to know for sure but this could mean âwhat happens if they figure out who you areâ or âwhat happens if they figure out the planâ or âwhat happens when you achieve x goal or use magic or die etc etc etcâ. But there is definitely some information being hidden in the missing/mistranslated words there.
âPilgrimage to the crematoriumâ - what at first seems to be an idiom for âthey will kill youâ draws attention to itself with Briony using âpilgrimageâ to describe what she is doing. With scripted lore chapters, and especially with both uses being in the same chapter, this is almost certainly intentional. It doesnât mean they have to refer to the same thing, and I bet they donât, but the double usage of the word makes me thing that this is more than just a warning. The crematorium could be a reference to the nether (with both of them being a place of fire/burning), and especially with the Styx references, the nether as an underworld would make sense. Again if dawnlight is canon/canon adjacent, I am unsure what the nether has to do with the pla, but since the plan seems to have some cross-realm shenanigans going on, it doesnât feel like a stretch to include it.Â
âThe dark of the matterâ - feels unnecessarily wordy in a way that feels like there is concealed meaning. With the saying usually being âshed light on the situationâ there is no word to be mistranslated as âdarkâ, implying an additional word/phrase in the original. My instinct is to think it has something to do with the End, shadows, etc, I do not immediately have any specific ideas as to what this could be - especially in a word or two. With that in mind, this is another candidate for the original word being some reference that Rythian would understand the broader meaning too rather than the answer being directly in the missing words. It seems that they knew Rythian would be going through it at this point, but maybe not that he would have lost his memory (either at all, this much, or that he wouldnât have regained it by the time he read the tattoos), so having some things be implied instead of explicit makes sense even if it isnât working out due to the amnesia right now.